Showing posts with label Power of Myth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Power of Myth. Show all posts

Saturday, September 28, 2013

"Religion without God" ... ?

Legal scholar/philosopher
Ronald Dworkin
That's the title of a book by the late teacher of jurisprudence and legal philosopher Ronald Dworkin, as discussed in a recent New York Times column, "Deeper Than God: Ronald Dworkin’s Religious Atheism," by Stanley Fish. Dworkin believed, says Fish, in "an underlying or overarching set of values in relation to which legal particulars are intelligible and have meaning." But he did not believe in a personal God who is "the source and definition of all that is good and true."

According to his own words, Dworkin believed that "inherent, objective value permeates everything, that the universe and its creatures are awe-inspiring, that human life has purpose and the universe order." Yet the “felt conviction that the universe really does embody a sublime beauty" was not the same for Dworkin as a need to affirm that the sublimity of the world requires a divine being to create it. Dworkin was a practitioner of "religious atheism."

With respect to how we as humans might react to the world's sublime beauty, Fish writes:

One form of acknowledgment might be the practice of theism — traditional religion with its rituals, sacred texts, formal prayers, proscribed and prescribed activities; but the conviction of the universe’s beauty does not, says Dworkin, “suppose any god” as its ground. Once we see this, we are on the way to “decoupling religion from a god” and admitting into the ranks of the religious those who are possessed by that conviction but do not trace it back to any deity. They will be, Dworkin declares, “religious atheists.”

“Decoupling religion from a god” is a notion I, as a Catholic, both do and don't understand. The part of me that doesn't understand the idea feels that the idea of "all that is good and true" necessarily resides in the same human brain cell as the idea of "God." The two are inseparable. If humans build on that notional dyad an elaborate theology, as the Catholic Church does, then dissenting humans are also able today to set that theology aside. Many do. Even if they do, though, it does not make any difference to the essential notional dyad. "God," by common definition, equals the fundamental source of "all that is good and true."

The part of me that does in fact understand Dworkin's decoupling notion now says, "Whoa!" There are clearly precedents for "decoupling religion from a god." One of these is Buddhism, which at least in its classical forms makes no mention of divinity. Another is the thought of the late myth-explainer Joseph Campbell, who has it that what we call "God" is but a mask of eternity, a metaphor for the utter incomprehensibility of the ground of all being.

Furthermore, "admitting into the ranks of the religious those who are possessed by that conviction [i.e., of sublime beauty, moral order, human purpose in the universe] but do not trace it back to any deity" is basically what I find myself longing for. I have urged, in this blog, that we today need to seek a "new awakening" of spirituality to thwart the descent into selfishness, sensuality, and violence that our culture seems to be beckoning us toward. In that regard, "religious atheists" à la Ronald Dworkin ought to be considered entirely welcome allies to Catholics and all other theists.



Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Jungian Web Links

In recent weeks, in overlapping topics whose labels appear at the bottom of this post, I've been blogging about the psyche as mapped by Carl Jung, the Swiss psychologist who died in 1961. Through reading several books which I've mentioned in these posts, I have become convinced that Jung's insights speak volumes about our human capacity for spirituality — including my own Christian and Roman Catholic spirituality.

This post contains links to valuable information I've found on the Web concerning Jung's ideas.

The first link is to a lengthy but extremely readable article on "The Organization Leader as King, Warrior, Magician and Lover: How Jungian Archetypes Affect the Way Men Lead Organizations." This article, in addition to describing various organizational leadership styles in terms of Jungian archetypes, is a good introduction to the idea of archetypes in general:

Archetypes, in Jung's thought, are as basic as, and very similar to, instincts. They are power centers that are "hard-wired" into the psyche of every human being, whether male or female, that largely control, or at least provide channels for, our thought, speech and behavior ...

The purpose of this essay is to enlighten and empower male leaders and their male and female coworkers by describing how the positive and negative aspects of the King, Warrior, Magician, and Lover archetypes influence male behavior, the way men lead, and the way they follow leadership.


The second link is to the Symbol Watcher website, dedicated to "the search for meaning in cultural, artistic and dream imagery." A tasty appetizer for the smorgasbord of this site is the short, succinct "The Projection of Sarah Palin," which tells how the country has projected the archetype of the Great Mother upon the governor of Alaska, who has been tapped as the Republican nominee for vice president:

... the Great Mother is at once container, cherisher and guardian of life, as well as ruler, possessive controller/destroyer and seductress. ... we seem to have thrust some — if not all — of the Great Mother’s expansive powers onto Gov. Palin.


To me, the very fact that almost no one is neutral about Palin is indicative of the strength with which we are archetypally projecting an image onto her — whether or not we like the image! One of the advantages of a Jungian approach to understanding ourselves is that it allows us to step back and know that we are projecting. Giving full rein to our subjectivity and irrationality, then looking at it through Jungian eyes, can be the first step in reclaiming our reason and our objectivity.

My Roman Catholic faith calls me to be rational. The Church teaches the fundamental rationality of God above. Yet, paradoxically, for us the way to rationality can be through the chaos of the unconscious and its archetypal wisdom. Jungian Web links such as these may serve seekers as guideposts through the chaos and beacon lamps in the darkness.

Saturday, August 23, 2008

Quest for the Self, Part 1

At the bottom of this post there are a number of labels. If you click on any one of them, you'll see a list of earlier posts I've made. In many cases, the same posts show up in more than one list. That's because they all revolve around the thought of the late Swiss psychologist Carl Gustav Jung.

Jung mapped the depths of the human psyche. Among the things he found buried there, according to Murray Stein in his book Jung's Map of the Soul: An Introduction, are a "plurality of unconscious images and fantasies" (p. 153).

One of these images, or as Jung called them, "archetypes," depicts from the perspective of any male of our species an idealized bearer of humankind's feminine qualities: the perfect woman, so to speak. This female-ideal is the Anima (see Addressing the Anima). Jung's own Anima, once he had addressed it sufficiently and at great length — a process that took several years — led Jung to a interior experience of an even deeper archetype: the Self.

Stein calls the Self the "most fundamental feature of [Jung's] theory" of the human soul, as well as its "capstone" (p. 151). But the Self is even harder to describe than the Anima (or, in women, the Animus, an image of the masculine ideal which likewise serves its female possessor as a "spirit guide" to the Self).


The Self is, in fact, exquisitely hard to talk about precisely. Specifically because of what Jung called the Self's "transcendence," every correct statement that can be made about the Self is to some extent inadequate to conveying the Self's full truth in its entirety. (Stein, by the way, does not capitalize terms like "Self"; I usually do because I think it makes the discussion clearer.)

