Showing posts with label Chastity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chastity. Show all posts

Friday, August 30, 2013

"Twerk" on MTV, Miley Cyrus Did

In 2013, 'twerk' was added to the Oxford Dictionary Online. The dictionary said the word had been around for 20 years, but the evidence for it to be included in the dictionary had tipped the scale when U.S. pop star Miley Cyrus gave a controversial and headline-producing twerking dance at the MTV Video Music Awards on August 25, 2013.

— Wikipedia          

The verb "twerk," says the Oxford dictionary, means "dance to popular music in a sexually provocative manner involving thrusting hip movements and a low, squatting stance."

Much debate ensued after Miley Cyrus "twerked" onscreen at MTV. Was her performance appropriate, the multitudes asked, or not?

Miley Cyrus on MTV
More Miley

I say not. My thought is that it extended a long-term trend a bridge too far. When I was in college at Georgetown in the late 1960s, the university enforced a rule against "public display of affection": no kissing or petting outdoors or in public view. The more general rule, at G'town and in society, was that sex is to be kept private. If it's sexual, hide it from public view.

The rule was coming apart at the seams even then. It had been doing so for decades, going back to the ending of the Victorian era of the final two-thirds of the nineteenth century. "Victorian morality can describe any set of values that espouse sexual restraint, low tolerance of crime and a strict social code of conduct," says Wikipedia. Strict restraints on sexual attitudes and behavior meant men and women wore clothes that covered all and that emphasized nothing that might arouse sexual feelings. Sex obviously happened, and a lot of it was downright illicit. There's no doubt about it. But it was done in private.

My generation was not the first to rebel, but in our own nineteen-sixties sexual revolution the gloves — and much else besides — came all the way off. Ample justification was given: that getting rid of repression and of hypocrisy would make society and its citizens all that much healthier.

Now we have a 20-year-old former child star looking to extend her something-very-like-a-career by a twerking display on TV. We have rampant sexual abuse in the U.S. military. "More than 70% of male Internet users from 18 to 34," according to Wikipedia, "visit a pornographic site in a typical month." Priestly child sexual abuse has racked the Catholic Church. Scandal after scandal has cut short a host of political careers and besmirched the memory of one of the most revered of college football coaches.

All because sex is, I believe, now more public than private. Not the act itself (at least for the most part) buts its hintings, simulacra, and accouterments.

You might think — and a lot of people actually do think — there's no reason why the loosening of nineteenth-century moral strictures that was supposed to make us saner would instead be making us sicker. You might think that between Queen Victoria's corsetings and Miley's MTV cavortings there ought to be a sweet spot which society can occupy, with only a few depraved outliers to either side of the sensible median strip.

It hasn't happened. The depraved outliers are everywhere. So I'd say we need to rein ourselves in. The only way to do that, I think, is to take sex back into the privacy of the boudoir an keep it under demure covers.

How might that happen? We need to start by shrinking the boundary of personal behavior that is considered appropriate. I have in mind, to begin with, a new reticence about stuff that really isn't all that naughty, in the grand scheme of things. For example: no posterior anatomy visible for guys with low-slung belt lines; no visible bra straps for gals. Start with tiny little things like those.

Start with making this taboo ...

... and this.

Whoa! I hear voices raised in protest already. These infractions are, to the extent they are sexual displays at all, very minor ones. They are matters of personal choice and free individual expression. Every generation since Victoria passed away in 1901 has shown more and more anatomy, more and more underwear, and where do you draw the line? Isn't this all just a Trojan horse for a thoroughgoing new Victorianism?

I hope not. But it isn't at all clear to me that there really exists a viable sweet spot between Victorian deprivation and no-holds-barred depravity — it has to be one that the bulk of us can hold to — unless it is also one that abhors (for example) hordes of us "sexting" up a storm or assiduously "tweeting our junk" at every conceivable opportunity. Such activities are not necessarily immoral but, as I hope we are learning, they straddle the increasingly invisible line between public and private. Which is why we all now know so well the name of former-Rep. Anthony Weiner.

So, no more "sexting." No more "tweeting our junk." No more peeking-out bra straps. No more visible vertical smiles. And no more of the many other "innocent" behaviors that put us on a slippery slope to less-minor infractions and then to much more that is far worse.

Notice that I am saying nothing about what can or ought to happen between consenting adults in their bedroom or boudoir. I make no claim to knowing what kinds of sex are quote-unquote bad, or, for that matter, good. All I am saying is give sexual privacy a fighting chance. Keep sex, its stand-ins, its simulacra, and its accouterments well out of public view, and we will see whether I am right and the abuses diminish.


Tuesday, August 28, 2012

The Need for Centeredness

My recent posts have revolved around society and sexuality:

Where Does the Urge to Rape Come From?
Lessons from "The Sex Lady"
Uncommitted Sex? Just Say No!
Our Baser Selves
The Procreative Norm

I think our society is way off balance — when it comes to sex, and when it comes to a lot of other things.



Another way to put it is that we are way off-center, and we need to be a lot more centered.

We need more self-respect and more respect for others. If we are off-center in our lives, it's a struggle to be respectful of others' needs, because we don't even understand our own needs.

Urges are not the same thing as needs. Urges can pull us off-center. True needs will not.

We are off-center as individuals, and we are off-center as a society and a culture. If the culture were more on-center, there wouldn't be as many rapes. There wouldn't be as many unwanted pregnancies and abortions. Not as many relationships that end in breakups and divorces. Not as many instances of domestic violence. Not as much child sexual abuse.


And, taking this out of the realm of sex, there wouldn't be as many tragic shootings by crazed individuals with guns.

Nor would there be as much crime in general. Most crime comes from individuals who think they have a right to something that only breaking the law can get them. That kind of self-centeredness is the exact opposite of the centeredness I'm talking about.

Most of us keep our baser behavior patterns in check, most of the time. Most of the time, we are kind to and respectful of others. Most of the time, we don't do wild things that may make us feel good in the short run, but then inevitably wind up making us feel sorry in the long run. Most of the time, we don't disrespect or bully people who "aren't like us."

But then sometimes we do stuff that we wouldn't do, most of the time. Stuff we "shouldn't" do, but we do anyway — some of the time.

Why do we act so schizoid? Why do there seem to be two different people inside our skins?

It's a sign of being off-center.

And how often do we seem to get pulled off-center by such things as pressure from our peers, as well as by the stuff we and they see every day online, or on TV, or at the movies. The whole culture seems to be conspiring to pull everybody off-center, over into our baser selves ...

... where the urge arises to fight, to snarl, to be snarky, to exhibit hostility ...

... and to behave sexually in less than a "chaste" way ...

... to act as if the world is out to hold us down, to keep us from the pursuit of what we imagine to be our happiness ...

... and so we get cynical about so-called "good" behavior. People who are good and generous and kind are simply pretending "the dark side" isn't there. They'll surely end up losers.


Whatever name you prefer to call "the dark side" of human nature and human behavior, it recedes into the background when individuals and the society as a whole are on-center.

A certain number of people today seem to have bought into the idea that the dark side might even conceivably "save the planet."

How ironic! When the phrase "the dark side" entered the language back in 1977, from the first Star Wars movie, no such idea was meant or implied. It's a sign that we have become ever more off-center that this notion of a heroic "dark side" has taken hold today.

