Showing posts with label Theology of the Body. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theology of the Body. Show all posts

Friday, August 30, 2013

"Twerk" on MTV, Miley Cyrus Did

In 2013, 'twerk' was added to the Oxford Dictionary Online. The dictionary said the word had been around for 20 years, but the evidence for it to be included in the dictionary had tipped the scale when U.S. pop star Miley Cyrus gave a controversial and headline-producing twerking dance at the MTV Video Music Awards on August 25, 2013.

— Wikipedia          

The verb "twerk," says the Oxford dictionary, means "dance to popular music in a sexually provocative manner involving thrusting hip movements and a low, squatting stance."

Much debate ensued after Miley Cyrus "twerked" onscreen at MTV. Was her performance appropriate, the multitudes asked, or not?

Miley Cyrus on MTV
More Miley

I say not. My thought is that it extended a long-term trend a bridge too far. When I was in college at Georgetown in the late 1960s, the university enforced a rule against "public display of affection": no kissing or petting outdoors or in public view. The more general rule, at G'town and in society, was that sex is to be kept private. If it's sexual, hide it from public view.

The rule was coming apart at the seams even then. It had been doing so for decades, going back to the ending of the Victorian era of the final two-thirds of the nineteenth century. "Victorian morality can describe any set of values that espouse sexual restraint, low tolerance of crime and a strict social code of conduct," says Wikipedia. Strict restraints on sexual attitudes and behavior meant men and women wore clothes that covered all and that emphasized nothing that might arouse sexual feelings. Sex obviously happened, and a lot of it was downright illicit. There's no doubt about it. But it was done in private.

My generation was not the first to rebel, but in our own nineteen-sixties sexual revolution the gloves — and much else besides — came all the way off. Ample justification was given: that getting rid of repression and of hypocrisy would make society and its citizens all that much healthier.

Now we have a 20-year-old former child star looking to extend her something-very-like-a-career by a twerking display on TV. We have rampant sexual abuse in the U.S. military. "More than 70% of male Internet users from 18 to 34," according to Wikipedia, "visit a pornographic site in a typical month." Priestly child sexual abuse has racked the Catholic Church. Scandal after scandal has cut short a host of political careers and besmirched the memory of one of the most revered of college football coaches.

All because sex is, I believe, now more public than private. Not the act itself (at least for the most part) buts its hintings, simulacra, and accouterments.

You might think — and a lot of people actually do think — there's no reason why the loosening of nineteenth-century moral strictures that was supposed to make us saner would instead be making us sicker. You might think that between Queen Victoria's corsetings and Miley's MTV cavortings there ought to be a sweet spot which society can occupy, with only a few depraved outliers to either side of the sensible median strip.

It hasn't happened. The depraved outliers are everywhere. So I'd say we need to rein ourselves in. The only way to do that, I think, is to take sex back into the privacy of the boudoir an keep it under demure covers.

How might that happen? We need to start by shrinking the boundary of personal behavior that is considered appropriate. I have in mind, to begin with, a new reticence about stuff that really isn't all that naughty, in the grand scheme of things. For example: no posterior anatomy visible for guys with low-slung belt lines; no visible bra straps for gals. Start with tiny little things like those.

Start with making this taboo ...

... and this.

Whoa! I hear voices raised in protest already. These infractions are, to the extent they are sexual displays at all, very minor ones. They are matters of personal choice and free individual expression. Every generation since Victoria passed away in 1901 has shown more and more anatomy, more and more underwear, and where do you draw the line? Isn't this all just a Trojan horse for a thoroughgoing new Victorianism?

I hope not. But it isn't at all clear to me that there really exists a viable sweet spot between Victorian deprivation and no-holds-barred depravity — it has to be one that the bulk of us can hold to — unless it is also one that abhors (for example) hordes of us "sexting" up a storm or assiduously "tweeting our junk" at every conceivable opportunity. Such activities are not necessarily immoral but, as I hope we are learning, they straddle the increasingly invisible line between public and private. Which is why we all now know so well the name of former-Rep. Anthony Weiner.

So, no more "sexting." No more "tweeting our junk." No more peeking-out bra straps. No more visible vertical smiles. And no more of the many other "innocent" behaviors that put us on a slippery slope to less-minor infractions and then to much more that is far worse.

Notice that I am saying nothing about what can or ought to happen between consenting adults in their bedroom or boudoir. I make no claim to knowing what kinds of sex are quote-unquote bad, or, for that matter, good. All I am saying is give sexual privacy a fighting chance. Keep sex, its stand-ins, its simulacra, and its accouterments well out of public view, and we will see whether I am right and the abuses diminish.


Friday, February 24, 2012

Catholics, Contraception, and Conscience

Now that we've had — and are still having — the brouhaha over whether quasi-religious institutions — Catholic-run schools, hospitals, universities, charities — ought to be exempt from the federal mandate to provide employees with health insurance that covers contraception without copays or deductibles, I'd like to look at what the brouhaha was all about in the first place.

Particularly, why do Catholic bishops oppose contraception? I've seen little in the standard news coverage and opinion writing that tells that story at its fullest.

Unfortunately, I myself am no authority on the matter. I can offer but a partial answer to readers, so check me on all I am about to write.

As a person who came into the Catholic Church in middle life from a Protestant/secular background, I was not immediately affected in 1968 when Pope Paul VI issued his famous encyclical Humanae Vitae (literally, "On Human Life"), whose alternate title is "On the Regulation of Birth." Humanae Vitae (pronounced Who-mah'-nay Vee'-tay) reaffirmed the Catholic Church's traditional view of marriage and conjugal relations and condemned (not for the first time!) artificial methods of birth control. Catholics were not permitted to use the then-new oral birth-control pill. Nor were condoms allowed — which reaffirmed the existing teaching on those devices.

According to Wikipedia's discussion of Pope Paul VI's various encyclicals:
Paul VI teaches in the first sentence of Humanae Vitae that the transmission of human life is a most serious role in which married people collaborate freely and responsibly with God the Creator. This divine partnership [between a married couple and God] ... does not allow for arbitrary human decisions, which may limit divine providence.
Later on, the same Wikipedia discussion adds:
Pope Paul was concerned but not surprised by the negative reaction [to Humanae Vitae] in Western Europe and the United States. He fully anticipated this reaction to be a temporary one: "Don't be afraid," he reportedly told [Canadian Cardinal Édouard Gagnon] on the eve of the encyclical, "in twenty years time they'll call me a prophet."
It has, quite obviously, taken more than twenty years for that to happen. We're still up in arms over contraception and its concomitants as they affect women's rights and women's health insurance coverage.

The Catholic Church's Reverence for Conception

What, from a Catholic perspective, underlies this dispute? It needs to be noted, first of all, how very, very highly the Catholic Church reverences conception. Conception is more than just the uniting of a man's sperm with a woman's egg, even more than the start of a human life. In addition to those, it is an occasion for calling to mind and honoring the entire gamut of joys, interpersonal relationships, and lifetime commitments that the idea of biological conception is meant to activate within us — including the consecrated relationship of a loving couple to God.

For the married couple, conception (once the pregnancy test turns out positive and an embryo is known to be present in the womb) is meant to be an occasion for great joy. In anticipation of the possibility of conception and pregnancy, each conjugal union is meant to be an act of physical pleasure and spiritual affirmation. Once a child is on its way, the couple is meant to reaffirm in attitude, thought, and deed its commitment to bringing him or her into the world and raising him or her to adulthood with mutual dedication and love.

The demand on the woman who must carry the pregnancy to term; go through the prolonged gestation period; then endure labor and childbirth; and then provide nutrition and nurture to the newborn child is a great one. The man has less to do early on, but he must faithfully persevere in supporting the family unit and being true to his marriage vows. Dad's contribution to the child-rearing process will increase as time goes on, and the youngster becomes less dependent on Mom.

That's the ideal. I think the insistence of the Church on the sacredness of human conception is meant to bring the whole of that ideal, including but not limited to biological conception per se, into the sharpest possible focus.

Put bluntly, then, sexual gratification all by itself is never front-and-center. Sex severed from reverence for conception is, the Church says, "intrinsically disordered."