"Transcendence" is a term of convenience Jung used to suggest a realm of thought and experience past all opposites, beyond every either-or polarity. Jung thought of the Self as transcendent in this specific sense: if we say the Self is this, we naturally need to add that the Self could not also be that, where that is the opposite of this. But in the case of the Self, Jung taught, such conclusions are unwarranted, precisely because the Self is by its very nature a bridge uniting — or, again, transcending — all the various polarities of our human identity.

First of all, the Self lies beyond the usual subjectivity-objectivity divide, the conceptual opposition between our personal, subjective attitudes and what purports to be the objective truth about the world. For example, Stein writes:

For Jung, the self is paradoxically not oneself. It is more than one's subjectivity, and its essence lies beyond the subjective realm. The self [instead] forms the ground for the subject's commonality with the world, with the structures of Being. In the self, subject and object, ego and other are joined in a common field of structure and energy. (p. 152)


In Jungian terms, the "ego" is the part of the conscious mind we ordinarily think about whenever we say "I": it is what we believe (in the end, erroneously) to be the center of our being. Our own identity is intrinsically different, or so we think, from that of every other being, and any assertion that "ego and other are joined in a common field of structure and energy" is bunk. Hence, much of what we do in life is aimed at furthering the apparent needs of this supposedly unique ego which rules our individual consciousness, potentially at the expense of failing to serve or even opposing the true needs of our fellow men and women. We might be by virtue of our evolutionary heritage self-serving in the way any animal is self-serving, but we couldn't be truly selfish without having evolved an ego.

Yet Jung's interior experience, documented in his autobiography and in his many other writings, went beyond such ego/other oppositions to the realization that:

When the ego is well connected to the self, a person stands in relationship to a transcendent center and is precisely not narcissistically invested in nearsighted goals and short-term gains. In such persons there is an ego-free quality, as though they were consulting a deeper and wider reality than merely the practical, rational, and personal considerations typical of ego consciousness. (Stein, p. 152)


It is one of my preoccupations, in the many posts I've been making and continue to make about Jung in this blog, to try to peer into what his thought has to say about my Christianity, such as it is.

I say "such as it is" because it is regrettably an attenuated notion of God that I find I have in my personal experience, just now in my life.

Yet when I read books like Stein's and the several others I've mentioned in this group of posts about Jung, I find that contemplating Jung's ideas about the Self helps me regain something of the wonder and awe I formerly associated with my contemplation of a Judeo-Christian God.

Why? What's the connection? At a basic level, the answer is a simple one: Jung spoke of the Self as the imago Dei, the image of God within each one of us. Christian theology has it that we all bear such a stamp or spark of divinity, and Jung affirms the exact same thing in different terms:

At the most immediate level [in the hierarchy of agencies within the depths of the psyche] is the shadow, and over this the anima/animus ... stands as a superior authority and power. Presiding over the entire psychic government is the self, the ultimate authority and highest value: [Jung wrote that] "unity and totality stand at the highest point on the scale of objective values because their symbols can no longer be distinguished from the imago Dei." Jung contends that every one of us bears the God-image — the stamp of the self — within ourselves. We carry the mark of the archetype: typos [in Greek] means a stamp impressed on a coin, and arche means the original or master copy. Each human individual bears an impression of the archetype of the self. This is innate and given.

Since each of us is stamped with the imago Dei by virtue of being human, we are also in touch with [per Jung] "unity and totality [which] stand at the highest point on the scale of objective values." When needed, this intuitive knowledge can come to our assistance ... (Stein, pp. 158-9)

This idea that our intuitive, archetypal knowledge of God as imago Dei comes to our assistance when needed is like, to me as a Christan, the answer to a prayer.


Let me try to be as clear as I can: to Jung the Self is the imago Dei, a supreme, supernal archetype which in turn enshrines certain values above all others: unity, totality, and wholeness.

Bringing the Self into the field of conscious awareness takes power away from the unconscious Shadow by bringing it, too, into the province of ego-consciousness. The Shadow, which represents our "lower" nature — basically, the urges we inherit from our evolutionary forebears — is not destroyed, but it is "depotentiated" and brought into harmony with our other, "higher" nature, our spiritual destiny.

Realizing the Self likewise defuses the power of the Anima or Animus, in its destructive, negative aspect, to take over and ruin the personality.

In short, there is nothing in the psyche, no matter how unsavory at first blush, which cannot be redeemed through Self-realization. Parallels with the Christian message of redemption are obvious here.


Which leads me to the subject of Sin and Evil. (These words are not part of the Jungian vocabulary per se, but I am capitalizing them in deference to their importance in the Christian lexicon.)

It seems likely to me that many Christian theologians as well as lay believers would feel uncomfortable with the implications of Jung's theory towards traditional religious notions of Sin and Evil. In order to try to put my finger on why there would be such controversy, such resistance, let me begin by discussing Jung's thoughts about serpent-symbols.

According to Stein (pp. 162-168), Jung constructed an elaborate schema of wholeness as it pertains to the human soul. There are four levels represented by four three-dimensional double pyramids. I won't go into detail about those four structures, but these doubled pyramids, each pair having a single base in common, are bounded by five separating or terminating circles, each representing a level of attainable wholeness. It is the circles I want to concentrate on.

The highest circle of attainable wholeness is Anthropos, Jung's name for the spiritual ideal he identifies also as the ultimate goal of Self-realization. In Christian terms, Anthropos corresponds to angels, saints, and us after we die and go to heaven, or are redeemed and resurrected into a heaven-come-to-earth. Next lower in the hierarchy of circles is Homo, which corresponds to our everyday ideal of human perfection, rooted in our ordinary ego-consciousness. Below that is Serpens, the serpent, which is the symbolical root source of all animal wisdom and (perhaps surprisingly) deserves its own circle of wholeness on the diagram. The remaining two levels are Lapis, the wholeness associated with minerals and plant life, and Rotundum, the circle which roots the hierarchy of wholeness in the place where physical matter emerges from pure energy.

Of these five levels of wholeness which humans can know or experience, the serpent, according to Stein:

... symbolizes the self in its strongest and most blatant paradoxicality. On the one hand, it represents everything that is "snaky" in human nature: cold-blooded instincts of survival, territoriality, base physicality. On the other hand, it symbolizes the wisdom of the body and the instincts — somatic awareness, gut intuitions and instinctual knowledge. The serpent has traditionally been a paradoxical symbol, referring both to wisdom and to evil (or to the temptation to do evil). The serpent therefore symbolizes the most extreme tension of opposites within the self. (p. 165)


Christians know, of course, that Jesus advised his followers to be "wise as serpents and harmless as doves” (Matthew 10:16). Yet it is a serpent who tempts Eve, and through her, Adam, in the Garden of Eden.

In his schematic diagram of psychic wholeness, Jung placed the Serpens circle on a line or axis whose extremes are labeled Christus and Diabolus, Christ and the Devil. To me this line is evocative of a very natural Christian ambivalence toward the serpent-symbol. One the one hand, we have Christ affirming the wisdom of serpents. On the other, the Devil disguises himself as a serpent to tempt humankind into original sin.