We live in an age of irony. In every aspect of life, we feel like we serve two masters, the "Force" that Luke Skywalker learned to "feel" as a budding Jedi knight, and the "dark side" that the evil Darth Vader epitomized. We mostly triangulate between the two, which is manifestly the cause for our overarching sense of irony today.

Most of us surf those roiled waters just fine, thank you very much ... most of the time. We may not be centered in any spiritual sense, but we do manage to keep our balance.

But "balanced" and "centered" aren't the same thing.

Balanced and cynically ironic about it, are we: it's a sure sign that we need centering.

As individuals, being balanced between our inner Luke Skywalker and our inner Darth Vader clearly "works" for us ... most of the time.

I see the problem as the effect on the culture of too much balancing and too little centering. We often feel we are balancing precariously, with one foot hanging over the edge of chaos. Some of us occasionally go over the edge. Others of us go permanently over the edge.

These are the rapists and sex offenders, the serial killers and crazies with hair-trigger fingers and loaded semiautomatic weapons, the people whose terminal self-centeredness makes them stony-faced criminals and cheats. There are way too many of them because of too much balancing and too little centering in the broader culture.

What centers us? It used to be our spirituality that did it. Spirituality, that is, that was anchored in religion. Religion tethered us to an ethos, a shared sense of right and wrong. As we shared it with one another, our centering came from God. We were a God-centered people.

Now, not so much.

Now we often find we need to take extraordinary measures just to keep our balance. This is where the free-floating anger just under the surface of our lives comes from. For some of us, it's right on the surface a good deal of the time. We get righteously angry, and it makes us feel so much better for a while.

If that doesn't work, we can always try bullying someone.

Or stalking someone.

Or tearing someone to shreds in a "flame war" online.

How often that word, "war," crops up today! We hear of a "war on drugs," a "war on poverty," a "war on terror," a "war on women." Conflict and mortal combat are constant metaphors in movies, in television, in sports contests, in the video games we play.

It was not always thus. War/conflict/combat themes didn't used to be omnipresent. Throw a dart at the monthly program guide of the Turner Classic Movies channel and the chances of hitting a old movie where somebody gets killed are at most fifty-fifty.

There were the World War Two movies, of course. They were more about people sacrificing, people standing together, people serving with honor, than they were about superheroes — imaginary stand-ins for each of us personally — saving the world from Armageddon.

We used to have something that kept us on-center without our having to imaginatively enact our own personal mortal combat situations over and over and over.

That something used to be religion. What are we going to replace it with?


Monday, August 13, 2012

Lessons from "The Sex Lady"

Deborah Roffman has been dubbed "The Sex Lady" for her strong advocacy for teaching kids about sex the right way. Here's an example:



Baltimore Sun columnist Susan Reimer, in "'The Sex Lady' offers lessons for parents" in today's edition, writes glowingly about Roffman and her new book. Roffman's book is titled Talk to Me First: Everything You Need to Know to Become Your Kids' "Go-To" Person about Sex. Reimer lauds Roffman for the way "she employs the fundamental elements of parenting — affirmation, information, clarity about values, limits and guidance — and applies them to a child's developing sexuality."

I don't claim to know much about teaching kids about sex. My reaction to Reimer's column is, however, one of great concern. Reimer writes that so much has changed in "the four decades Deborah Roffman has taught [children] about their bodies," and that:

... the only thing that hasn't changed is the discomfort of their parents when they try to talk about sex. Even the sex has changed, becoming casual and transactional, invasive and pervasive. Marketing and advertising have driven the mercury higher. Technology has put sex only a touch or a keystroke away. "The boundaries that used to separate children's lives from adults' lives have in many respects vanished," said Ms. Roffman ...

And, per Roffman:

"We spent the 20th century carving out the stages of child development, and marketers have managed to collapse them. Now 8-year-olds are just short 14-year-olds. And 14-year-olds are just short 20-year-olds."

I know this much: there was a time in human history when the line between childhood innocence and adult sexual maturity was a clear one. It was crossed at the appropriate age by virtue of initiation ceremonies that were once part and parcel of religions. For example, Jewish bar mitzvah ceremonies, as originally conceived, were when a young male of the species could finally say (in Hebrew) "Now I am a man" ... and mean it!

The treatment of young women was somewhat different, since the onset of menstruation is in itself a threshold. But the point is that there was a threshold, and religions enforced it.

Not today. Our religions seem to have yielded to the general culture and "dumbed down" the whole concept behind thresholds, confirmations, bar mitzvahs, and religious initiations in general. Or maybe it's that the secular culture has drowned out our religions' ancient messages.

So now we hear from Reimer that Hoffman:

... writes with candor about ... the 12-year-old who announces to her stunned father that she will be going to parties this school year and she will probably be performing oral sex when she gets there.

Say what? Seventh-grade girls going to parties and performing oral sex? When I was in seventh grade, at a class party in 1959, I kissed a girl (her name was Carol Scott) for the first time, and considered myself bold for having done so. My how times have changed ...

... for the worse.

I agree with Roffman in the video above that "abstinence only" sex education in schools is not the answer, and that an admirable goal is to bring up children to be able to think clearly about sex. The goal of "chastity," mentioned in passing by Roffman, is, I agree, not the same as the goal of "abstinence." As I define chastity, though, it is a matter of "just saying no" in specific situations because you have made a personal choice to do so. So I think I have to disagree with Roffman's words in the video, to the extent that she seems to believe "abstinence only" actually means "chastity" — which she thinks is an inappropriate goal.

I'd say there still needs to be a threshold of maturity on the early side of which "just say no" is a rule, not a choice. Our sex-drenched culture, as Reimer says, obliterates that threshold ... mainly, I'd say, because sex sells products (left).

So I think we need to make at least three changes in our culture. One, as Reimer and Roffman say, we need to teach our kids about sex the right way. Two, we need to give our pre-teen children back their childhood by insisting on the old-fashioned rules concerning bodies and sex. Three, we need to get our churches and religions back on the same page with us, and us with them, because without religion's underpinnings for sexuality's thresholds, there is no earthly reason why 8-year-olds should not consider themselves short 14-year-olds.



Saturday, August 11, 2012

Uncommitted Sex? Just Say No!

I've been struggling to come up with a way to say how I personally feel about the rights and wrongs of sex. What I have finally arrived at is this, as at least Step 1 toward attaining the ideal of thoroughgoing chastity: Just say no to uncommitted sex.

Committed sex is, quite obviously, what is normally associated with a married heterosexual couple. In contradiction of Catholic orthodoxy, I would extend it to all committed couples, straight or gay, whether legally married or not.

Uncommitted sex is every other kind. According to my ethics for sex, extramarital sex is out. Premarital sex, unless the couple is in a committed relationship, is out. Recreational sex: out. Group sex: out. "Friends with privileges" sex: out. Pick-up Friday night sex: out. Pornography: out. Voyeurism: out. Masturbation: out.

That's Step 1. The next step, Step 2, would have to address the tender question of what exactly the couple's commitment entails. Is it a commitment to each other, and nothing more? Or is it a commitment to their existing (if any) and potential children? To their families, friends, and loved ones? To the larger society? To God?

The Catholic Church's answer: all of the above.