We need to keep in mind that this reverence for conception does not limit sex by married couples to couples who are capable of conceiving a child. Married couples in which the woman is past the age of menopause can legitimately enjoy sex, as can married couples in which a partner is infertile. The same is true when a mother, breastfeeding her baby and not ovulating each month, cannot get pregnant.

The Catholic Church Says All Acts of Conjugal Love Must Be "Open to Conception"

The Catholic reverence for conception is why it is said by Catholic authorities that every sex act engaged in by a married couple must be "open to conception." That phrase echoes "open to the transmission of life" in paragraph 11 of this translation of the Latin in which Paul VI wrote Humanae Vitae. The Catechism of the Catholic Church, for its part, uses the phrase "openness to fertility" to head sections 1652-54.

How exactly is this phrase "openness to conception/fertility/transmission of life" to be construed?

In Humanae Vitae, Paul VI expressly insists on "safeguarding both ... essential aspects [of conjugal love], the unitive and the procreative." These two aspects of conjugal love, unitive and procreative, are said by the pope to be crucially bound up with one another. The pope writes:
11. These acts, by which husband and wife are united in chaste intimacy, and by means of which human life is transmitted, are, as the [Second Vatican] Council recalled, "noble and worthy," and they do not cease to be lawful if, for causes independent of the will of husband and wife, they are foreseen to be infecund, since they always remain ordained towards expressing and consolidating their union. In fact, as experience bears witness, not every conjugal act is followed by a new life. God has wisely disposed natural laws and rhythms of fecundity which, of themselves, cause a separation in the succession of births. Nonetheless the Church, calling men [and women] back to the observance of the norms of the natural law, as interpreted by their constant doctrine, teaches that each and every marriage act ... must remain open to the transmission of life.
12. That teaching, often set forth by the magisterium [the teaching authority of the Church], is founded upon the inseparable connection, willed by God and unable to be broken by man on his own initiative, between the two meanings of the conjugal act: the unitive meaning and the procreative meaning. Indeed, by its intimate structure, the conjugal act, while most closely uniting husband and wife, capacitates them for the generation of new lives, according to laws inscribed in the very being of man and of woman. By safeguarding both these essential aspects, the unitive and the procreative, the conjugal act preserves in its fullness the sense of true mutual love and its ordination towards man's most high calling to parenthood. We believe that the men [and women] of our day are particularly capable of seeing the deeply reasonable and human character of this fundamental principle.
It's fair to assume that "openness to conception/fertility/transmission of life" is, in the papal view, the procreative meaning of sex. Put simply, it can never be legitimately severed from the unitive aspect by which sex binds two spouses closer together, thereby "expressing and consolidating their union." If the two inseparable aspects of sex are in fact distanced from one another by means of artificial birth control, the married couple fails (per paragraph 10 of Humanae Vitae) to "conform their activity to the creative intention of God, expressed in the very nature of marriage and of its acts, and manifested by the constant teaching of the Church."

In paragraph 13 of Humanae Vitae, Pope Paul VI adds to that:
To use this divine gift [of conjugal love] destroying, even if only partially, its meaning and its purpose is to contradict the nature both of man and of woman and of their most intimate relationship, and therefore it is to contradict also the plan of God and His will.
So conjugal acts which are "foreseen to be infecund" do not destroy the "meaning and purpose" of the conjugal acts themselves, "since they always remain ordained towards expressing and consolidating" the union of the married pair. That's why natural family planning — the "rhythm method" — is legitimate. But, in the view of Paul VI, if the infecundity is artificially produced, the "meaning and purpose" of the conjugal acts is illicitly corrupted.

The Ongoing Dispute within the Church over Contraception

"Contraception," says Fr. Richard P. McBrien in his thick compendium of the Catholic faith, Catholicism, is what Church teaching specifically forbids — not "birth control" per se. Natural family planning (formerly called "the rhythm method") is allowed, after all, and clearly it counts as a method of "birth control." "Contraception" per se, though, is "the intentional placing of a material obstacle to the conception of a child: e.g., a contraceptive pill, an intrauterine device, contraceptive foam, a condom" (p. 982), and it is what is not allowed.

I gather that a pharmacological method such as the well-known oral birth-control pill counts as "a material obstacle" in this respect, and it is officially deemed as objectionable as a condom is.

McBrien talks (pp. 982-992) about the strict official teaching of the Church concerning contraception, and also about "the other side" in this debate, which
... argues that contraception may not only be legitimate under certain circumstances but even mandatory. This side speaks in terms of "responsible parenthood."
The "other side" consists of faithful Catholics who dispute the position taken by Paul VI in Humanae Vitae. Non-Catholics reading this should accordingly realize that there does exist within the Church an ongoing internal dispute about contraception. However, the strict official teaching of the Church insists that contraception, as McBrien has specifically defined it, is forbidden to Catholics.

McBrien alludes to three main areas of dispute. He says the two sides differ in their respective understandings of:

  • natural law
  • the binding force of official Church teachings
  • the development of Church doctrine

Non-Catholics who are reading this simply to comprehend the current controversy over federally mandated contraception coverage need not examine the two sides' respective cases in depth. They represent an "internal family dispute" among Catholics, after all. The "official" position of the Church is what counts, I'd say, in the mandated contraception coverage debate. Why? Because the bishops' objection to such coverage is that it forces them to violate their Church's official position — and thus it violates the "conscience" of the Catholic Church.

The Catholic Church's Heavy Reliance on "Natural Law"

Still, some of the basic ideas fueling the internal dispute are important for anyone trying to see what underlies the current argument over federally mandated contraception coverage. First, and most importantly, the teachings and doctrinal history of the Catholic Church place heavy emphasis on "natural law." According to Wikipedia:
The Roman Catholic Church holds the view of natural law set forth by Thomas Aquinas particularly in his Summa Theologica ... 
The Summa Theologica was written by Thomas Aquinas in 1265–1274. It established a theological/philosophical basis by which most imaginable questions about God-given human nature could be answered. The Summa Theologica, says Wikipedia, "presents the reasoning for almost all points of Christian theology in the West."

According to Aquinas's formulation of natural law, says Wikipedia:
Humans are capable of discerning the difference between good and evil because they have a conscience. There are many manifestations of the good that we can pursue. Some, like procreation, are common to other animals, while others, like the pursuit of truth, are inclinations peculiar to the capacities of human beings. 
"Common to other animals"? How is this commonality important? Well, notice that in reasoning about natural law, we can understand our human capacity for conjugal love, at least in part, by examining what animals use sex for: reproduction. Accordingly, if we humans use artificial means of contraception to sever sex from reproduction, then the sex act can be called intrinsically disordered: against God-given human nature, as ordered by the principles of natural law.

To the best of my understanding, this appeal to natural law is a peculiarly Catholic way of discerning right from wrong. I am not aware that any other religious denomination considers its faithful to be bound by Aquinas-style natural-law reasoning in this way. I do not mean that all other faiths endorse artificial contraception, but if they do not, they may have other ways of reasoning to that conclusion.

Lay Catholics Respond to the Mandated Contraception Controversy

In her letter to the editor of The Washington Post (Feb. 5, 2012) Falls Church, Virginia, resident Mary Clare Murray states the official Catholic view of contraception in this elegant way:
In her Feb. 12 column, “A new front in the culture wars,” Lisa Miller said that “birth control is noncontroversially good for families and children.” Since this conversation arises because of the Catholic Church’s reaction to current events, this might be a good time to explain what the church teaches regarding birth control. 
It is not just that using birth control closes a man and woman off from sharing in God’s creation of life, it is also that using birth control closes the couple off from a full expression of love, which is total self-giving and the commitment to stay together, regardless of what life brings. 
Sexual intimacy is not meant to be entertainment. It is meant as something beautiful that will bind two people in a permanent union of selflessness, which is really what is “good for families and children.” The misuse of this is not “noncontroversially good” but rather a sound explanation for the devastating divorce rate, sexually transmitted diseases, depression and other illnesses; the couple’s bodies are sharing a commitment, but their minds aren’t. That’s not good for anybody.
I'd say this expresses quite beautifully the official teaching of the Catholic Church about marriage, sexual union, birth control, pregnancy, and the mutual sharing of long-term family responsibilities. The basic point is that sex should open us up, not close us off. A "permanent union of selflessness" on the part of the married couple is a sine qua non of sex ... but so too is the sex act's fundamental "openness to conception."