As a Catholic Christian, I am attuned to Catholic ideas about Sin and Evil, which are different in nuanced ways from Evangelical ideas. Yet as the son of (lapsed) Baptist and Methodist parents, I respond to Evangelical ideas, too. When Pastor Rick Warren, during his Saddleback Civil Forum (see transcript here), asked presidential candidates Barack Obama and John McCain, "Does evil exist? And if it does, do we ignore it, do we negotiate with it, do we contain it, do we defeat it?", I pricked up my ears.

As one who is interested in following Jung's recommendations for heightened Christian awareness through Self-realization, I find I am made uncomfortable by the does-evil-exist question. Upon reflection, I have come up with this as an explanation. Christians who are deeply concerned with how presidential candidates answer such questions are, I imagine, intensely concerned to stay on the safe side — the "Christ side" — of the Christus-Diabolus line.

I find that staying on the "Christ side" of the line and not worrying about straying over to the "Diabolus side" is of less and less concern for me personally, on the other hand, as my spiritual trajectory takes me more and more into a Jungian perspective.

The Serpens circle is right in the middle of this Christus-Diabolus crucial line, though, and out of it spring the higher levels of Jungian wholeness represented by Homo, and then, above that, Anthropos. In bringing Jung's ideas about wholeness into my conscious awareness, I find I have already had to get used to the idea that what we might term the vertical axis of wholeness, the one that passes down through Anthropos, Homo, Serpens, etc., is located as close to Diabolus as it is to Christus.

Some years ago, I found my imagination stimulated by the new scientific ideas concerning chaos and, specifically, the "edge of chaos." The latter is an abstract dynamical region between predictable order and unpredictable chaos; evolution takes place there. The unique dynamics of the edge of chaos are such that rank novelty can emerge gracefully there, embodied in new life forms, and then be sustained indefinitely as life evolves into forms of greater and greater complexity.

In those days I wrote incessantly about the edge of chaos and made repeated mental pictures of it. I now believe these word pictures and mental images were versions of a standard Jungian symbol of the Self. For I imagined the evolutionary "tree of life" as being planted smack at the edge of chaos. To Jung, the tree, in that it represents growth and ascent, is a Self-symbol.

I quickly got hung up, though, on what seemed to me an obvious problem: the edge of chaos is as close to chaos, which is seemingly bad, as it is to order, which is seemingly good. The symbolism, in fact, precisely mimics the notion that in Jung's wholeness diagram, Serpens is equidistant from Christus and Diabolus.

I'll deal with the implications of that in Part 2 of this series.

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Follow Your Bliss (Jungian Wholeness, Part 6)

In this ongoing Power of Myth series of posts I've been considering how the thought of the late ambassador of myth Joseph Campbell jibes with that of the very-much-still-alive scientist Stuart Kauffman in his latest book, Reinventing the Sacred: A New View of Science, Reason, and Religion.

Kauffman talks of the ceaseless and unpredictable creativity of the cosmos as "God enough" to command our devotion and awe. This creativity can be esteemed as sacred when science stops insisting that nothing is real but the meaningless dances of subatomic particles, out of which, as ghostly metaphysical illusions, arise all higher things: form, function, life, agency, value, meaning, consciousness.

Kauffman argues that these higher things are not just illusory emanations of particle dances. Real in and of themselves, they're emergent entities taking their own rightful place in the roster of items composing the "furniture of the universe."


As I have hinted at in my Jungian Wholeness series, in the light of Kauffman's investigations it makes sense to count as emergent items in the list of all the real things in our universe the aspects of the human psyche mapped by Carl Jung, the Swiss psychologist who took the button of Freud's insights into the human unconscious and sewed on it a coat of many colors.

Jung found that our minds come with certain pre-fabricated images and patterns by which we organize our mental experiences. These are the "archetypes," which number in the dozens or hundreds. There is an archetype for the mother, the father, the hero figure of myth and legend ... and one for the self.

That last is the central source of all the archetypal images, the ground of all our innate psychic tendencies toward structure, order, and integration. It lies at the core of the ego — it is the seed of the "I" at the center of our consciousness.

Yet, as an archetype, the self is not itself something we are conscious of (until a brilliant scientist like Jung comes along and "discovers" it, that is).

Every unconscious archetype is instead a sort of template for how we may best organize our experiences. There are abstract archetypes for (for instance) order, for chaos, and for dualities qua dualities ... such as the order/chaos duality.

So when Jung detects the archetype-of-archetypes by virtue of which we can come into possession of a transcendent sense of our very own self, taken as a whole, what he means is that when our experience resonates with this particular pattern or image it tends to be amplified and confirmed in a uniquely potent way.


Joseph Campbell tells us of a non-intellectual, spiritual reason to take myth seriously. It's not to help us create an intellectual map, scientific or otherwise, of reality and truth, which is Stuart Kauffman's main pursuit as a scientist.

And perhaps surprisingly, it's not to find the so-called meaning of life, a desideratum of a great many philosophers and theologians. There is something of great value beyond meaning. "I think," Campbell tells Bill Moyers in The Power of Myth,
what we're seeking is an experience of being alive, so that our life experiences on the purely physical plane will have resonances within our own innermost being and reality, so that we actually feel the rapture of being alive. That's what it's all finally about, and that's what these clues help us to find within ourselves. (p. 5)

Campbell famously spoke of "following your bliss":
If you follow your bliss, you put yourself on a kind of track which as been there all the while, waiting for you, and the life that you ought to be living is the one you are living. Wherever you are — if you are following your bliss, you are enjoying that refreshment, that life within you, all the time. (p. 91)

To know the rapture of being alive: this admirably expresses the "wholeness" which Jung identified with the affirmation of the archetype he called the self. When we manage to restore our archetypal self-image to its original place at the center of our ego-consciousness, we come alive to bliss and rapture.


This, I think, is what Stuart Kauffman's reinventing the sacred has to bring about, if it is to succeed.

Kauffman himself, it is clear from reading his books, has followed his own bliss in carving out a whole new scientific territory. Kauffman's task has been to find out the deep truths of all incessantly co-constructing, co-evolving, complex systems, including: the evolution of the earth's biosphere; human economic growth and technological progress; the development of the world's legal systems such as English common law; and the natural emergence of the functions of the human mind and consciousness.

So it looks to me as if Kauffman has successfully reinvented the sacred for himself by following his bliss. He has undoubtedly, in so doing, experienced the rapture of being alive that goes along with achieving some measure of Jungian wholeness within himself. He has fulfilled the destiny of a mythic hero, plumbed the depths from which emerge all life and all worlds, and brought to the rest of us an elixir of scientific understanding by dint of which we, too, can reinvent the sacred. Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell would be proud of him.