The Church forbids the couple — if obedient Catholics — to forestall pregnancy using artificial means such as contraceptive pills and condoms. Step 3 in the search for chastity would have to address this question.

My answer is a tentative one. I've never been married, never had to worry about pregnancy. If I were in that position, though, I think I'd hope my wife and I could agree to try for successful management of fertility via Natural Family Planning.

NFP, according to the Couple to Couple League, involves determining when the woman is fertile and able to become pregnant, and avoiding having sex during that time. Her body temperature and certain other symptoms of her fertile time of the month can be measured as clues to when not to have sex. Also, after a baby is born, breastfeeding can postpone the return of her monthly cycle for several months and thus postpone the possibility of another pregnancy.

Clearly, NFP is based on the couple willingly remaining chaste during her fertile periods.

Step 4? It would seem to be the time when we ask whether commitment demands an actual marriage ceremony. Ideally, I think it does, as long as it's seen as a way to cement the commitment that already exists between the two people.

All this says nothing about how sex is done, when it's done. That would be a matter for Step 5, which would take up the vexed questions of the appropriateness of:

  1. Oral sex
  2. Anal sex
  3. Sado-masochistic sex
  4. The use of sex toys
  5. Phone sex
  6. Internet sex
  7. "Sexting"
  8. Etc., etc., etc.

Getting back to Step 1, I think it's something we all need to think about. Our culture today tolerates — nay, encourages — sex without commitment. It's thought of as normal and natural, while looking for Mr. or Ms. Right, to have casual sex at the drop of a hat. When Mr. or Ms. Right comes along, though, we find it hard to break the habit. Result: lots of breakups, lots of divorces. Chastity, I think, demands that we choose to break the habit now, before it breaks up a happy relationship. Or, better yet, never acquire it in the first place.



Tuesday, January 26, 2010

"Rise in teenage pregnancy rate spurs new debate"

The epigraph to this rededicated blog has been changed. It is now a quote from Mere Christianity by C.S. Lewis:

Chastity is the most unpopular of the Christian virtues. There is no getting away from it; the Christian rule is, "Either marriage, with complete faithfulness to your partner, or else total abstinence."

"Rise in teenage pregnancy rate spurs new debate on arresting it," an article from today's The Washington Post, plays off Lewis's sentiment about chastity and abstinence in ways that the greatest explainer of Christian belief of the 20th century could not have anticipated. Lewis died in 1963 before the "sexual revolution" had entrenched itself in the culture. Mere Christianity was the outgrowth of BBC radio talks made between 1941 and 1944, while Lewis, a Britisher, was an academic at Oxford during World War II.

Now, less than half a century later,

The abortion rate among teenagers rose 1 percent in 2006 from the previous year — to 19.3 abortions per 1,000 women in that age group, the analysis [of the most recent data collected by the federal government and the nation's leading reproductive-health think tank] found. Taking that and miscarriages into account, the analysis showed that the pregnancy rate among U.S. women younger than 20 in 2006 was 71.5 per 1,000 women, a 3 percent increase from the rate of 69.5 in 2005. That translated into 743,000 pregnancies among teenagers, or about 7 percent of women in this age group.
has become a news item to be consumed with the morning cereal. In Lewis's time there was not such frank talk about adults', much less teenagers', sex lives.

In the year Lewis died, 1963, although teen pregnancies and teen births were already high in the U.S. by the historical standards of the time, the culture had not yet begun to rely heavily on sex education in the public schools to rein in teen sexual expression. I was a (male) teenager of 16 in that year. The persons we now speak of as "women under age 20" were, at the time, still "girls." The rule was, "Nice girls don't."

In those now seemingly halcyon days, I never had a "sex ed" course, though I believe girls were getting some preliminary form of it in junior high school gym classes under the topic of "hygiene." I wound up in private school by 9th grade, so maybe I just missed it.

Today, those who say sex-ed courses should teach the use of condoms and other birth control methods duke it out with those who want an "abstinence only" curriculum.

I would recommend "chastity only," not "abstinence only." Abstinence per se is not a virtue; chastity is. Abstinence is a negative; chastity is a positive.

The purpose of a public school education is to instill in children the virtues they need to possess if they are going to be good citizens. Not just some of the virtues, all of them. And chastity is one of them.

C.S. Lewis continued, in his essay on chastity:

I want to make it as clear as I possibly can that the centre of Christian morality is not here. If anyone thinks that Christians regard unchastity as the supreme vice, he is quite wrong. The sins of the flesh are bad, but they are the least bad of all sins. All the worst pleasures are purely spiritual: the pleasure of putting other people in the wrong, of bossing and patronising and spoiling sport, and back-biting, the pleasures of power, of hatred. For there are two things inside me, competing with the human self which I must try to become. They are the Animal self, and the Diabolical self. The Diabolical self is the worse of the two. That is why a cold, self-righteous prig who goes regularly to church may be far nearer to hell than a prostitute. But, of course, it is better to be neither.

I think Lewis (pictured at right) was right about one thing here, but wrong about another. He was right to suggest that the Diabolical self can turn us into self-righteous prigs, or as Jesus put it in one of the Gospels, Matthew 23:27, into "whitewashed tombs ... full of dead men's bones and everything unclean." In other words, the worst kind of hypocrites.

But Lewis was wrong to suggest that "the pleasure of putting other people in the wrong, of bossing and patronising and spoiling sport, and back-biting, the pleasures of power, of hatred" are in a different category than the pleasures of the flesh. We have seen, in the years since Lewis wrote, the opening up of the culture to unfettered sexuality. We have also seen a huge rise in all of the ostensibly non-sexual offenses Lewis mentions above.

Think about Internet "flame wars." Think about vitriolic talk radio. Think about all the current furor over the "culture of power in Washington D.C." Think about the naked hatred that seems to be fueling much of our politics today. They suggest that maybe, just maybe, a lack of sexual chastity in the culture morphs inevitably into a lack of chastity in general.

In fact, I think that is exactly what recent history proves. If I'm right, then we all need to reclaim the notion that chastity, sexual and otherwise, lies at the very core of Judeo-Christian belief and practice.

If the monotheistic religions of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam teach the fundamental sanctity of nuptial sex — and all do — then we need to listen to them again. We need to bring their conceptions of virtue back into currency in the "public square." We need to make them once again the foundation-stones of our civic virtue.


* * *



Since the above was posted, Study: Abstinence sex-ed works appeared on the front page of The Washington Post. A scientific study published in the Archives of Pediatric & Adolescent Medicine has shown that abstinence-only sex education programs for sixth and seventh graders can result in fewer children becoming sexually active in the ensuing two years.

As a Catholic, I see that as the cup being half full. On the one hand, it counters the assertions that have recently held sway to the effect that abstinence education is a big flop. On the other hand, it apparently says nothing about abstinence-only programs that "take a moralistic tone, as many abstinence programs do. Most notably, the sessions [under study] encouraged children to delay sex until they are ready, not necessarily until married; did not portray sex outside marriage as never appropriate; and did not disparage condoms.

Would "moralistic" abstinence programs that advocate delaying sex until marriage, not having sex outside marriage at all, and not using artificial means of birth control fare as well? Or perhaps even better? Those important questions are beyond the scope of the study ...

Sunday, January 24, 2010

Rededicating This Blog Yet Again!