I would add that the couple's underlying attitude toward conception is a litmus test for the quality of the marital union, or so the Catholic Church would say.

But not all conscientious Catholics agree. This published response to Ms. Murray's letter came from Angela Corigliano Murphy of Bowie, Maryland:
Ms. Murray stated that contraception, which is a temporary inducement of infertility, “closes the couple off from a full expression of love, which is total self-giving and the commitment to stay together regardless of what life brings.” Let’s carry this idea through to its logical conclusion. What happens when infertility is biological and permanent, such as when the wife goes through menopause? Are the husband and wife now closed off from a full expression of love? When I went through menopause, some 20-plus years ago, should my husband and I have stopped expressing our love for each other physically because we could no longer have children? I find that notion highly risible.
No, sexual intimacy is not entertainment, but neither does it cease to be “a full expression of love” when it cannot result in procreation, whether temporarily or permanently. 
I myself would argue that Ms. Murphy is somewhat mistaken in her logic, in that the official position of the Church carefully distinguishes between natural and artificial inducements of infertility. Menopause is natural, and post-menopause sex between husband and wife indeed serves the remaining — i.e., unitive — purpose of conjugal relations. For natural reasons, "a full expression of love" after menopause cannot produce a baby. Yet it is fully in accord with natural law for husbands and wives of post-fertility age to continue to relish sex.

It's not just about the physical possibility of conception, then. It's about all the things associated with conception, when conception is possible and is taken in its broadest, most abstract sense — and it's especially about what those things "truly mean."

The Church endorses natural family planning methods (the rhythm method, which amounts to abstaining from intercourse during certain parts of the menstrual cycle) since they take advantage of what Humanae Vitae calls "a faculty provided by nature." As with post-menopause sex, this is a case in which conjugal sex is legitimate, even if apart from the possibility of purely biological conception.

I have to conclude, then, that the Church wants Catholics to reverence conception in the abstract — even when "faculties provided by nature" happen to prevent the biological union of sperm with egg.

So, when the bishops balk at covering contraception in health insurance paid for by Catholic-run institutions, they're standing fast for a time-honored worldview that Pope Paul VI in 1968 thought would reassert itself "in twenty years time."

The Official Catholic Teaching vs. Pro-Contraception Belief

It's a worldview that is quite clearly at odds with the one that predominates in our culture today. In today's dominant worldview, women have the right to contraception, to free coverage thereof in their health insurance plans, and even to discretionary abortions when needed and as desired.

There are excellent arguments to be advanced in favor of this dominant worldview. One is the who's-fooling-whom argument: the vast majority of Catholic women use artificial contraception at some point in their lives. I've read that the figure is fully 98 percent, but this article in The Washington Post says it's lower.

I dug into the matter and found that, according to "Countering Conventional Wisdom: 
New Evidence on Religion and Contraceptive Use," an April 2011 report by Rachel K. Jones and Joerg Dreweke for the Guttmacher Institute, 68 percent of Catholic women "at risk of unintended pregnancy" use "highly effective methods" of birth control — sterilization, the pill or other hormonal pharmaceuticals, or IUDs. Fifteen percent rely on condoms. Two percent use natural family planning/the rhythm method. Four percent use other means of birth control. And eleven percent use no method at all.

That data can be found in the table "Supplementary table to Figure 3. Current contraceptive use among women at risk of unintended pregnancy, by religious affiliation, 2006–2008 NSFG" at the very end of the report, and can also be seen as the second table here. ("NSFG" refers to the National Survey of Family Growth, conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.) The controversial 98 percent figure comes from the first of the two tables on that same page, and is shown as derived from "Unpublished tabulations of the 2006-2008 National Survey of Family Growth." It refers to surveys of all women who have ever had sex, not just women who are "at risk of unintended pregnancy."

However the numbers are to be parsed, one argument in favor of mandated contraceptive coverage is that large numbers of Catholic women use contraceptives. Contraception-tolerant arguments are also heard, within the Church itself, from a number of its opinion leaders both ordained and lay. Father Richard P. McBrien notes in Catholicism that a "Papal Commission for the Study of Population, the Family, and Birth" produced, in 1966, just two years prior to Humanae Vitae, two reports: a majority report favoring a reconsidered view of contraception and a minority report insisting on the traditional view that artificial contraception is intrinsically disordered.

When Pope Paul VI promulgated Humanae Vitae in 1968, he sided with the minority, not the majority.

The promulgation of Humanae Vitae triggered a hue and cry from liberal Catholic opinion leaders who had imagined that the pontiff's much-anticipated encyclical was going to affirm the perspective of the commission's majority, not that of the minority. Per McBrien:
According to the majority opinion, the argument [of the minority] in favor of the traditional teaching based on [the Church's longstanding] authority fails to recognize the evolutionary character of that teaching.
The Catholic Church has traditionally maintained that its hierarchy possesses a magisterium — a teaching authority — that illuminates what Catholics believe. In addition to dogma, opposition to which constitutes heresy, there is a much vaster body of official doctrine which the magisterium urges on Catholics. The teaching of Humanae Vitae is a matter of such doctrinal teaching, and must be taken very seriously by Catholics — yet it is not to be considered the infallible teaching of the pope. Catholics may dissent from it in good conscience.

The dissenting faction against Humanae Vitae in 1968 asserted that Paul VI had failed to recognize that Catholic doctrine has evolved significantly in the past and must be allowed to evolve concerning contraception in the present. For example, in the past, usury — the lending of money at interest — had been disallowed. Times changed, and modern banking emerged. Lending of money at interest became the norm in secular society ... and the Church changed its doctrine to permit it.

In the modern world, the liberals' thinking went in 1968, the traditional doctrine against contraception needed to change. Why? In part, because (as the liberals writing the 1966 majority report had urged) a principle of totality dictates that (per McBrien):
... the conjugal act itself must be viewed not as an isolated reality but in the larger context of human love, family life, education, etc. ... Sexuality is not ordered only to procreation. Sacred Scripture says not only "Be fruitful and multiply" (Genesis 1:28) but also "they become one flesh" (2:24), portraying the partner as another helpful self (2:18). [The majority report stated that] "In some cases intercourse can be required as a manifestation of self-giving love, directed to the good of the other person or of the community, while at the same time a new life cannot be received. This is neither egocentricity nor hedonism but a legitimate communication of persons through gestures proper to being composed of body and soul with sexual powers."
McBrien says that the liberals' posited principle of totality was flatly "declared erroneous" by Paul VI in Humanae Vitae.

Looking back at Angela Corigliano Murphy's objection to the traditional view of contraception expressed by Mary Clare Murray in the Washington Post opinion section, I'd say it implicitly endorses the principle of totality. Crucially, to Murphy, sexual intimacy does not "cease to be 'a full expression of love' [even] when it cannot result in procreation." Her letter to the editor would seem to show that the liberals' posited principle of totality in 1968 is still at work in Catholic lives and minds, even today.

Yet, the ghost of Paul VI would argue, the liberal position actually fails in its mission to ensure complete "totality." If a married couple is fertile, then, by our very nature as human beings, conjugal intimacy and openness to conception must go together, Paul's ghost would say. Breaking that natural link by artificially suppressing the procreative aspect of sex goes against God's plan and imperils society's good order.

A Woman's Right to Contraceptive Coverage?

I don't know whether theological-moral disputes of this sort make any sense whatever to non-Catholics, especially secular ones who do not profess faith in a religion. Let me try to put the issue under a slightly different microscope, instead. I think a fundamental question here is whether women have a right to sex without costs and consequences.

Costs: the monetary outlays just for using the oral contraceptive pill can be up to $600 a month. But the dollar costs of having a baby and raising it to adulthood are vastly more huge.

Consequences: specifically, pregnancy, childbirth, and, barring adoption, motherhood. The sacrifices and sheer difficulties inherent in raising a child for X number of years, perhaps with no father around to share the burden. Also, possibly having to give up a career to become a full-time mom, meaning taking big-time hits to life plans and economic prospects.