Thursday, July 10, 2008

Jungian Wholeness, Part 3

I have been, in my Jungian Wholeness series of posts recently, exploring the thought of Carl Jung. Jung, who followed Freud in mapping the human psyche and discovered the potent patterns he dubbed archetypes in the collective unconscious, wanted to apply his insights to the Christian religion.

Specifically, he felt that the Christian emphasis on the trinitarian archetype, expressed in the Holy Trinity, needs to give way to quaternity, based on the archetype for wholeness. The God-symbol of three Persons, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, admirably led us in the direction of psychological wholeness in the past, but then got us stuck on a quest for spiritual purity instead of finishing the task of bringing the whole structure of the self out of the unconscious depths.

A quest for spiritual purity had its place, Jung said, according to Jung's Treatment of Christianity: The Psychotherapy of a Religious Tradition, Murray Stein's book on how Jung wanted to heal the Christian church. But Jung felt that modern Christianity was coming in for a crash landing due to its failure to allow for the redemption of our bodies in their gross, even sinful material reality.

So the Trinity as a God-symbol set us up for splitting our psyche into what about it could be admitted into conscious awareness and what had to be pushed into the unconscious depths to become part of the Jungian "shadow": the dark döppelganger to the persona that we gladly expose to outward and inward scrutiny. In the shadow we would keep our knowledge of our carnal, animal, lustful, aggressive characteristics, at times conveniently projecting them outward onto people we identify as being "other" than our own kind — justifying holy wars, crusades, inquisitions, witch burnings, and the like.

Meanwhile, we would pursue a vision of our own spiritual purification, blessed by God. This was a valid strategy for constructing the civilization we called Christendom, Jung said, but the Renaissance and the Enlightenment drove a wedge between the erstwhile power of the Trinity God-symbol and the way we live our lives in the modern world today.

Jung's prescription for bringing the power back to our God-symbol was to evolve it into a quaternity in which the supposedly wicked physical part of our nature could also be redeemed.


It occurs to me that the transition from Trinity to quaternity patterns with the Dark Night of the Soul spoken of by the Jesuit Thomas M. King in his book Enchantments, which I dealt with at length in my Enchantments series of posts.

King meditates on the repeated pattern in human experience in which we undergo a "Night of the Senses" that baptizes us by immersion in water, as it were. The immersion in effect kills off our naive belief that the physical world alone can save us. At that point we begin a quest for spiritual elevation and purification which involves an "enchantment" by the Word of God. We do our utmost to hark to God's Word alone and leave the claims of the physical world behind.

At some point, though, we inevitably come crashing back to earth. The enchantment turns to disenchantment. We are crushed by the weight of a "Dark Night of the Soul." God's Word has turned to ashes in our mouth.

Suddenly, then, we can receive a "Zen enlightenment," similar to the one told of by the great Trappist monk Thomas Merton. The formerly distasteful physical world takes on its own aura of sanctity. We realize we have undergone a second baptism, by fire and Spirit this time, and we enter upon a new kind of spiritual quest entirely: one that in no way tries to deny the stuff of our physical bodies with its cravings and its supposedly unholy agenda.

This new spiritual orientation that follows the second baptism by fire and Spirit would seem to correspond to the bringing of the full Jungian structure of the self up out of the unconscious shadow to the level of conscious awareness.

King shows that the Dark Night of the Soul and the second baptism by fire and Spirit are fully consistent with Jesus' teachings and with longstanding Christian practice, such as that found in the Spiritual Exercises of the founder of the Jesuits, Ignatius Loyola. They are also consistent with the evolution of the philosophy of Plato, the subtexts of Cervantes' Don Quixote and the numerous Faust narratives, etc., etc., etc. We have many, many authorities that can be cited for the validity of the pattern ... and King, as I recall, does not even mention Jung.

Wednesday, July 09, 2008

Jungian Wholeness, Part 2

I've been blogging about the Jungian concept of psychic integration and wholeness — see Jung's Treatment of Christianity: The Psychotherapy of a Religious Tradition, Murray Stein's book on how the Swiss psychologist Carl Jung wanted to heal the Christian church. Jung felt that modern Christianity was coming in for a crash landing due to its failure to allow for the redemption of our bodies in their gross material reality.

Jung said our main Judeo-Christian religion in Europe and the West had become too bent on seeking spiritual perfection. Its version of God could not relate to the shadow-side of human nature, the carnal, aggressive, animal instincts which evolution has left us saddled with. According to our religion, our lusts, sexual and otherwise, could only be redeemed by abandoning them in our quest for spiritual purity.

But, Jung said, they cannot really be abandoned, only repressed into the structure within the unconscious mind which he named the shadow. Our baser drives must accordingly be split off from conscious awareness, if we are to satisfy the traditional Christian mandates.

A better strategy, said Jung, is to bring all the structures and dynamics of the psyche into the field of consciousness in a balanced way. A new vision of God as a four-person quaternity, rather than a three-person Trinity, is needed. The goal of religion would be psychic wholeness, beyond spiritual purity.

It is my belief that our culture is off-kilter today because we have yet to heed Jung's call for an evolved Christianity that promotes psychic wholeness beyond spiritual purity.

My reasoning runs like this: When we encourage traditional views of the human condition as "fallen" and therefore requiring us to rededicate ourselves to a lost spiritual purity, we build a split into the psyche. Psychic splitting in one area results in splitting in other areas, and we start seeing the world as an "us" versus "them" thing: "they," the aliens among us, are not like "we" are, in that "they" suffer from some irremediable defect of humanity, while "we," whatever our flaws, are capable of being redeemed.


Notice how that type of thinking crops up in our debates over immigration. Robert Samuelson's opinion piece in today's Washington Post gives the impression that we're headed for deep trouble because of the heavy influx of Hispanic immigrants who, in their third and fourth generations, remain way behind ordinary Americans in terms of education and economic status.

Though the second generation makes big gains in terms of learning English and assimilating to American culture, that generation's children and grandchildren do not. Samuelson points out how Hispanics' shortfalls in these areas threaten to exacerbate our looming problems with Social Security and Medicare, which may go bust in an increasingly gray America, come the middle of this century. If we wind up with a large dollop of poorly educated, low-productivity Mexican-Americans in our labor markets, they won't have big enough paychecks to help Social Security and Medicare stay solvent.

He chides the presidential candidates, John McCain and Barack Obama, for failing to acknowledge these two intertwined problems. But Samuelson himself fails to address the question of why third- and fourth-generation Hispanic immigrants fall so far behind the economic curve that they won't be productive enough to keep our seniors' entitlement programs afloat.

The problem is really that third- and fourth-generation Hispanic immigrants are still treated as aliens by the rest of us. They are told in a thousand ways that they are and evermore shall be "other."