An occasional topic of this blog has been Christian chastity. In this blog and in my personal commitments, I've been wobbly about chastity in the past, in terms of what it means, of how important it is (or isn't) to the Christian. Of late I've come to realize that chastity lies at the core of Christian belief and practice.

Sexual chastity, in particular. There are all sorts of promiscuity, and all sorts of its opposite, chastity. But the word chastity calls to mind, mainly, sexual restraint.

Ever since I've been a Christian at all, and it's been some 30 years since I was baptized, I've not been particularly chaste. Nor have I been particularly promiscuous. I've been somewhere in between, and I've rationalized it by imagining that questions of chastity and promiscuity are peripheral to being a good Christian in this day and age.

Wrong.

It's just that, today, in this modern world, traditional Christian beliefs about such things as the sanctity of married, one-man-one-woman, sexually exclusive fidelity have become so much more "radical" than they ever were before that I wanted to believe that some kind of a new dispensation had arrived from God. We could be good, holy, loving-of-others Christians while setting aside the old rules about sex.

I've reformed my views. Why? Because I finally came to see that I've harbored those old views all my life, while at the same time not admitting to others, or myself, that I did.

It's easy to juggle internal contradictions like that — until such time as you realize you've been doing so. I've always absolutely adored the idea of a man and a woman finding one another, pairing off for life under the auspices of holy wedlock, coming to each other as virgins on their wedding night, cherishing each other for the rest of time (and beyond). It's even better when their union produces abundant children whom they love, and who love them back. And so it goes, from generation to generation.

Except, today, it doesn't work that way. Not all the time.

Still, it happens often enough (well, maybe not the virgins-on-their-wedding-night part) that the ancient pattern is not lost to view. Yet the deviations from the pattern are so ubiquitous today that they seem "normal" and the pattern itself seems "outdated" and "quaint."

That's one reason why I say that belief in the sanctity of the pattern is "radical." Another reason has to do with the root meaning of "radical," which is, of course, "of or pertaining to the root." For I have finally put it together in my mind that the old ideas about sexual chastity and holiness lie at the root of Judeo-Christian beliefs.

If you go back to the Hebrew Bible — Christians call it the Old Testament — you find just about every story laced with allusions to sex and marriage. In Genesis alone: Adam and Eve; Abraham and Sarah; Jacob and Rachel (pictured at left), and so on. Even on the Ark "two of every sort [of animal]...male and female" are Noah's passengers.

In the New Testament we learn that Jesus was born of Mary after God's angel visited her and told her that she, though a virgin, would conceive by the Holy Spirit.

Why all the marital imagery?

Catholic theology holds that in the One God in Three Persons — in the Most Holy Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit — the Persons are related in a way that human marriage and procreation reflect. From the love between the Father and His only-begotten Son proceeds the Holy Spirit. Though this divine love is not sexual, human sexual love and procreation mirror it.

If this is so, then our chastity is favored by the very weave of the fabric of reality. God wove reality in a way that makes wrong the sorts of promiscuity we claim the "right" to freely embrace today.

If we don't like the "weave of reality" metaphor, we can put it differently: Reality is so deeply colored by God's insistence on chastity that it might as well have been dyed that way ... and, shucks, I guess we're back to the metaphor of reality as a fabric that God has woven and given indelible color to.

Another try: God in effect "tattoos" reality with a mark of His holiness, but we are blind to it unless we use sex aright.

But why? It seems more logical that the prevailing wisdom today — that we are "free" to have sex of any type we want, with whatever consenting adults we choose — would be correct. Why would sexual license be responsible for so much of the world's pain?

Don't believe me? Just watch The Maury Povich Show when "Who's My Baby's Daddy?" is its theme, as it so frequently is.

Or, think about the approximately 46 million abortions that are performed worldwide every year. According to this page, 1.21 million induced abortions were performed in the United States in 2005, down from 1.31 million in 2000. From 1973 through 2005, more than 45 million legal abortions occurred in the U.S. Each abortion, wherever it occurs, is a tragedy. Even abortion doctors admit that their patients are anything but blithe as they enter and, after the procedure, leave the clinic.

That observation alone does not make abortions, though deemed legal and permissible by modern society, morally wrong. But it tells me that the general social situation of which the high incidence of abortion is but a symptom represents a veritable cultural sickness. Purposely killing the baby in your own womb is something that should happen rarely if ever. Yet it is anything but rare.

Again, why? Why is the current sexual permissiveness so hard on us? If sex is natural and normal in great variety and quantity, as we are told today, why does it so often put us in situations of regret?

My answer is that permissiveness goes against the grain of reality. No wonder it gives us so many splinters.

And that, to me, bespeaks the existence of God. Why would there be an anti-permissive grain to reality at all, unless that reality reflects at its deepest level something about the inner nature of the God who fashioned it?

Monday, May 18, 2009

Rites of Initiation

Something human culture used to do well, but doesn't do well anymore, are rites of initiation by virtue of which children at about the time of puberty are ushered into adulthood.

Mythology guru Joseph Campbell told Bill Moyers in The Power of Myth about the need for puberty rites (p. 8):
Moyers: Society has provided [young people] no rituals by which they become members of the tribe, of the community. All children need to be twice born, to learn to function rationally in the present world, leaving childhood behind. I think of that passage in the first book of Corinthians: "When I was a child, I spake as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child: but when I became a man, I put away childish things."

Campbell: That's exactly it. That's the significance of the puberty rites. In primal societies, there are teeth knocked out, there are scarifications, there are circumcisions, there are all kinds of things done. So you don't have your little baby body anymore, you're something else entirely.
(You can read more from the book in this MySpace blog entry; scroll down about halfway for this quote. Or, click here to search inside the book; enter "initiation" in the search field.)

Though I am not Jewish, I am, by Campbell's mention of circumcisions, put in mind of the Bar Mitzvah/Bat Mitzvah ceremony at which a 12-year-old girl or 13-year-old boy participates for the first time as an adult in the regular Sabbath service. In today's Judaism it has become a big deal, not unlike a combination of the First Holy Communion and Confirmation sacraments in the Catholic Church, but bigger still.

Jewish boys (but not girls) are ritually circumcised, not at puberty, but within a few days after birth.

Possibly (see this Wikipedia article) male circumcision originated as a rite of passage marking a boy's entrance into adulthood, though other intents have been cited as well. Campbell seems to favor the "rite of passage" interpretation. He also mentions "scarifications," the imposition of scars on the skin to signify the passage into adulthood. Modern civilization toned down the rites of passage such that by the time of Campbell's youth in some 100 years ago, the conferring of the right to wear long pants stood in for circumcisions and scarifications.

Today, in the hip hop generation, we find adult males wearing short pants in situations which would seem to demand trousers.

Campbell further tells Moyers (p. 82):
As a Catholic boy, you choose your confirmed name, the name you are going to be confirmed by. But instead of scarifying you and knocking your teeth out and all, the bishop gives you a smile and a slap on the cheek. It has been reduced to that. Nothing has happened to you. The Jewish counterpart is the bar mitzvah. Whether it actually works to effect a psychological transformation will depend on the individual case, I suppose. But in those old days there was no problem. The boy came out with a different body, and he had really gone through something.
Also (pp. 81-82):
... we know what the aborigines do in Australia. Now, when a boy gets to be a little bit ungovernable, one find day the men come in, and they are naked except for stripes of white bird down that they've stuck on their own bodies using their own blood for glue. They are swinging the bull-roarers, which are teh voices of spirits, and the men arrive as spirits.