Is there, then, a right justly claimed by American women that they must not be forced to bear the costs and consequences of having sex? At least, not if human ingenuity and artifice can have anything to say about it.

This question may be the linchpin of this whole debate. If you think women do have such a right, I can pretty well predict how you would answer all the other questions surrounding the issue. For example, if you think such a right exists, you would typically say that women's health insurance plans must, all of them, cover birth control with no extra premiums, deductibles, or copays.

On the other hand, if you deny that such a right exists, you are likely in sympathy with the pronouncements of the bishops on the matter — even if you yourself are not a Catholic.

The Catholic Church denies that there is such a right, because the Church has always taught that there can't be such a right. Catholic doctrine says flatly that all conjugal acts (a) must be between married partners of the opposite sex and (b) must be open to the transmission of life. The idea that sex can and ought to be freely engaged in while blocking its expectable natural consequences is "gravely disordered." End of discussion.

When the Obama administration announced its original policy making free contraceptives universally mandatory in women's health insurance, it included a carve-out to the effect that churches per se were exempt. The carve-out was a narrow one, since it applied strictly only to religious congregations and their immediate employees. Then, Catholic bishops and others howled in protest. What about, they asked, our various hospitals/schools/charities that aren't included in the exception?

The administration was forced to broaden the carve-out to include those semi-secular institutions.

When that happened, some liberal Catholics felt relieved. The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, though, did not. On the other side of this issue, some pro-choice groups called the modified rule a sell-out, because women employees of Catholic institutions who are not themselves Catholic or those who use contraception despite the Church's teachings would now be left without coverage — an unacceptable situation if you believe women have the right to have sexual intercourse freely, without putting themselves in line for undesired consequences and costs.

Widening the Scope of the Discussion

One can cast the discussion narrowly as a contrast between two competing values:
  1. A woman's proclaimed right to sex without consequences, and therefore to contraceptives at no cost.
  2. The Church's proclaimed right to act within the dictates of its official conscience.
Put that way, it's hard for me personally to decide which value ought to trump the other.

Arguments from within the Church and outside it to the effect that Church teachings on contraception ought to be updated, since they've "evolved," don't really help me settle the matter. Whether or not it's so, the fact remains that right now the Catholic Church bans contraception as a matter of moral and theological principle. Until that changes, I don't see how it's right for the government's agenda to trample over the Church's religious teachings.

Then again, so many Catholics do in fact use artificial contraception that it's hard to think of "the Church" as being united on this issue. Meanwhile, two generations of American women of whatever religious background have been raised to believe that there's nothing whatsoever wrong with using contraception, and it cannot be denied that they feel a great deal more free than their grandmothers did, simply because they understand that sex can, if they choose, be without consequences.

But what's missing in what I have said so far is, I think, the question of the consequences of widely available contraception as they pertain to the larger society.

You might think that oral contraceptives' introduction in 1960 would have led to a state of affairs in which there were fewer unwanted pregnancies and (post-Roe v. Wade in 1973, which legalized abortion) almost no need for abortions — that, in the famous words of President Clinton, abortions would be "safe, legal, and rare."

Abortions are safe today, and they are legal, but they're not rare. According to "United States abortion rates, 1960-2008," there were over 1.2 million abortions in the United States in 2008. Most of them were, I assume, due not to medical necessity but to the fact that prospective mothers declined, however regretfully, to carry their fetuses to term. That abortion rate, admittedly, was somewhat down from over 1.6 million in 1990.

Prior to Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Court decision which legalized abortion in 1973, abortions in the United States rose from a paltry 292 in 1960, the year the Pill was introduced, to 586,760 in 1972, the last pre-Roe year.

This useful graph represents the statistics:
























Ratio = the number of abortions per live births; % = abortions as percentage of total pregnancies (live births + abortions).

Then there's the question of babies born out of wedlock, mothers who aren't married, and single-parent families. Columnist George F. Will writes recently in The Washington Post that
... now more than 50 percent of all babies born to women under age 30 are born to unmarried mothers. ... In 1965, [the late Senator] Daniel Patrick Moynihan, then in President Lyndon Johnson’s administration, published his report on the black family’s “crisis,” which was that 24 percent of black children were then born to unmarried women. Today, 73 percent are. Forty-one percent of all children are now born to unmarried women.
How could the wide availability of birth control have led to more, not fewer, post-Roe abortions and more, not fewer, fatherless children today?

If the Catholic bishops are right, the crux of the problem is that contraceptives unhinge sex from its procreative aspect. And if Paul VI was right in Humanae Vitae, that undesirable result was apt to be accompanied by another one: the unhinging of sex from its unitive aspect as well. The procreative and unitive aspects of conjugal sex are intrinsically inseparable, Paul VI wrote. Sex both produces new life and unifies prospective parents in a deeper bond of mutual commitment.

Sever sex from its procreative aspect and — given that widely available contraception so often fails to prevent unwanted pregnancies — you get abortions numbering in seven figures nationally. Sever sex from its unitive aspect and you get an epidemic of single motherhood.

These are, however, social pathologies and have no clear remedy in the realm of public policy, George Will writes. For example:
The entitlement state can be reformed by various known — if currently politically impossible — policy choices. But no one really knows the causes of family disintegration, so it is unclear whether those causes can be combated by government measures.
The Pill is not a direct cause of (paradoxically) high abortion rates, nor is it a direct cause of family disintegration. No one is saying that it is. Yet it is clear (to me at least) that contraception's wide availability has contributed to those social pathologies — while in its more positive aspect it has contributed to the justly applauded liberation of women in our society.

Also clear to me is that we need to strike the proper balance between legitimate public policy concerns — e.g., women's access to contraception under their health plans — and legitimate expressions of religious conscience such as the Church's principled refusal to be accomplices in same. Only out of the careful balance between these competing world views can come the next evolutionary step in the culture wars.


Thursday, February 18, 2010

The Very Logic of Christianity

The following "My Turn" column appeared in a recent edition of The Catholic Review, the weekly newspaper of the Archdiocese of Baltimore:

Theology series aids relationships

Rob Bart Jr.


Growing up outside the Catholic Church in the ’60s, I did not have the benefit of a strong instruction on chastity. Becoming a Catholic in 1999 opened for me a new world of sacraments, saints, popes and the Mass.

A friend, Lou Breschi, shared Christopher West’s video tape series on John Paul II’s Theology of the Body (TOB) with me. My wife, Ginnie, and I watched the eight talks and saw he had written something so incredible that it needed to be shared with everyone – to heal the wounds so prevalent today in marriage and relationships. We agreed we would spend the rest of our lives learning and sharing this message which is the very logic of Christianity.

The legacy that John Paul left us is not new Catholic teaching, but a repackaging of the Gospel message “truth proposed not imposed.”

He teaches us we are not called to be more spiritual, but to be more incarnational. We are embodied souls; He put flesh on our spiritual lives. Ginnie has a great way of looking at it: “We are not like a peanut, the hull being the body and the nut being the soul – discard the hull to get to the nut. Rather, we are like sugar snap peas, it’s all good!”

Recognizing this, TOB helps us to answer two profound questions: “What does it mean to be human?” and “How do I live my life in a way to bring true happiness?”

To answer these, we consider what is the deepest yearning of every human heart. Is it to love and be loved? If so, how?

To answer these questions, John Paul takes us back to the garden, not my vegetable garden where we spend most of our free time in the summer, but “The Garden,” where Adam and Eve lived and loved in perfection, which is our true calling. We get a glimpse that they, and we, are made in the image of God and called to participate in the eternal exchange of love between Father, Son and Holy Spirit, which is self-giving divine love. We learned there is a ‘spousal meaning’ of the body. We are made in one human nature, embodied as male and female and made for union and communion through the sincere and fruitful gift of self. One of the major keys of TOB is that we are made for self-donation. Ask yourself, when are you happiest? Is it when you are giving or receiving?