Joseph Campbell tells Bill Moyers in The Power of Myth that:
In India there is a beautiful greeting, in which the palms are placed together and you bow to the other person ... That is a greeting which says that the god which is in you recognizes the god in the other. (p. 53)

In Jungian terms, the palms-together bow symbolizes the recognition of the same whole human self in the greeter as in the one being greeted. There is no "us"; there is no "them." In a line from a Joan Baez song, "And the stars in your sky are the stars in mine and both prisoners of this life are we."

If our present mindset is one that is prone to splitting off our "bad" side, repressing it into our unconscious, and projecting it outward upon the "other" — the descendants of Hispanic immigrants, in this case — the lack of integration of the "other" into our world becomes a foregone conclusion.

On the other hand, if we let our Judeo-Christian tradition evolve into one which affirms a psychological wholeness beyond spiritual purity, the problems associated with Jungian splitting, repression, projection, and alienation of the "other" may simply evaporate.

Here, then, is an excellent reason why our society should give Jung and his pronouncements a second look.

Tuesday, July 01, 2008

Creation and Eternity

In The Sacred Feminine Today I mentioned the ceaseless creativity of the cosmos, endlessly moving as it does from the "present actual" into one version after another of the "adjacent possible" — one of the central ideas in Stuart A. Kauffman's important new book, Reinventing the Sacred: A New View of Science, Reason, and Religion. I presented the book as a pointer to a way in which we might recapture humankind's ancient devotion to the "sacred feminine," the mythic representation of the Mother Goddess that was symbolized primarily through images and events connected with fertility and reproduction.

In so doing, my intent was to open Kauffman's scientific worldview out onto that of the late explainer of myth, Joseph Campbell, author of such wonderful classics as The Hero with a Thousand Faces.

To Campbell, myth teaches us that there is, beneath the ceaseless creativity of the cosmos as it generates the numberless forms of the reality we consciously perceive, a deep but hidden generative power. This power can be referred to in many ways, all of them suggestive of, but ultimately inadequate to, the invisible reality behind what we see and know. This deep, hidden power can properly be described as "the ineffable," but it can also be called, with equal accuracy, "being" or "the void" — even if those two terms would ordinarily seem to us to be antonyms.

As Campbell points out, Freud, Jung, and the other psychoanalytic theorists of the early 20th century gave this ineffable power, particularly as it is manifested in the vast unconscious workings of the human psyche, the name libido — a designation that many of us lay persons suppose to be synonymous with our sexual urges. Nothing wrong with that slight misapprehension, Campbell would say: myth's understanding of creation and creativity is, after all, fundamentally sexual in character.

Within the human mind, Campbell notes, the Freudian, Jungian, psychoanalytic unconscious is analogically equivalent to the ineffable being-void out of which arises all creation, all worldly phenomena, in all their multifarious forms ... presumably including the higher-order realities Kauffman celebrates: life, agency, intention, will, value, meaning, and (yes) consciousness itself.

But to Campbell, the consciousness we are so proud of represents, in truth, a constriction of the "superconsciousness" which is our true birthright. "Superconsciousness" means an unimaginably-to-us direct awareness of the ineffable being-void whose power makes the cosmos. It is lost at the universe's very moment of Creation, though its trace remains alive in the Freudian unconscious and gives us our dreams and myths.

Campbell sees in the Christian doctrine of the Fall, properly reinterpreted, a reference to this constriction of superconsciousness into the consciousness-unconsciousness dyad, a narrowing that inevitably happens whenver a world emerges from the power of the void. The true purpose of religion, spirituality, and myth is to clue us back into superconsciousness.

To Campbell, our anthropomorphic God (along with the gods, plural, of non-monotheist religions) properly functions as a pathway back to our lost superconsciousness: our birthright awareness of the transcendent reality from which springs forth our cosmos with its own marvelous and ceaseless creativity. Redemption is, in his view, but a word for our return to superconsciousness. When Jesus teaches us in the Gospel of Luke that "the Kingdom of God is within you," he is referring to the fact that our psyche's unconscious realm already knows of the Kingdom and is in fact superconscious.

In Campbell's worldview, God is, like all the pagan and primitive gods, a mask of eternity. Owing to how our no-longer-superconscious minds work, we need at first to view the eternal being-void as if its masks were "final," meaning that we think the anthropomorphic visage we see as we gaze upon the mask of God is truly the ultimate supernal ground of all reality.

That the divine mask is not actually the ultimate truth of all reality is something that non-monotheist traditions uphold quite readily, however, for those seekers who are ready to look behind the mask. The monotheist religions are much more circumspect about this. Only so-called "mystics" have permission to explore behind the mask, and what they find there is deemed far too esoteric for the masses. Hence most believers in the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are not encouraged even to speculate that God's "face" may in truth be a mask.


As I ponder such ideas as these, I find myself asking my Roman Catholic faith some "embarrassing questions." I would like to know why traditional Christian belief and practice holds itself so aloof from what Joseph Campbell calls the "perennial philosophy." Why are we ordinary, everyday, non-mystical Christians not encouraged to look into (if we want to) the ineffable being-void behind God's eyes? Why does insisting on the "face" of God as being final strike me as in some subtle way underwriting, not eliminating, some of the great problems in our culture today?

I speak principally of such problems as war, the rightful roles of women, and the rights of gays.

Compare women's roles in the West with those in the East. The Eastern cultures, as represented by the non-monotheist societies of India, China, and Japan, don't seem to be able to generate the sort of feminist movement we in the West have created, but neither is there any great anti-woman backlash in the East, as there is in Muslim lands, against Western feminism. There seems to be, rather, a sort of benign tolerance of so-called women's liberation in us Westerners.

By the same token, while the East is not particularly concerned with advancing the gay and lesbian cause, there is again a sort of benign tolerance of those in the West who insist on so doing — as if to say, "This concern with who has what 'rights' is only a mind game, and true enlightenment strives to get beyond such games."

Monotheism seems to have given the culture of the West a tendency to bifurcate: to develop splits and schisms between those who advocate this or that worldview and those who think the same worldview is the work of the devil.

So we fight with each other. We go to war over belief systems. Oh, people make war in the East, too, but not over idea systems — except in cases where a Western idea system, Islam, has taken root in places like the modern state of Pakistan. When India, following Gandhi's lead, succeeded in convincing the British to leave, Indian Muslims and Hindus made bloody war on one another, to Gandhi's chagrin. The two sides had to be separated, at the expense of abandoning hope of unity on the subcontinent, and Pakistan was born.

It seems there has to be a connection: monotheism of the type we know today was invented by nomadic Semitic tribes who invaded the settled, agrarian, peaceful, Goddess-worshiping Neolithic communities of the Fertile Crescent in the third and second millennium B.C. The nomadic conquerors' principle deities were male tribal patrons, the forerunners of Yahweh, who empowered their favored peoples' acts of conquest.