The boy will try to take refuge with his mother, and she will pretend to try to protect him. But the men just take him away. A mother is no good from then on, you see. You can't go back to Mother, you're in another field.

Then the boys are taken out to the men's sacred ground, and they're really put through an ordeal — circumcision, subincision [a modification of the urethral opening of the penis], the drinking of men's blood, and so forth. Just as they had drunk mother's milk as children, now they drink men's blood. They're being turned into men. While this is going on, they are being shown enactments of mythological episodes from the great myths. They are instructed in the mythology of the tribe. Then, at the end of this, they are brought back to the village, and the girl whom each is to marry has already been selected. The boy has now come back as a man.

He has been removed from his childhood, and his body has been scarified, and circumcision and subincision have been enacted. Now he has a man's body. There's no chance of relapsing back to boyhood after a show like that.

Moyers: You don't go back to Mother.

Campbell: No, but in our life we don't have anything like that. You can have a man forty-five years old still trying to be obedient to his father. So he goes to a psychoanalyst, who does the job for him.
This gives us profound understanding as to why there is a "maturity gap" today.

Self-Policing Freedom

Nils Lofgren, Taking Memos From the Boss appears in today's Washington Post. It gives several quotes from that ace guitarist in Bruce Springsteen's E Street Band, Nils Lofgren. In answer to the question, "There's some controversy surrounding the show here. TicketsNow, the Ticketmaster-owned reseller, sold some tickets to the show that it didn't have, leaving some fans in the lurch. Do you follow that sort of news at all?", Mr. Lofgren says:

Not too much. . . . I read what Bruce commented about it, how wrong it was, and I'm obviously in total agreement. Listen, that's why the whole planet's getting run down, because of greed and freedom gone unchecked. Sadly, there's people that aren't burdened with a conscience. Greed is king. We don't police those people well enough as a society, and that obviously has to change or things are just going to keep getting worse. This is just a microcosm of what's wrong with the planet. Look at Bernie Madoff.

America to me is the greatest country in the world and the greatest experiment in freedom we'll ever have. But our forefathers, I'm sure, expected us to police freedom appropriately. In other words, you shouldn't have freedom to pipe in porn to kids' computers . . . You shouldn't have freedom to murder and pillage and get out on good behavior in seven years. What the hell is that about? That's the great challenge of society, is to police freedom appropriately. It's not happening at the moment.

An important question, policing freedom appropriately. At first, "policing freedom" sounds like an oxymoron, a contradiction in terms. This blog maintains that the best way to resolve the tension between freedom and policing is self-policing.

In Rededicating This Blog I talked about words such as self-control, maturity, forbearance, and chastity. Self-policing is a good umbrella term for all of those.

To be an adult is to have the ability, ostensibly, to self-police ... which is why Mr. Lofgren bemoans the "freedom to pipe in porn to kids' computers." Adults have the right to look at porn on their computers. They also have the right to forbear looking at porn. In my earlier post, I gave "an abstaining from the enforcement of a right" as a definition of both forbearance and chastity. It could also be given as a definition of the umbrella term, self-policing.

Self-policing is impossible for the immature. For those with just a little bit of maturity, self-policing is a hit-or-miss proposition. For the truly mature, self-policing is a given.

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Rededicating This Blog

This blog is being renamed and rededicated! Once named "In Search of Solidarity," it is now called "In Search of Maturity." (It also has a new look.)

The change is fitting for several reasons. One is that this blogger will turn 62 this year. Quite obviously, if he doesn't gain some sort of maturity at this point in his life, he never will.

Second, I have, finally, in fact turned a corner on my own personal maturity. The maturity I am in search of is actually more that of others in the society and culture, particularly younger people.

Third, as a result of that indefinable something finally falling into place for me personally, in the last few months — as if a capstone has at last been dropped into a waiting arch — what has come into focus for me is the idea that our culture presently suffers from a massive "maturity gap." I'd like to do what I can to help close that gap.


To close the gap is hard, in part because defining the gap and demonstrating that it exists is hard. I would like to begin by citing Don't Eat the Marshmallow!, an earlier post to this blog. The thrust of that post was that an article recently in The New Yorker, "Don't!", furnishes evidence about something I consider to be a near-synonym of maturity, self-control.

Specifically, science has found that self-control is a thing that we can develop, but often fail to. We're not stuck with however much or little we are born with.

Scientists have experimented with children as young as four and found wide disparities in their ability to delay eating a marshmallow or Oreo cookie placed before them while their adult supervisor attends to an errand outside the room. When told to ring a bell if they can't wait any longer, some do and some don't speed up the instant of gratification, with those who don't ever ring the bell and who thus duly put off eating the goodie getting the promised reward of an extra goodie, once the adult returns.

And some children not only don't wait, they don't even bother to ring the bell. They just snatch the goodie and consume it. Some even find a way to (seemingly) fool the adult: lick the cream filling out of an Oreo and reassemble it to escape detection.

Experimenters have looked into the later lives of the impatient "low delayers" (these experiments were originally conducted in the late 1960s) and found that some have become "high delayers," and that these lucky individuals have had more successful lives than the perennial snatchers and grabbers who never learned to postpone gratification.


I would argue that the ability to postpone gratification is the essence of maturity, by whatever name you wish to call it: self-control, self-discipline, self-denial, etc.

I would further suggest that another name for the same phenomenon is "chastity." Here is a word, I know, that immediately rings bells and sounds loud buzzers in the culture, for the first thing it brings to mind is sexual forbearance. Isn't that type of forbearance something the culture gratefully laid to rest in the 1960s? Isn't it the general (and proper) understanding today that sex by and between consenting adults is perfectly fine, whatever the circumstances of those adults?

My response:

First of all, chastity, properly understood, is more than sexual forbearance. It is (as is forbearance per se) a word that means "a refraining from something; patient endurance; self-control; an abstaining from the enforcement of a right." To be chaste is to be pure and virtuous, stainless and undefiled. Obviously, abstaining from the wrong sorts of sex is a big part of chastity, but it's only the tip of the iceberg. There are plenty of ways for someone who is totally celibate, sexually speaking, to offend against chastity.

Second, I may as well say this right out loud, right now, rather than tiptoe around the issue: I no longer believe in the Sexual Revolution.


In fact, I have this confession to make: the recent arrival of the capstone in my arch of maturity coincided with my giving up masturbating, a practice which the Sexual Revolution said was as natural and healthful as eating and breathing.

As I indicated in God of Chastity, Part II and earlier posts in my Theology of the Body series about an important theological outlook espoused by the late Pope John Paul II, my church preaches chastity. This past Lenten season, I began practicing it by stopping masturbating.

Specifically, I gave up looking at porn on the Internet and doing what comes naturally when one looks at porn ... a thing one also tends to do many times, as well, when not looking at porn on the Internet.

More specifically yet, the kind of dirty pictures I favored when looking at online porn were not "normal," but oriented toward a particular fetish or perversion. I'm not going to say what it was ... it's a preoccupation that a lot of men have, and not a few women as well, in which something bodily that is not intended to provoke lust does anyway. I now realize that entertaining such preoccupations, though no one is really harmed by it, is nothing if not immature.