John Paul proceeds to show us how the fall of man put an end to this perfection, but Christ’s redemption gives us an opportunity to live this way again. Do you yearn for more meaning, true love in your relationships, in your sexuality? Do you believe it is even possible or just a remote hope? If you were given a real way in your real everyday life to realize your heart’s deepest longing, would you accept it? Do you want it? If you do or are not sure, join us for the next study of TOB [here, the author mentions some local parishes, dates, and times].

(Rob Bart Jr. is a St. Francis Xavier parishioner in the Baltimore Archdiocese.)

I would like to add a hearty Amen! to the idea that the chastity message embodied in John Paul's teaching "is the very logic of Christianity." I once didn't understand that; now I do.

John Paul II's book The Theology of the Body: Human Love in the Divine Plan is a compendium of addresses the late pope gave on his "theology of the body" for the benefit of his "Wednesday audiences" from 1979 to 1984, early in his pontificate.

For the benefit of lay audiences, Christopher West elucidated what the Holy Father had to say in his 2004 book Theology of the Body for Beginners: A Basic Introduction to Pope John Paul II's Sexual Revolution.

Mr. West also maintains two websites (here and here) devoted to spreading the word about the theology of the body. Through the first website (click here) you can obtain various books, DVDs, etc. that can be used for private contemplation or for study groups.

Most of these materials are Catholic-oriented, but there are also items aimed at Protestants, since what is at stake is indeed "the very logic of Christianity."

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Rededicating This Blog

This blog is being renamed and rededicated! Once named "In Search of Solidarity," it is now called "In Search of Maturity." (It also has a new look.)

The change is fitting for several reasons. One is that this blogger will turn 62 this year. Quite obviously, if he doesn't gain some sort of maturity at this point in his life, he never will.

Second, I have, finally, in fact turned a corner on my own personal maturity. The maturity I am in search of is actually more that of others in the society and culture, particularly younger people.

Third, as a result of that indefinable something finally falling into place for me personally, in the last few months — as if a capstone has at last been dropped into a waiting arch — what has come into focus for me is the idea that our culture presently suffers from a massive "maturity gap." I'd like to do what I can to help close that gap.


To close the gap is hard, in part because defining the gap and demonstrating that it exists is hard. I would like to begin by citing Don't Eat the Marshmallow!, an earlier post to this blog. The thrust of that post was that an article recently in The New Yorker, "Don't!", furnishes evidence about something I consider to be a near-synonym of maturity, self-control.

Specifically, science has found that self-control is a thing that we can develop, but often fail to. We're not stuck with however much or little we are born with.

Scientists have experimented with children as young as four and found wide disparities in their ability to delay eating a marshmallow or Oreo cookie placed before them while their adult supervisor attends to an errand outside the room. When told to ring a bell if they can't wait any longer, some do and some don't speed up the instant of gratification, with those who don't ever ring the bell and who thus duly put off eating the goodie getting the promised reward of an extra goodie, once the adult returns.

And some children not only don't wait, they don't even bother to ring the bell. They just snatch the goodie and consume it. Some even find a way to (seemingly) fool the adult: lick the cream filling out of an Oreo and reassemble it to escape detection.

Experimenters have looked into the later lives of the impatient "low delayers" (these experiments were originally conducted in the late 1960s) and found that some have become "high delayers," and that these lucky individuals have had more successful lives than the perennial snatchers and grabbers who never learned to postpone gratification.


I would argue that the ability to postpone gratification is the essence of maturity, by whatever name you wish to call it: self-control, self-discipline, self-denial, etc.

I would further suggest that another name for the same phenomenon is "chastity." Here is a word, I know, that immediately rings bells and sounds loud buzzers in the culture, for the first thing it brings to mind is sexual forbearance. Isn't that type of forbearance something the culture gratefully laid to rest in the 1960s? Isn't it the general (and proper) understanding today that sex by and between consenting adults is perfectly fine, whatever the circumstances of those adults?

My response:

First of all, chastity, properly understood, is more than sexual forbearance. It is (as is forbearance per se) a word that means "a refraining from something; patient endurance; self-control; an abstaining from the enforcement of a right." To be chaste is to be pure and virtuous, stainless and undefiled. Obviously, abstaining from the wrong sorts of sex is a big part of chastity, but it's only the tip of the iceberg. There are plenty of ways for someone who is totally celibate, sexually speaking, to offend against chastity.

Second, I may as well say this right out loud, right now, rather than tiptoe around the issue: I no longer believe in the Sexual Revolution.


In fact, I have this confession to make: the recent arrival of the capstone in my arch of maturity coincided with my giving up masturbating, a practice which the Sexual Revolution said was as natural and healthful as eating and breathing.

As I indicated in God of Chastity, Part II and earlier posts in my Theology of the Body series about an important theological outlook espoused by the late Pope John Paul II, my church preaches chastity. This past Lenten season, I began practicing it by stopping masturbating.

Specifically, I gave up looking at porn on the Internet and doing what comes naturally when one looks at porn ... a thing one also tends to do many times, as well, when not looking at porn on the Internet.

More specifically yet, the kind of dirty pictures I favored when looking at online porn were not "normal," but oriented toward a particular fetish or perversion. I'm not going to say what it was ... it's a preoccupation that a lot of men have, and not a few women as well, in which something bodily that is not intended to provoke lust does anyway. I now realize that entertaining such preoccupations, though no one is really harmed by it, is nothing if not immature.

And this is now a blog against immaturity!


I bring these personal things up because I believe a lot of the sexual behavior that goes on today without any stigma of illicitness is just the acting out of immaturity and the inability to postpone gratification. It has been so since very early in my life — I was born in 1947 — but the pace picked up with the Sexual Revolution of the 1960s. And, as the young people of my Baby Boomer generation threw off the old shackles of sexual repression, they also gave evidence of being notably less mature in other ways.

I witnessed this in my own young life in the form of the cataclysmic violence that erupted in the late 1960s as college and university students tried to "tear down the walls" and summarily enact a political revolution.

I was a junior at Georgetown University in 1968 when opposition to the war in Vietnam turned ugly. Students who were "clean for Gene" early in the year — for Senator Eugene McCarthy, who ran as an antiwar candidate against incumbent President Lyndon Johnson — watched as the hope engendered by his positive early results in the New Hampshire primary and elsewhere were doused by the killings of Martin Luther King and Bobby Kennedy. King was the crucial link between the civil rights movement and establishment politics, and Robert Francis Kennedy was the man most likely to translate McCarthy's quixotic crusade into a successful peace Presidency.

With their snuffing out, leaders of the "movement" for civil rights and peace descended on Chicago during the week of the Democratic National Convention bent on goading the police into starting a riot — which is what actually happened. Young self-styled radicals defended what they had wrought in terms of no longer being willing to wait for peace and justice.

No longer being willing to wait ... that, par excellence, is a recipe for the victory in one's soul of the precipitous and the immature.

Did their coming to prevail have anything to do with the Sexual Revolution? The question answers itself when you consider that the old order of sexual propriety was based on the notion that sex before marriage is a sin. When sex before marriage is a sin, sex outside of the duly sanctified bridal chamber is out of the question entirely. Throwing such notions aside, I believe, was manifestly a recipe for the onset of radical immaturity in other avenues of life.

Believe me, I wish it were otherwise. I wish we could have our marshmallow and eat it, too: that we could be faultlessly mature in other areas of life while not reining ourselves in sexually in the least degree. But my experience is that we are not built that way, and the world does not work that way.

I don't plan to say all that much about sex in my rededicated "In Search of Maturity" blog, though. I know of no better way to turn what I would hope to be a reasonable discussion into a food fight than to become a scold about the kind of behavior I know people want to hear nothing negative about.

Besides, there are any number of topics related to maturity and self-control that don't ask people to give up such a mainstay of their present lifestyle as "illicit sexuality" ... until they're ready to do so, that is. Lord knows, that was literally the last thing I myself wanted to give up!

* * *


Before I shut up, a few words about the quotation at the head of my blog. "Use the Force, Luke!" are words that echoed in the thoughts of new-minted Jedi Knight Luke Skywalker as he led the rebels' attack against the Death Star of Darth Vader in the original Star Wars movie in 1977. Luke had learned them from his mentor, old Ben Kenobi, when being trained in the ways of the Force.