Joseph Campbell, in his lifetime, called on us to recognize the peculiar intrinsic bias of Abrahamic monotheism toward war, and particularly Holy War. He showed that the antidote was not to abandon monotheism in favor of atheism, but to revise it by recognizing its God as but a mask of eternity. As such, God is real ... but not final. Hence we need to put an asterisk by those aspects of our religion that do not comport with the perennial philosophy revealed to us by ancient myth. The asterisk should serve to remind us that where God seems to want us to make war on heathens and infidels, the dispute (like all disputes) is meaningless and foolish to the eternal source of all being behind the mask of our Creator God.

Saturday, June 28, 2008

The Sacred Feminine Today

Dan Brown's hugely popular, terribly controversial suspense thriller The Da Vinci Code takes as one of its themes the idea of the "sacred feminine": from the earliest times in human culture, the mythic representation of the Mother Goddess, symbolized through images and events connected with fertility and reproduction.

Brown's novel contends, counter-factually, that Jesus of Nazareth married Mary "Magdalene" and fathered a daughter, the truth of whose existence was suppressed by the Early Church. Jesus's putative wife and daughter, as vessels of ongoing human devotion to the sacred feminine, had to be blotted out from history by a church bent on establishing a patriarchal male priesthood and clamping down on female sexuality, not to mention sexual freedom in general.

The facts of history are all against Brown. Jesus had no wife and daughter, the church did not hide them from the eyes of the world, Leonardo Da Vinci coded no secret information about the sacred feminine in his paintings, and no one buried in Westminster Abbey — neither Sir Isaac Newton nor anyone else — was in on this secret. And, whatever the Holy Grail was, it was not a stand-in for the fruit of Mary of Magdala's fertile womb.

Still and all, the sacred feminine has been and remains a real desideratum of human spirituality, which I expect partly explains the massive impact of The Da Vinci Code despite its odious historical errors. Never has the vaunted "willing suspension of disbelief" been more willing on the part of millions of Brown's readers — myself included.

These thoughts cross my mind as I ponder the thrust of Reinventing the Sacred: A New View of Science, Reason, and Religion, the new book by Stuart A. Kauffman, implications I first dealt with in Reinventing the Sacred, Part 1. Kauffman's stated mission is to establish a new scientific paradigm, that of emergence. Emergence lies "beyond reductionism," which is the longstanding assumption that nothing in the universe is really real but the fundamental particles of physics — or, below them, the theoretical "strings" of string theory — along with, of course, the particles' or strings' motions and interactions.

Emergence recognizes, above and beyond the dance of particles, the hard reality of higher-level entities that somehow arise from that dance. These realities include life itself, on earth and possibly elsewhere, plus abstract realities such as functions, actions, and intentions; agency; consciousness; values and meanings.

It also recognizes the ceaseless creativity of the cosmos, endlessly moving from the "present actual" into the "adjacent possible" ... and the next, and the next, and the next, on and on and on. Each "salient" or bubble at the edge of advancing actuality spawns new items to be added to the list of "furniture" of the universe, items whose advent was impossible to have predicted in advance.

This ceaseless creativity has nothing to do, says Kauffman, with the Creator God of Abrahamic tradition, whether Jewish or Christian. I'm not all that certain of that, but I still find Kauffman's ideas about reinventing the sacred compelling.

When I put Kauffman's ideas together with what little I know about the sacred feminine as alluded to ceaselessly by The Da Vinci Code, I have to think that what Kauffman means when he extols "reinventing the sacred" might in fact be a renewal of devotion to the sacred feminine.


I do know that the late explainer of myth Joseph Campbell taught that ancient cultures personified gods as masculine father images and goddesses as various feminine incarnations of the Earth Mother Goddess.

Every mythic hero figure, Campbell wrote in The Hero with a Thousand Faces, has to undertake a perilous journey outward/downward to unknown realms and back again home with some sort of material or spiritual boon in tow, a precious prize or elixir that will feed his needy people.

During the course of the adventure, between his departure and his return, the hero typically undergoes an initiation. Two of the six canonical parts of the hero's initiation, not all of which are necessarily present in any particular hero myth, are his "meeting with the goddess" and his "atonement with the father."

In the former, there is "a mystical marriage ... of the triumphant hero-soul with the Queen Goddess of the World" (p. 109, in my edition of the book) — a personage who may be seen as gentle and benign, or hostile and castrating. In either case, the hero typically succeeds in passing her test:
The meeting with the goddess (who is incarnate in every woman) is the final test of the talent of the hero to win the boon of love (charity: amor fati), which is life itself enjoyed as the encasement of eternity. (p. 118)

Yet the initiation, at least in some hero myths, is as yet incomplete. The hero must still achieve atonement with the male personage who represents his father figure. If Stuart Kauffman would like to reinvent the sacred, he must accommodate not only the Mother Goddess but also the Heavenly Father. In the Abrahamic religions of Judaism and Christianity, Yahweh, the Creator God whom Kauffman does not believe in, fills this role.

Usually the mythic hero's biological father is unknown to him, having disappeared from the scene prior to, or not long after, the hero's birth. At some point the now-grown hero begins to ask, Where is my father? No one really can answer his question, and so his mythic journey, full of peril, is motivated specifically as a father hunt.

If on this journey there is along the way a sacred marriage between the hero and the Queen Goddess of the World, it is merely a preparatory step for his ultimate encounter with the Father who lives outside the world and is fully transcendent of it. Clearly, in these father-quest myths, the hero's difficulty in going to his transcendent, supernal Father patterns with his inability to find and be reconciled with his actual, biological father.

The questing hero, of course, finds his path inevitably leads him to his transcendental father's house — the difficulty in finding it having proved surmountable — where he has no choice but to seek admission if he wants to complete his journey. But the father rebuffs him, demanding that he perform certain impossible feats first.

Here is where the imagery Campbell alludes to — "the arrow, the flames, and the flood" (p. 129) — take a decidedly Judeo-Christian, Old Testament turn. The supernal father first appears to the hero as a wrathful ogre bent on punishing him for (among other things) having succumbed to the blandishments of "woman as the temptress," the stage of the initiation process that canonically comes between "the meeting with the goddess" and the "atonement with the father."

Some of the ancient hero myths involve the hero's failure to satisfy the unapproachable father, in which case the hero must turn trickster and steal the father's elixir, so to bring it home to his, the hero's, expectant community as the requisite boon.

Other myths have the hero properly perform the set tasks — often with the mother-wife-goddess's secret or not-so-secret aid. In succeeding in performing the tasks the hero can be said to be, in words familiar to Christians, born again:
The paradox of creation, the coming of the forms of time out of eternity, is the germinal secret of the father. It can never be quite explained. Therefore, in every system of theology there is an umbilical point, an Achilles tendon which the finger of mother life has touched, and where the possibility of perfect knowledge has been impaired. The problem of the hero is to pierce himself (and therewith his world) precisely through that point; to shatter and annihilate the key knot of his limited existence.