And this is now a blog against immaturity!


I bring these personal things up because I believe a lot of the sexual behavior that goes on today without any stigma of illicitness is just the acting out of immaturity and the inability to postpone gratification. It has been so since very early in my life — I was born in 1947 — but the pace picked up with the Sexual Revolution of the 1960s. And, as the young people of my Baby Boomer generation threw off the old shackles of sexual repression, they also gave evidence of being notably less mature in other ways.

I witnessed this in my own young life in the form of the cataclysmic violence that erupted in the late 1960s as college and university students tried to "tear down the walls" and summarily enact a political revolution.

I was a junior at Georgetown University in 1968 when opposition to the war in Vietnam turned ugly. Students who were "clean for Gene" early in the year — for Senator Eugene McCarthy, who ran as an antiwar candidate against incumbent President Lyndon Johnson — watched as the hope engendered by his positive early results in the New Hampshire primary and elsewhere were doused by the killings of Martin Luther King and Bobby Kennedy. King was the crucial link between the civil rights movement and establishment politics, and Robert Francis Kennedy was the man most likely to translate McCarthy's quixotic crusade into a successful peace Presidency.

With their snuffing out, leaders of the "movement" for civil rights and peace descended on Chicago during the week of the Democratic National Convention bent on goading the police into starting a riot — which is what actually happened. Young self-styled radicals defended what they had wrought in terms of no longer being willing to wait for peace and justice.

No longer being willing to wait ... that, par excellence, is a recipe for the victory in one's soul of the precipitous and the immature.

Did their coming to prevail have anything to do with the Sexual Revolution? The question answers itself when you consider that the old order of sexual propriety was based on the notion that sex before marriage is a sin. When sex before marriage is a sin, sex outside of the duly sanctified bridal chamber is out of the question entirely. Throwing such notions aside, I believe, was manifestly a recipe for the onset of radical immaturity in other avenues of life.

Believe me, I wish it were otherwise. I wish we could have our marshmallow and eat it, too: that we could be faultlessly mature in other areas of life while not reining ourselves in sexually in the least degree. But my experience is that we are not built that way, and the world does not work that way.

I don't plan to say all that much about sex in my rededicated "In Search of Maturity" blog, though. I know of no better way to turn what I would hope to be a reasonable discussion into a food fight than to become a scold about the kind of behavior I know people want to hear nothing negative about.

Besides, there are any number of topics related to maturity and self-control that don't ask people to give up such a mainstay of their present lifestyle as "illicit sexuality" ... until they're ready to do so, that is. Lord knows, that was literally the last thing I myself wanted to give up!

* * *


Before I shut up, a few words about the quotation at the head of my blog. "Use the Force, Luke!" are words that echoed in the thoughts of new-minted Jedi Knight Luke Skywalker as he led the rebels' attack against the Death Star of Darth Vader in the original Star Wars movie in 1977. Luke had learned them from his mentor, old Ben Kenobi, when being trained in the ways of the Force.

Using the Force is, I'd say, a metaphor for the wisdom taught by all our religions, a wisdom that comes down to the values of self-control, discipline, and chastity in the broad sense in which that word is spoken of above. Luke had, or developed, such virtues as a Jedi knight-in-training, in contrast to the gruff dissolution of the lifestyle of Han Solo. Han was by no means evil like Darth Vader; he was good, but as a cynical hothead he was clearly no candidate for Jedi knighthood.

The character of Obi-wan Kenobi made manifest such wisdom and maturity as young Luke was in need of en route to his knighthood. Often, those in the presence of Ben Kenobi would automatically do as the Force would have them do, no matter how much they were customarily in thrall to the Dark Side. That's why I hereby make "Use the Force, Luke!" the epigraph to this blog.

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Don't Eat the Marshmallow!

An interesting article in The New Yorker of May 18, 2009: "Don't!" by Jonah Lehrer.

The article is about the scientific investigation of self-control. Decades ago, a psychologist named Walter Mischel experimented to see whether there were meaningful differences among four-year-olds' abilities to postpone gratification. He left them alone in a room with instructions not to eat a marshmallow until he returned from an errand outside the room, at which time they could have two marshmallows, not just one. But if they couldn't wait, they could ring a bell, and he would come back in right away and give them just a single marshmallow.

Some of the kids could delay gratification for as long as fifteen minutes, the outer limit imposed by Mischel; others held out for three minutes or just 30 seconds before the bell got rung, and some stuffed a marshmallow into their mouth right away without even ringing the bell. One lad, tested with Oreo cookies rather than marshmallows, opened a cookie and licked out the cream filling before slyly re-assembling the cookie and returning it to the tray.

In short, some of the kids were "high delayers" at the age of four, while others were "low delayers." One might assume the large differences at such a young age to be genetic, but Mischel believes there is a dance between nature (genes) and nurture (upbringing; environmental factors) such that either/or questions about those two poles of behavior causation are meaningless.


My interest in this has to do with my belief that postponing gratification and the practice of self-control are crucial to traditional religious standards of morality.

We Christians pray, "Lead us not into temptation but deliver us from evil." For a four-year-old, temptation is being left alone in a room with a tray of marshmallows they aren't permitted to touch, and evil is stealthily consuming the filling of an Oreo cookie without letting on what one has done.

Whether it's waiting until Christmas morning to open presents or waiting until marriage to have sex, postponing gratification has always been part and parcel of the Christian experience.

Speaking just for myself as a baby boomer, my personal experience has been one of becoming a consistent "high delayer" only later in life. This seems to have been a result of becoming, in midlife, a Christian in more than name only.


Before I was 40, I was not religious. And in many ways I'd say I was a low delayer, though never one who would grab the marshmallow without ringing the bell. Accordingly, I think Mischel and the other researchers mentioned in the article ought to make a careful distinction between low delayers who nonetheless play by the rules, and those who secretly filch Oreo fillings and look innocent when the adult returns.

Another thing: in my experience there seem to be two classes of evildoing. I was never tempted to become a bully. I have always been appalled at snobbery and intolerance. I have had relatively little trouble getting on board with feminism, inclusiveness, and multiculturalism.

Consuming illicit marshmallows (or other banned substances) was more my style. Being in a big hurry about obtaining gratification was something else again ... something that waxed and waned over the course of my formative years, exactly as Mischel's research shows it might. Mischel believes high and low delayers are determined at least in part by the specific contexts in which the behavior is taking place.

Low delayers can use various tricks to make themselves high delayers in a specific context, says Mischel. For example, he successfully trained kids faced with the task of not eating a marshmallow to imagine it as a picture in a frame, or a fluffy cloud. He found the kids that were already high delayers had their own tricks, such as occupying their minds with other pursuits while they waited.


Mischel's original research has been followed up by himself and other experimenters who are interested in, among other things, how the four-year-olds from the late 1960s fared in adulthood. In general, the high-delay children have done better in several areas of life. This result has been confirmed by other research. For instance, Angela Lee Duckworth has found that "the ability to delay gratification — eighth graders were given a choice between a dollar right away or two dollars the following week — was a far better predictor of academic performance than I.Q."