Using the Force is, I'd say, a metaphor for the wisdom taught by all our religions, a wisdom that comes down to the values of self-control, discipline, and chastity in the broad sense in which that word is spoken of above. Luke had, or developed, such virtues as a Jedi knight-in-training, in contrast to the gruff dissolution of the lifestyle of Han Solo. Han was by no means evil like Darth Vader; he was good, but as a cynical hothead he was clearly no candidate for Jedi knighthood.

The character of Obi-wan Kenobi made manifest such wisdom and maturity as young Luke was in need of en route to his knighthood. Often, those in the presence of Ben Kenobi would automatically do as the Force would have them do, no matter how much they were customarily in thrall to the Dark Side. That's why I hereby make "Use the Force, Luke!" the epigraph to this blog.

Saturday, April 18, 2009

God of Chastity, Part II

Christopher West's book Theology of the Body for Beginners is an old topic in this blog — see the earlier entries in my Theology of the Body series about the theological outlook espoused by the late Pope John Paul II, as described in West's book — but today I think of it as, for me, new wine in new skin.

John Paul II made it clear that there is nothing profane about combining "theology" with "the body" or "the flesh" ... as in S-E-X. Indeed, the truth is quite the opposite: there is nothing more appropriate to a Christian outlook. There is nothing more important for the Christian to understand than the reason St. Paul could write, in his letter to the Ephesians:

Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her to make her holy, cleansing her by the washing with water through the word, and to present her to himself as a radiant church, without stain or wrinkle or any other blemish, but holy and blameless. In this same way, husbands ought to love their wives as their own bodies. He who loves his wife loves himself. After all, no one ever hated his own body, but he feeds and cares for it, just as Christ does the church — for we are members of his body. "For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh." This is a profound mystery — but I am talking about Christ and the church. (Ephesians 6:25-32)

This makes it sound as if Christ and the church have a "one flesh," i.e., a marital, relationship — as indeed they do! Relationships of the "flesh" — sex — image or reflect the mysterious love of the three persons that make up the Holy Trinity for one another: Father, Son, and Spirit. This is the meaning of sex.

West calls this the "spousal analogy." To Catholics, as I hope to all Christians, analogies are profound tokens of truth. True, God is all spirit, and his three inner persons do not have "sex lives." But God's self-revelation in the Bible, whether Old Testament or New, uses a spousal analogy at just about every turning. Paul, for example, cites one of the earliest verses in the Bible, Genesis 2:24:

For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and they will become one flesh.

The idea that Christ, as the Lamb of God, is the "bridegroom" and the church is his "bride" comes to fruition in one of the last Bible verses, Revelation 19:7:

Let us rejoice and be glad and give him glory! For the wedding of the Lamb has come, and his bride has made herself ready.

All the way through the Bible, the deep, inner nature of the created world, and of us, is shown as being fundamentally nuptial. "Be fruitful and multiply" is not just something that would be nice for us to do. It is our most basic way of being in conformance with the contours God gave his created universe.


So, yes, I've gone over to "the other side" on some very basic things. In modern parlance, I've had a paradigm shift.

The way I know I've had a paradigm shift is that when I saw, on West's p. 14, "Make no mistake: in the final analysis the abortion debate is not about when life begins. It is about the meaning of sex," I finally got it.

The first two times I read the book, that passage did not even merit being highlighted — though I was assiduously highlighting passages all around it. This time, I thought it deserved highlighting not in my customary blue marking pen but in day-glo pink.

"The meaning of sex." Sex has a meaning? A deep, permanent, nature-of-all-things, fundamental significance, as opposed to what two consenting adults happen to be willing to accord to it, at the moment, if not tomorrow, or next week, or next year? The meaning of sex?

It was like the scene in The Blues Brothers where Jake (John Belushi) sees the light:

Jake: "The band ... the band ..."
Rev. Cleophus [James Brown]: "DO YOU SEE THE LIGHT?!"
Jake: "THE BAND!!!"
Rev. Cleophus: "DO YOU SEE THE LIGHT?!!"
Elwood [Dan Aykroyd]: "What light?!"
Rev. Cleophus: "DO YOU SEEEE THE LIGHT?!"
Jake: "YES!! YES!! JESUS H. TAP-DANCING CHRIST ... I HAVE SEEN THE LIGHT!!!"

I finally got it. I saw the light. Sex has a meaning. You can't be a serious Christian, not really, until you are willing to admit it. For years, I was unwilling to admit it.

I had all the data at my disposal: how my church wanted its members to act in accordance with that fundamental outlook; how the outlook permeates the Bible. I just didn't see it. I just didn't want to accept that such a contentious, divisive — and, to me, seemingly peripheral — facet of modern-day living as our "right to sexual freedom" should be allowed to divide people, both within the church and outside it.

But it's not peripheral. It's central. It's make-or-break. Marital fidelity, chastity outside marriage, the male-female union as "one flesh" never to be sundered by man, the time of the beginning of life as periperal to the abortion debate, the reason homosexual unions are against God's plan, the reason casual sex, pornography, and masturbation are wrong ... all these hot-button topics of the present day look different to me, post paradigm shift, than they did before.

I no longer think Christians who — such as I myself did, prior to the shift — think they are complete Christians even though they differ with their tradition on issues of sex, gender, marriage, reproduction, and family are actually finished.


Paradigm shifts are funny. Not ha-ha-funny or peculiar-funny. They are funny because you can't really argue about them, or with them. You either see the new paradigm, or you don't.

In a way, I have "understood" what is now my new paradigm for a long, long time. I just didn't get it.

I understood that the church saw issues of the flesh and the body as crucial, where I simply didn't.

I understood that the Bible uses what West calls the "spousal analogy" throughout ... but I thought of old-fashioned analogies as disposable and dispensible, in the modern world.

I understood that God's revelation of his own nature and truth to us in scripture was timeless ... while mentally striking out those ideas that didn't accord with my own way of looking at things!

So I didn't immediately snap to attention the first time or two I read West's sentence about the abortion debate and the meaning of sex. His thought went right over my head. If someone had brought it to my attention, I would have rejected it or tried to explain it away.

A paradigm shift feels like something snapping into place, something seating itself, in your mind, in just the way it is meant to be. You just know, once you have had it, that you'll never be the same. And, sure, you want to share it with everybody. At the same time, mature reflection tells you that they, too, likely have all the data at hand, and unless something just snaps into place for them, they just aren't going to agree with you. They still have that old paradigm, the one you used to have. Paradigm shifts do not lend themselves to easy solidarity.

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

God of Chastity, Part I

This isn't a particularly easy topic to talk about, but here goes anyway...

Let me put it this way: I believe in God. I also believe that sex should be reserved for marriage. Furthermore, I believe that the truth about God and the truth about chastity, as I'll call the latter, are tightly intertwined.

Once upon a time, it was common knowledge that sex outside marriage was a sin against God. That sex without benefit of marriage was of questionable morality was the understanding I was given as a child in the 1950s, even though I wasn't brought up religious. Then came the Sexual Revolution. Though my contemporaries began availing themselves of "carnal knowledge" at every opportunity — and I was no saint — I never got comfortable with the new idea that "anything goes."

In midlife I became religious for the first time. That was about 20 years ago. But somehow, I never particularly came to believe that being religious necessarily implied being chaste.

Instead, I was of the opinion — see many of my earlier entries in this blog — that the old rules about chastity were passĂ©. Or, at least, they were "optional." They grew out of the same Judeo-Christian tradition that kept women from full equality with men, made abortion and homosexual acts sinful, etc., etc., etc.

Recently, though, I have woken up to the fact that, deep down, I still believe that "family values" are the best values. I never really stopped believing that. I just compartmentalized that idea away from my religious beliefs.

This, despite the fact that I am perfectly well aware, and long have been, that there is no theme more characteristic of Judeo-Christian scripture — the Old Testament and the New — than the sanctity of marriage. It is a bit difficult to detect a "through line" to the narrative of the Bible, but one does seem to be there. In the beginning, Adam and Eve's "marriage" in the Garden of Eden is tainted by Original Sin. In the end, in the Book of Revelation, there is a sacred marriage between Christ, who has come back to this world, and his Church, encompassing all people who are saved.