The problem of the hero going to meet his father is to open his soul beyond terror to such a degree that he will be ripe to understand how the sickening and insane tragedies of this vast and ruthless cosmos are completely validated in the majesty of Being. The hero transcends life with its peculiar blind spot and for a moment rises to a glimpse of the source. He beholds the face of the father, understands — and the two are atoned.

To be born again at the end of a father quest is to attain atonement ("at-one-ment") with the father. Of course, the mythic hero is a stand-in for all of humanity: for each one of us, whether male or female.

Accordingly, Campbell (who was a lapsed Catholic) sees Jesus Christ as a consummate hero whose death and resurrection brings the boon of his own perfect at-one-ment with his heavenly Father to each of us. To be born again is, for the Christian, an act by which we recapitulate Jesus' trials and accept this boon.

So, whether from the Jewish or from the Christian point of view, Yahweh/God represents an essential piece of the human spiritual puzzle: the yearning for atonement with a distant and/or judging father figure. The real question is, How can we harmonize devotion to the Earth Mother (which Kauffman's reinvention of the sacred puts on a scientific footing) with the equally important need to locate and be reconciled with an at-first-missing (because he transcends the physical world) Heavenly Father.


Campbell finds throughout his writings that the monotheistic religions we have today descend from incursions starting around 2400 B.C. into the Fertile Crescent — the region of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers — by Semitic tribes originally from the Syro-Arabian desert to the south. Among the monotheistic religions that originated with the Semites in the Near East are Judaism and Christianity.

These religions differ in their foundational mythology from those of other prehistoric cultures. In the late Paleolithic and early Neolithic periods prior to the invasions, in the Fertile Crescent and elsewhere in Europe and Asia there lived the earliest sedentary humans. These people were agrarian, depending for their livelihood on planting, not hunting or slaughtering animals. To them, the primary deity was the Goddess.

The invaders and, ultimately, conquerors who came into the Fertile Crescent from the south were nomads whose lifestyle depended on animals for both transport and food. Their main gods were tribal deities whose principal function was to support the tribes in conquest. By contrast, the Goddess of the conquered agrarians was a universal deity whose principal function was to bring all humans into harmony with the natural forces inside themselves, as well as in the external world.

In Transformations of Myths Through Time, Campbell shows that ancient gods were indeed of two orders, ones representing the universal powers of nature that operate externally and internally within each of us, and ones that are "specific patrons of the tribe" (p. 54). With the coming of the Semite conquerors, then, the latter became preeminent over the former ... and the latter were the principal gods of a "patriarchal warrior people," while the former were "earlier mother goddess systems."

Complicating the mythological history of the human species, however, is a third ancient system of mythic understanding: the Indo-European. In the same general time as the one in which the Semites were mounting their incursions into the domains of settled farming communities in the Fertile Crescent, the Indo-Europeans (sometimes referred to as Aryans) were moving into and taking over the agrarian settlements from the north.

The Indo-Europeans, like the Semites, were nomads dependent on animal-derived energies rather than on sustenance derived directly from plants. They were hunters and domesticators of the horse — while the Semites domesticated the dromedary/camel and slaughtered the goats and sheep they herded for food, rather than hunting wild animals as the Aryans did.

The Indo-Europeans, like the Semitic tribes, no longer worshiped the Earth Goddess as their principal creator deity, owing their primary allegiance instead to a male god who was held to be the direct source of supernatural power.

While the Semites were responsible for generating the monotheisms of the Near East, the Indo-Europeans were influencing what would become the classical cultures of Greece and Rome, and also shaping the religious atmosphere of India, the continuing home of Hinduism and the original source of Buddhism.

The Indo-Europeans and the Semites were alike in having moved the Mother Goddess out of the limelight in favor of a male gods or God. But they differed in terms of the ways in which, once the male deities' preeminence was established, they allowed (or refused to allow) the Goddess back into the picture.

The flavor of the discrepancy can be gleaned from an essay by Campbell, "Of Harmony and of Discord," which appeared in his book The Mythic Dimension: Selected Essays 1959-1987. (The essay may be read here.) In the essay, Campbell alludes to "the Heroic Age":
... those centuries of barbaric invasions and wiping out of cities that we find celebrated in the Indo-European Iliad and Mahabharata, as well as throughout the Old Testament, [in which] there were brought onto the historic stage two sorts of nomadic, herding, and fighting peoples bearing analogous, though significantly differing, sociologically oriented systems of mythology inspired by notions of morality wherein the high concern was not of harmony with the universe in its mystery but of the aggrandizement and justification of some local, historical tribe or cult. The whole character, as well as function, of mythology was thereby transformed; and since the myths, ideals, and rites of the new orders of justified violence overlay wherever they fell the earlier of an essential peace at the heart of the universe, the history of mythology in a great quarter of the world for the past three thousand years has been of a double-layered continuum. In some parts, notably India, the mythology of the Goddess returned in time to the surface and even became dominant.

In India we have an example of a culture in which the Indo-European mode of re-harmonizing the primordial Goddess with the usurping male deities established a preference for harmony rather than discord as a way of life. The same sort of thing happened in ancient Greece. But in the Near East, the cultures influenced by (or constituted by) the Semites produced a negative take on the rightful place of Goddess worship. Thus, per Campbell, we read in 2 Kings 23 in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament of the "very good King Josiah of Judah (ca. 640-609 B.C.), when he":
... deposed the idolatrous priests whom the kings of Judah had ordained to burn incense in the high places at the cities of Judah and round about Jerusalem; those also who burned incense to Ba'al, to the sun, and the moon, and the constellations, and all the host of the heavens.

Deposing "idolatrous priests" who "burned incense to Ba'al, to the sun, and the moon, and the constellations, and all the host of the heavens" was a way of not coming to terms with the Neolithic Great Goddess whose place (or places, plural) Yahweh usurped.

Campbell summarizes:
As a consequence of ... truly unspeakable violence and barbarity over an immense part of the already civilized portion of Europe and Asia (only Egypt on its desert- and god-protected Nile remained through those millennia unbroken), what the historian of mythologies everywhere uncovers, from the British Isles to the Gangetic Plain [the area of the River Ganges in India], is a consistent pattern (retained in religions even to the present day) of two completely contrary orders of mythic thought and symbolization flung together, imperfectly fused, and represented as though of one meaning.

The first and elder of the two orders of mythic thought is that of the Great Goddess who embodies "the mysterium tremendum et fascinans of life itself as motherhood and as birth, as growth and as transformation terminating in a return to the mother in death, out of which source appears new life."