Of the original "marshmallow subjects," the article says, some "failed the marshmallow task as four-year-olds but ended up becoming high-delaying adults. 'This is the group I’m most interested in,' [Mischel] says. 'They have substantially improved their lives'." For this to happen, ad hoc mental tricks are not enough; "the real challenge is turning those tricks into habits, and that requires years of diligent practice."

It is my belief that religion does precisely that. It starts out giving us tricks to delay gratification in specific circumstances and thus gradually turns waiting and postponing into a way of life.

For instance, Christians have a way of imagining that Jesus walks beside them at all times. Of course, the answer to "What would Jesus do?" is never to steal the filling from an Oreo cookie.

Jesus's counsel would ever be, "Don't eat the marshmallow!" At some point we learn not to partake too soon without always needing to have His voice in our ear, and we have the basis to begin living an "It's not all about you" life.

Saturday, April 18, 2009

God of Chastity, Part II

Christopher West's book Theology of the Body for Beginners is an old topic in this blog — see the earlier entries in my Theology of the Body series about the theological outlook espoused by the late Pope John Paul II, as described in West's book — but today I think of it as, for me, new wine in new skin.

John Paul II made it clear that there is nothing profane about combining "theology" with "the body" or "the flesh" ... as in S-E-X. Indeed, the truth is quite the opposite: there is nothing more appropriate to a Christian outlook. There is nothing more important for the Christian to understand than the reason St. Paul could write, in his letter to the Ephesians:

Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her to make her holy, cleansing her by the washing with water through the word, and to present her to himself as a radiant church, without stain or wrinkle or any other blemish, but holy and blameless. In this same way, husbands ought to love their wives as their own bodies. He who loves his wife loves himself. After all, no one ever hated his own body, but he feeds and cares for it, just as Christ does the church — for we are members of his body. "For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh." This is a profound mystery — but I am talking about Christ and the church. (Ephesians 6:25-32)

This makes it sound as if Christ and the church have a "one flesh," i.e., a marital, relationship — as indeed they do! Relationships of the "flesh" — sex — image or reflect the mysterious love of the three persons that make up the Holy Trinity for one another: Father, Son, and Spirit. This is the meaning of sex.

West calls this the "spousal analogy." To Catholics, as I hope to all Christians, analogies are profound tokens of truth. True, God is all spirit, and his three inner persons do not have "sex lives." But God's self-revelation in the Bible, whether Old Testament or New, uses a spousal analogy at just about every turning. Paul, for example, cites one of the earliest verses in the Bible, Genesis 2:24:

For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and they will become one flesh.

The idea that Christ, as the Lamb of God, is the "bridegroom" and the church is his "bride" comes to fruition in one of the last Bible verses, Revelation 19:7:

Let us rejoice and be glad and give him glory! For the wedding of the Lamb has come, and his bride has made herself ready.

All the way through the Bible, the deep, inner nature of the created world, and of us, is shown as being fundamentally nuptial. "Be fruitful and multiply" is not just something that would be nice for us to do. It is our most basic way of being in conformance with the contours God gave his created universe.


So, yes, I've gone over to "the other side" on some very basic things. In modern parlance, I've had a paradigm shift.

The way I know I've had a paradigm shift is that when I saw, on West's p. 14, "Make no mistake: in the final analysis the abortion debate is not about when life begins. It is about the meaning of sex," I finally got it.

The first two times I read the book, that passage did not even merit being highlighted — though I was assiduously highlighting passages all around it. This time, I thought it deserved highlighting not in my customary blue marking pen but in day-glo pink.

"The meaning of sex." Sex has a meaning? A deep, permanent, nature-of-all-things, fundamental significance, as opposed to what two consenting adults happen to be willing to accord to it, at the moment, if not tomorrow, or next week, or next year? The meaning of sex?

It was like the scene in The Blues Brothers where Jake (John Belushi) sees the light:

Jake: "The band ... the band ..."
Rev. Cleophus [James Brown]: "DO YOU SEE THE LIGHT?!"
Jake: "THE BAND!!!"
Rev. Cleophus: "DO YOU SEE THE LIGHT?!!"
Elwood [Dan Aykroyd]: "What light?!"
Rev. Cleophus: "DO YOU SEEEE THE LIGHT?!"
Jake: "YES!! YES!! JESUS H. TAP-DANCING CHRIST ... I HAVE SEEN THE LIGHT!!!"

I finally got it. I saw the light. Sex has a meaning. You can't be a serious Christian, not really, until you are willing to admit it. For years, I was unwilling to admit it.

I had all the data at my disposal: how my church wanted its members to act in accordance with that fundamental outlook; how the outlook permeates the Bible. I just didn't see it. I just didn't want to accept that such a contentious, divisive — and, to me, seemingly peripheral — facet of modern-day living as our "right to sexual freedom" should be allowed to divide people, both within the church and outside it.

But it's not peripheral. It's central. It's make-or-break. Marital fidelity, chastity outside marriage, the male-female union as "one flesh" never to be sundered by man, the time of the beginning of life as periperal to the abortion debate, the reason homosexual unions are against God's plan, the reason casual sex, pornography, and masturbation are wrong ... all these hot-button topics of the present day look different to me, post paradigm shift, than they did before.

I no longer think Christians who — such as I myself did, prior to the shift — think they are complete Christians even though they differ with their tradition on issues of sex, gender, marriage, reproduction, and family are actually finished.


Paradigm shifts are funny. Not ha-ha-funny or peculiar-funny. They are funny because you can't really argue about them, or with them. You either see the new paradigm, or you don't.

In a way, I have "understood" what is now my new paradigm for a long, long time. I just didn't get it.

I understood that the church saw issues of the flesh and the body as crucial, where I simply didn't.

I understood that the Bible uses what West calls the "spousal analogy" throughout ... but I thought of old-fashioned analogies as disposable and dispensible, in the modern world.

I understood that God's revelation of his own nature and truth to us in scripture was timeless ... while mentally striking out those ideas that didn't accord with my own way of looking at things!

So I didn't immediately snap to attention the first time or two I read West's sentence about the abortion debate and the meaning of sex. His thought went right over my head. If someone had brought it to my attention, I would have rejected it or tried to explain it away.

A paradigm shift feels like something snapping into place, something seating itself, in your mind, in just the way it is meant to be. You just know, once you have had it, that you'll never be the same. And, sure, you want to share it with everybody. At the same time, mature reflection tells you that they, too, likely have all the data at hand, and unless something just snaps into place for them, they just aren't going to agree with you. They still have that old paradigm, the one you used to have. Paradigm shifts do not lend themselves to easy solidarity.

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

God of Chastity, Part I

This isn't a particularly easy topic to talk about, but here goes anyway...

Let me put it this way: I believe in God. I also believe that sex should be reserved for marriage. Furthermore, I believe that the truth about God and the truth about chastity, as I'll call the latter, are tightly intertwined.

Once upon a time, it was common knowledge that sex outside marriage was a sin against God. That sex without benefit of marriage was of questionable morality was the understanding I was given as a child in the 1950s, even though I wasn't brought up religious. Then came the Sexual Revolution. Though my contemporaries began availing themselves of "carnal knowledge" at every opportunity — and I was no saint — I never got comfortable with the new idea that "anything goes."

In midlife I became religious for the first time. That was about 20 years ago. But somehow, I never particularly came to believe that being religious necessarily implied being chaste.