Along the way, between Genesis and Revelation, we keep getting clues that marriage is sacrosanct. When Abraham and his descendants are told to "be fruitful and multiply," it is within the bounds of marriage that this is to take place. The Old Testament strictures against promiscuity, homosexuality, and masturbation make most sense against this backdrop.

Jesus, with his "one flesh" dictum, took marriage to be sacrosanct. In Matthew 19, we read:

Some Pharisees came to him to test him [Jesus]. They asked, "Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife for any and every reason?" Haven't you read," he replied, "that at the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female,' and said, 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh'? So they are no longer two, but one. Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate."

Though the first post-Resurrection Christians were told by Paul to eschew marriage if they could tolerate celibacy, this seems to have been under the assumption that the Second Coming was imminent and there were, meanwhile, more important things to be done, such as evangelizing the heathen world.

Once the Church began to realize Christ's return might be a long way off, it renewed the ancient Israelite emphasis on the sanctity of marriage, and Paul himself was emphatic in his Letter to the Romans that "anything goes" was not a proper way to worship the Lord. (Paul also wrote in one of his epistles of the need for wives to defer to their husbands ... one of the most resented passages of scripture these days!)

I don't personally claim to know with any certainty how to square scripture with modern-day sexuality is all its most controversial aspects. But I do now claim that it makes no sense to call oneself a Christian or a Jew and not take with the utmost seriousness the claims these religions traditionally make on us to be chaste and to hold marriage sacrosanct.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Theology of the Body, Part 9

Now, yet more in my Theology of the Body (TOB) series about the theological outlook espoused by the late Pope John Paul II, as described in Christopher West's book Theology of the Body for Beginners.

The "theology of the body," as John Paul called it, is all about chastity, the opposite of lust.

According to West, TOB affirms that there is, beyond repression or indulgence, a third way of the heart by which we can redeem our erotic impulses. Once we have found this way, we can turn our sexuality into a sacrament.

That's the good news. The bad news is that it isn't either quick or easy to find the way. Time after time, West writes, we must pray to Jesus to transform our lust. Eventually, if we have enough faith, we will be rewarded.

Self-scrutiny tells me that I personally don't have enough faith for this. And, on a chastity scale from one to ten, where ten is the Virgin Mary, I imagine I'm at least a six. I don't lust in my heart all that much. But I know that some people do, and many who don't haven't found the sacramental third way; rather, they repress and suppress and turn aside from sexual indulgences in deference to what West calls the "negative" rules of purity.

Most good Christians, I believe, are thou-shalt-not Christians.

The theology of the body, accordingly, would seem to be a sort of post-graduate course in the "nuptial meaning of life."


Intellectually, I can see that the Bible affirms such a nuptial meaning. The story begins with Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden. Before the fall from grace that occurs when they eat of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, they innocently live out the original nuptial meaning just as God wants them to, and they are not at all ashamed of their nakedness.

After they eat the forbidden fruit, cover their private parts, and are expelled from Eden, a huge amount of narrative ensues, all focused on the way God interacts with his people in view of their inheritance of Adam and Eve's original sin and their constant infidelity to his worship and will. Eventually, Jesus of Nazareth, a man who was born of a virgin, walks this earth. He teaches us, works miracles, dies on a cross, is resurrected and assumed into heaven, and eventually turns out to have been the Son of God all the time. Finally, at the end of history, his return to us is promised in the Book of Revelation; he will be the Bridegroom, and his redeemed people will be his Bride.

As I say, the Bible as a whole affirms the nuptial meaning of our existence. I can see that intellectually. But I cannot see how the vast bulk of us are really capable of faithfully living that meaning, except in negative, thou-shalt-not terms.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Theology of the Body, Part 8

Now, more in my Theology of the Body series about the "theology of the body" (TOB) espoused by the late Pope John Paul II, as described in Christopher West's book Theology of the Body for Beginners.

In Theology of the Body, Part 7 I described TOB as a way of understanding Christ's redemption of humankind's "original sin." The original sin of Adam and Eve, our mythical forebears in the Book of Genesis, was rooted in lust: exchanging their initial ability to delight in each other sexually, in the context of giving themselves to one another totally, for something much, much less ennobling, and therefore shameful. Lust (even when shared) is self-gratification for its own sake. It blocks us from knowing the "nuptial meaning" of human existence.

I made the case in the prior post that you can match up the process of re-appropriating this nuptial meaning of life with the process of Self-realization laid out by Jung. Given the essential Jungian step which I refer to as "addressing the Anima (or Animus)", the biblical idea that a man and woman must cleave together as "one flesh" receives its secular, psychological interpretation. Two approaches to one great truth, these would seem to be.

The two approaches are united in being more matters of inner personal experience than just believing in psychological formulas or adhering to religious laws. Pope John Paul II talked about how the thing that his theology of the body seeks is not just adherence to an ethic or set of rules concerning sex. Rather, our hearts must be converted to a "new ethos" wherein we no longer desire to break the erstwhile rules.

To gain the inner personal experience we seek, so that we might come to know the "nuptial meaning of the body," is not something that we can expect to happen fully in this lifetime. Fulfillment, in the sense of completion, West writes, comes only in heaven. Yet we can make a start:

As we open ourselves to this gift, the grace of redemption begins to "re-vivify" our humanity, to enliven our hearts with God's own goodness. To the degree that we allow this grace to inform and transform us, God's Holy Spirit impregnates our sexual desires [in John Paul II's words] "with everything that is noble and beautiful," with "the supreme value which is love" ... (pp. 43-44)


My own problem with this is one West addresses in his section "Purity Is Not Prudishness" (pp. 45-47). The problem is this: I don't yet seem to have the ability to find the middle way between lust and prudishness.

I accordingly feel quite encouraged by John Paul's words (written in Love & Responsibility while he was still Karol Wojtyla) to the effect that "mature purity"

consists in quickness to affirm the value of a person in every situation, and in raising [sexual reactions] to the personal level ... (p. 45)


I sort of already know that, but can't always put it into practice ... and so I have found myself adopting a "don't look" policy: don't even produce an occasion of sin by looking at a woman with concupiscence in the first place. As West points out (p. 46), that's a bit like the Old Testament admonition, "Turn away your eyes from a shapely woman" — and it is no more than "a necessary first step," a "negative" and immature purity.

According to John Paul II:

"In mature purity man enjoys the fruits of the victory won over lust." He enjoys the "efficacy of the gift of the Holy Spirit" who restores to his experience of the body "all its simplicity, its explicitness, and also its interior joy" ...

... thus rescuing us from both lust and prudishness at one and the same time!

This means I can expect to discard my "don't look" training wheels real soon now.

Theology of the Body, Part 7

This post represents a re-taking up of my Theology of the Body series from three years ago. The focus of the series is the "theology of the body" espoused by the late Pope John Paul II, as described in Christopher West's book Theology of the Body for Beginners.

In previous installments, I indicated how conflicted I was about what I'll abbreviate as TOB. On the one hand, I felt deeply drawn to it; on the other, repelled by it as a sure way to drive a wedge between true believers and everyone else.

The basic idea of TOB is that there is really nothing more fundamental, in terms of our life in this world, than sex in all its ramifications, and therefore nothing more capable of serving as the taproot of sin than sex. When our original desire to share ourselves fully with one another, man-to-woman and woman-to-man, was perverted into lust, it became our "original sin." Christ's death on a cross and resurrection to life everlasting have redeemed that sin and all its follow-on transgressions fully, assuring us of a place in heaven, but we have to appropriate that redemption willingly, and at some great difficulty, in this life.

The theology of the body, laid out by John Paul II in a series of talks early in his pontificate, is a discourse in how we do that.


Herein, rather than try to lay out the entire complex subject in one blog post, I'd like to try to relate the Holy Father's theology of the body to Jungian psychology.

In my long recent series on Jungian Wholeness and its Addressing the Anima subset, I discussed Jung's ideas about the hidden powers of the unconscious mind: the archetypes, including the Shadow, the Anima, and the Self. The Shadow, I said, betokens the repository of aspects of the psyche that we don't like about ourselves. We don't particularly want to see our sexual avidity as "lust," for instance, so we park "lust" in the unconscious depths, where it becomes part of the Shadow complex.