Campbell does not in this essay completely characterize the follow-on orders of thought, whether Indo-European or Semitic, in which the Great Goddess was succeeded by a male deity ... and then found her way back into the mythic traditions in positive and negative, overt and hidden forms.

In fact, Campbell seems bent on showing how, even in the Near East where the worship of the Goddess was officially deprecated by the Hebrew champions of the male God, Yahweh, the Goddess reasserted herself in various ways:
Thus the force of the underlying layer, even where officially suppressed or apparently forgotten, worked its influence, often in subtle ways; as for example, in the instance already recognized, of the number 86,400 concealed in the length of years of the biblical antediluvian age.

(Apparently, 86,400 was a number associated in some way originally with the Goddess cult.)

On the other hand, in The Power of Myth Campbell makes clear how odd the religions of today that bring forward the early monotheistic orders of myth — principally Judaism, Christianity, and Islam — are with respect to the religions of the "perennial philosophy" whose antecedents are more in the Indo-European, rather than Semitic, mold.

Responding to a question from his interviewer, Bill Moyers, about the (Judeo-)Christian idea of the Creation and the Fall, Campbell said (p. 66):
I once heard a lecture by a wonderful old Zen [Buddhist] philosopher, Dr. D.T. Suzuki. He stood up with his hands slowly rubbing his sides and said, "god against man. Man against God. Man against nature. Nature against man. Nature against God. God against nature — very funny religion!"

Our "very funny religion" has a creation myth of Adam, Eve, the Garden of Eden, and the Fall, in which Adam's temptation by Eve (after Eve was tempted by the Serpent) is the root source of sin. It is not likely that such a religion would easily come to comfortable terms with the Great Goddess whom Eve is the stand-in for.

In my own analysis — I have no reason to be sure Campbell would have agreed with this — I come to the conclusion that we in the Judeo-Christian-Islamic tradition are heirs to the ancient Hebrews' designation of the fecundity of the female womb as being the property of male humans — fathers, brothers, husbands, the male community in general — and ultimately of the male deity, the Lord God of Hosts, Yahweh.

Female fecundity is, of course, the focus of Goddess worship, what devotion to the Goddess was all about. When the energies of the female side of the cosmic equation reappear in a specifically Christian guise, they revolve around the Virgin Mary, whose son Jesus was the Son of God ... and was himself God.

Campbell in The Power of Myth shows how Mary's virginity ought to be interpreted, in his estimation: as a model of sacred (re)birth out of the physical body and into the life of the spirit. The question of how Mary physically got pregnant is of no importance here.

Campbell compares this idea of the Virgin Mary's instrumentality in all sacred birth and rebirth with ideas found in India about the spirit's ascent, above the bodily centers associated with physical urges and desires, to the level of the compassionate heart. Here again are found images of being "born again of water and the spirit," just as in Christianity.

In fact, Campbell has ways of harmonizing just about all the images and symbols of Christianity with the underlying images and symbols that derive, often stealthily, from modes of myth less inimical to the Great Goddess, for whom Mary becomes, again, the stand-in.

For Campbell, it is possible to map Christian and Jewish (not to mention Islamic) symbology back to that of the "perennial philosophy" of the rest of the world and thus rescue monotheism as we know it from being a "very funny religion."


A case in point is found in The Hero with a Thousand Faces, in the chapter titled "The Keys." In the pre-Vatican II rites of Holy Saturday in the Catholic Church — the book was published in 1949 — are found, says Campbell, echoes of the making of fire in the belly of the whale, a motif found in hero myths around the world.

The hero is consumed by a monstrous whale and enters the realm of the dead. In Christian belief, on the day before Christ's resurrection, Jesus descends to hell and rescues the souls imprisoned there. The resurrection is Easter. The vigil on the Holy Saturday preceding Easter Sunday commemorates Christ's final victory over hell and death.

In the canonical belly-of-the-whale legend, the hero brings about the whale's death and his own release by making a fire in the gut of the monster, using two sticks (see p. 248). He rubs together a socket-stick, which represents the female sex organs, with a phallic spindle-stick. The flame which is thereby sparked "is the newly generated life," and the motif as a whole is "a variant of the sacred marriage."

So when on Holy Saturday the Catholic priest blesses and lights a paschal candle, then carries it to the baptismal font whose waters he blesses and makes holy, the fact that he touches the candle to the "immaculate womb of the divine font" three times and thrice calls the "virtue of the Holy Ghost" to come into and inhabit the symbolic womb echoes the spindle-and-socket pattern of all fire-making myth. Here, Jesus Christ is the male hero who slays death ... with the transformation attendant upon baptism in blessed water, a symbol of the waters of the female womb.

Similar symbology is found in India, where the male organ is represented ir religious symbology as the lingam and the female as the yoni. But in Christianity, "the popular interpretation of baptism is that it 'washes away original sin,' with emphasis on the cleansing rather that the rebirth idea" (p. 251). The latter idea brings too close to the surface of awareness the realization of the paschal candle as a phallic symbol and the font as a womb symbol.

Since The Hero with a Thousand Faces was written some sixty years ago, our culture has striven mightily to rid itself of such overweening delicacy. Indeed, we have grown not just frank but coarse. Meanwhile, the life of the spirit has become a closed book to many of us, partly in consequence of our incessant "keeping it real." A hefty minority, meanwhile, is fighting a rear-guard action against anything which threatens the old-time religion ... with its core values that, at the extreme, demand that we denounce whichever of the Teletubbies happens to be gay.

Somewhere in the middle, between cynicism and fundamentalism, most of the rest of us find ourselves. We long to reinvent the sacred, we yearn to participate in the mysterium tremendum et fascinans of regeneration and rebirth that our Earth Mother teaches and embodies, and we also struggle for atonement with our Heavenly Father.

Stuart Kauffman's Reinventing the Sacred can help us here. Though it's not yet clear to me how his viewpoint might foster atonement with the Father, it does seem to furnish a ready antidote to this gloomy pronouncement by Campbell in The Hero with a Thousand Faces:
Wherever the poetry of myth is interpreted as biography, history, or science, it is killed. The living images become only remote facts of a distant time or sky. Furthermore, it is never difficult to demonstrate that as science or history mythology is absurd. When a civilization begins to reinterpret its mythology in this way, the life goes out of it, temples become museums, and the link between the two perspectives is dissolved. Such a blight has certainly descended on the Bible and on a great part of the Christian cult.

Only a few years after Campbell wrote that, Watson and Crick discovered DNA, and human characteristics seemed to be reduced to genes. Now Stuart Kauffman gives ample reason to look beyond that reductionism (and to believe that DNA and genes were latecomers to the party of life). In a universe that ceaselessly creates itself through the processes of emergence, there is more to reality than the dance of particles. There is life, consciousness, value, meaning. On our way to atonement with our transcendent, supernal Father, we need to enter once again into sacred marriage with our eternally fertile cosmic Mother.