Instead, I was of the opinion — see many of my earlier entries in this blog — that the old rules about chastity were passé. Or, at least, they were "optional." They grew out of the same Judeo-Christian tradition that kept women from full equality with men, made abortion and homosexual acts sinful, etc., etc., etc.

Recently, though, I have woken up to the fact that, deep down, I still believe that "family values" are the best values. I never really stopped believing that. I just compartmentalized that idea away from my religious beliefs.

This, despite the fact that I am perfectly well aware, and long have been, that there is no theme more characteristic of Judeo-Christian scripture — the Old Testament and the New — than the sanctity of marriage. It is a bit difficult to detect a "through line" to the narrative of the Bible, but one does seem to be there. In the beginning, Adam and Eve's "marriage" in the Garden of Eden is tainted by Original Sin. In the end, in the Book of Revelation, there is a sacred marriage between Christ, who has come back to this world, and his Church, encompassing all people who are saved.

Along the way, between Genesis and Revelation, we keep getting clues that marriage is sacrosanct. When Abraham and his descendants are told to "be fruitful and multiply," it is within the bounds of marriage that this is to take place. The Old Testament strictures against promiscuity, homosexuality, and masturbation make most sense against this backdrop.

Jesus, with his "one flesh" dictum, took marriage to be sacrosanct. In Matthew 19, we read:

Some Pharisees came to him to test him [Jesus]. They asked, "Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife for any and every reason?" Haven't you read," he replied, "that at the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female,' and said, 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh'? So they are no longer two, but one. Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate."

Though the first post-Resurrection Christians were told by Paul to eschew marriage if they could tolerate celibacy, this seems to have been under the assumption that the Second Coming was imminent and there were, meanwhile, more important things to be done, such as evangelizing the heathen world.

Once the Church began to realize Christ's return might be a long way off, it renewed the ancient Israelite emphasis on the sanctity of marriage, and Paul himself was emphatic in his Letter to the Romans that "anything goes" was not a proper way to worship the Lord. (Paul also wrote in one of his epistles of the need for wives to defer to their husbands ... one of the most resented passages of scripture these days!)

I don't personally claim to know with any certainty how to square scripture with modern-day sexuality is all its most controversial aspects. But I do now claim that it makes no sense to call oneself a Christian or a Jew and not take with the utmost seriousness the claims these religions traditionally make on us to be chaste and to hold marriage sacrosanct.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Is Pornography Adultery?

About a year and a half ago I filed the following, which I no longer agree with myself about but leave as a record of what I once thought:

In Is Pornography Adultery?, in The Atlantic Monthly for October 2008, Ross Douthat asks whether married men looking at porn on the Internet are committing the moral equivalent of adultery.

I'll file my response here in my "Music Etcetera" blog, since looking at porn on the 'Net qualifies as a kind of "home entertainment" (maybe).

Douthat's contention is that Internet porn viewing is much closer to an act of adultery than we might initially think. The fact that the process is mediated by a stream of digital pixels across a network connection does not separate it all that much from paying a prostitute to watch her perform a sex act in a hotel room, says Douthat. If that's cheating on your wife, then watching the same sort of performance across an Internet connection is too, right?

Or, if not, why not?

Douthat says that "in moral issues, every distinction matters." And there is a distinction, it seems to me, in the fact that a hotel room encounter is face-to-face. On the Internet, there is no encounter, period.

Adultery has to be face-to-face, I'd say, or at least skin-to-skin. Watching porn doesn't necessarily rise to the level of adultery.


Even so, the real question remains: If a husband looks at porn, is it a breach of marital faith and trust?

And the answer to that is: if the wife says it's a breach, then, yes, it is a breach.

Breaches of faith are non-negotiable. That is, there is no basis for him, the porn-avid husband, to say, in effect, "Honey, if I agree to do this, that, and the other, will you agree to let me look at porn?" No matter how big a sacrifice doing-this-that-and-the-other may represent to him, it can never offset a fundamental breach of marital trust in her eyes.

Accordingly, looking at porn is never a "right" that he can claim he has, as a man or as a husband. He has no "right to look at porn," unless she agrees that it's not a fundamental breach of marital faith and trust.


If she does say that it's a fundamental breach, then, for that marriage, looking at porn becomes the moral equivalent of adultery.

This attitude differs from Douthat's in that he would have porn viewing be absolutely the equivalent of adultery, or not, depending on how you argue morally. If the moral argument he presents to the effect that porn viewing is adultery is accepted as correct, then all porn viewing by married men is adulterous.

From that perspective, the wife's views, should they happen to be broad-minded, don't matter.

Douthat cites studies showing that a hefty percentage of women are broad-minded about porn use:

About a third of the women [surveyed] described the porn habit as a form of betrayal and infidelity. But the majority were neutral or even positively disposed to their lover’s taste for smut, responding slightly more favorably than not to prompts like “I do not mind my partner’s pornography use” or “My partner’s pornography use is perfectly normal.”


I object to a moral stance such as Douthat's which finds porn use occupies an invariably too-close-to-adultery position on a continuum with adultery at its end point. One reason is the it's-not-skin-to-skin argument I made earlier. Another is that, as I say, the stance ignores the attitude of the woman most involved: the wife. Like many moral absolutes, it's stealthily patriarchal: it "protects" the wife, even if she doesn't feel she needs this particular kind of protection.


A third reason is that Douthat's absolutist stance is, perhaps unwittingly, closet relativism. It skirts an important question: is porn use immoral in and of itself? That is, shouldn't the view of the (in my case Roman Catholic) church that porn use is absolutely sinful be the controlling one here?

Your religious affiliation may differ, but the question is equally valid. Is porn use a breach of religious faith? Does God forbid it?

My church says God forbids porn use, masturbation, premarital and extramarital sex, as well as artificial birth control, abortion, and homosexual acts.

Douthat notes that Jesus of Nazareth said, “I tell you that anyone who looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her in his heart.”

Jesus lived in a different age. I'd say that the attitude each of us men, married or not, takes toward that adjuration or the various pronouncements of religion regarding sex is, in this day and age, a personal matter. If a man is unmarried, such that the question of his wife's trust doesn't arise, he can choose. He can commit "lust in his heart," or not, and suffer the consequences, if any.

As long as what he does does not exploit unwitting or unwilling adults, is not coercive in any way, does not involve children, does not violate marital trust, is not physically harmful or abusive, does not become an addiction, etc., etc., etc., it's entirely a matter of private conscience.

And, yes, my position does imply that sexual morality changes, era by era, by the way. But that's a topic for a whole other discussion.

At any rate, I don't think a moral argument such as Douthat's to the effect that porn use occupies an absolutely "wrong" position on a continuum of imaginable marital offenses can possibly work. Continua are intrinsically relativistic. You can't be both a relativist and an absolutist.


On the other hand ... if a man holds himself out as a paragon of traditional religious virtue, sexual and otherwise, but looks at porn, then whether he is married or not, he's a hypocrite.

I don't mean anybody has to place ads in the paper saying, "I masturbated today" or "I had premarital sex" or "I'm gay." Such things are no one else's business. But if a main rails against such behavior on Sunday and does it on Monday through Saturday, he's a liar.

'Nuff said about that.