Jung held that deeper than the Shadow in men lies the archetype called the Anima (the Animus in women). As a feminine component in a masculine personality, the Anima represents a man's ideal for members of the opposite sex. The Animus in women, as a masculine component in a feminine soul, does the same in return. True psychic health demands that at some point the Anima/Animus should be confronted, internally and consciously, but even before that happens, the Anima/Animus typically gets projected outward on a member of the other sex. As a result, we fall in love.

The way we treat our Anima/Animus figure, once we have done so, is intended to be the opposite of lust.

If the healthy sexual desire we have for our beloved turns to lust, or gets smothered by the lust we have for other women or men, we lose the ability to "address the Anima." But addressing the Anima allows "her" (or "him," as the Animus in women is referred to) to guide us in our ultimate search for the Self.

The Self is the one archetype which can unify the psyche. It has a number of aspects which I discussed in earlier posts, including the capability of being symbolized as a Christian cross. For purposes of this post, the Self represents the imago Dei, the "image of God" within us.

Stripped of excess detail, we need to move from being slave to the Shadow (lust) to full expression of the "better angels of our nature" when we address the Anima, either in the guise of our beloved spouse or internally and consciously. That leads us onward to some sort of union with God.

So the Jungian scheme of things would seem to be consistent with John Paul II's theology of the body!

Thursday, December 29, 2005

Theology of the Body, Part 6: The Riddle of the Third Way

Christopher West's Theology of the Body for Beginners: A Basic Introduction to Pope John Paul II's Sexual Revolution is my continuing object of fascination (see Theology of the Body, Part 5: the Transformation of Lust and preceding posts for more).

One of the trickiest things to understand about the message of this book is that there is a hidden, divinely aided third way beyond the pair of strategies for sex which initially must seem to exhaust all possibilities: repress lust, or indulge it.

A person who is blind to the third way, as so many are, would say that the sexual urge is a given. If it is not to be repressed — thereby doing us immeasuarable harm — it must be indulged to the fullest. Since religion opposes sexual indulgence, religion must go.

That's true, as far as it goes. If religion is basically about the repression of lust, then it's bad for us. But West tells us in his book that Pope John Paul II's "theology of the body" hates the repression of lust as much as it despises lustful indulgence!

Repression represents "the trap of 'holding to the form of religion' while 'denying the power of it'" — that is, the power of God, if we give him our assent, to change the way we feel and the way our minds and hearts operate inside us (p. 48; the quotation is from St. Paul's Second Letter to Timothy 3:5). Christ through his death and resurrection can redeem our sexuality. "In other words," writes West, "the death and resurrection of Christ is effective. It can change our lives, our attitudes, our hearts — yes — our sexual desires" (p. 48).


Practically speaking, how does this work? The key thing is primarily for us to switch from following the false lure of self-gratification to preferring "the love of total self-donation" (see p. 29).

The "right kind" of sexual desire is accordingly that which is found in the best marriages: in the conjugal bed, as in the rest of married life, each partner is mainly interested in "donating" his or her own selfish gratification to the needs of the other, to ensure the other's fulfillment.

Self-donation on a wider, not-necessarily-sexual scale is accordingly the keynote of all Christian life ... just as Christ's death on the cross to save the entire world from the wages of sin was the ultimate act of self-donation.


But self-donation, when emphasized all by itself, is but one of two co-equal aspects of the hidden third way. The other aspect — the other manner of describing this marvelous change of heart which depotentiates lust and sin — is to recognize that it can't happen without supernatural help. For our sexual nature to be "redeemed" requires, if we are Christian, that we accept the redemption spoken of by Christians when they refer to Christ's saving death on the cross.

Likewise, God's gift of redemption can equally be spoken of as allowing the Holy Spirit admission into our hearts. Whether spoken of as the indwelling of the Spirit or the salvation of Christ's cross, it all comes down to this: "... 'in a certain way we [according to the Catechism of the Catholic Church] have already risen with Christ' ... Here and now we can begin to experience the redemption of our sexual desires, the gradual transformation of our hearts. It is a difficult and even arduous journey, but one that can be accomplished" (p. 34).

Christ's saving cross and the entry of the Holy Spirit into our hearts together enable us to choose to be self-donating in our sexual and communal lives, while our opting for self-donation over self-gratification is what allows Christ's redemption and the indwelling of the spirit to be effective. The two aspects of the Riddle of the Third Way go with one another hand in glove to change our lives radically, over time, to ones of total commitment to God's plan and sincere self-donation to others.

Monday, December 26, 2005

Theology of the Body, Part 5: The Transformation of Lust

Christopher West's Theology of the Body for Beginners: A Basic Introduction to Pope John Paul II's Sexual Revolution continues to interest me greatly (see Theology of the Body, Part 4: Faith in Analogies and earlier posts for more). As I make my way through it, I become more and more convinced that its message concerning the body and sex is crucial to understanding and living out the Christian faith, Catholic-style.

The message is, it comes as no surprise, one of chastity and purity. There are two equally chaste vocations, the book says: marriage and celibacy. Perhaps surprisingly to some, conjugal chastity typifies the lives of Christian married couples. It includes a lot of healthy sex ... for sex and the body are good, in the Christian view, not sinful.

Nor is celibate chastity — the vocation I seem to be called to — a rejection of sex. Yes, physical sex is freely given up. Yet celibacy, which amounts to choosing to live one's life as a so-called "eunuch for sake of the kingdom of heaven," as Jesus put it at Matthew 19:12, is a calling that "embraces and anticipates 'the heavenly marriage'" (pp. 66-67). That is, celibacy on the part of some of us points all of us toward the beatific vision we will all share of God when we have arrived in heaven.

In turn, a celibate's life here on earth points out to the non-celibates who far outnumber him/her "the ultimate purpose and meaning of sexuality." This is so because in this world of ours "man and woman become one flesh as a sign or 'sacrament' of Christ's eternal union with the Church (see Eph [Paul's Letter to the Ephesians] 5:31-32)."

Celibates who eschew sex and married practitioners of a conjugal chastity which includes a vigorous sex life both "experience the redemption of their sexuality in Christ" (p. 68). In neither case is there repression of lust. Nor is there indulgence in lust. Chastity of either variety is a transformation of lust into something better and purer. Ordained by Christ, chastity, conjugal or otherwise, serves "to restore creation to the purity of its origins" (p. 68). In other words, purity allows us "to experience redemption from the domination of lust" (p. 69).


Therein, a capsule summary of the entire Christian outlook. Broadly speaking , all sin is lust — though, of course, it is not always sexual lust — and lust of any variety is sin. The point of the whole Christian exercise is to break free from sin, which after all is said and done, is always "the domination of lust."

Which makes Pope John Paul II's theology of the body central to Christian spirituality. There is a riddle here not unlike Zen's "What is the sound of one hand clapping?" It is this: How can there be a third, entirely constructive way to deal with our lust, in addition to repression and indulgence, both of which are destructive?

How can there be a difference, that is, between repression and the healthy self-denial which even married couples must practice, if lust is to be avoided? How can strong sexual desire manifest itself rightly ... especially in the life of the celibate who has no sexual relations and whose sacrifice is accordingly total?

West spells it out (p. 73): "... [T]he self-denial involved in such a sacrifice [i.e., celibacy] must not be conceived as a repression of sexuality. Celibacy for the kingdom [i.e., heaven, as the kingdom of God] is meant to be a fruitful living out of the redemption of sexual desire, understood as the desire to make of oneself a 'sincere gift' for others."

The same is true for married people. Their mode of redeeming their sexual desire also serves to liberate healthy expressions of sex from lust. It too enables the marrieds' making a "sincere gift" of themselves to others: to the other spouse, to their children, to their larger family, to the community as a whole.

So the "self-donation" which a husband makes to his wife in their bedchamber, and which she of course makes back to him, stands as an archetype for all the "sincere gifts" a person makes to other persons ... which is why the idea of the redemption of lust can be construed as lying at the very heart of Christianity!