Showing posts with label Culture in Crisis?. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Culture in Crisis?. Show all posts

Friday, August 30, 2013

"Twerk" on MTV, Miley Cyrus Did

In 2013, 'twerk' was added to the Oxford Dictionary Online. The dictionary said the word had been around for 20 years, but the evidence for it to be included in the dictionary had tipped the scale when U.S. pop star Miley Cyrus gave a controversial and headline-producing twerking dance at the MTV Video Music Awards on August 25, 2013.

— Wikipedia          

The verb "twerk," says the Oxford dictionary, means "dance to popular music in a sexually provocative manner involving thrusting hip movements and a low, squatting stance."

Much debate ensued after Miley Cyrus "twerked" onscreen at MTV. Was her performance appropriate, the multitudes asked, or not?

Miley Cyrus on MTV
More Miley

I say not. My thought is that it extended a long-term trend a bridge too far. When I was in college at Georgetown in the late 1960s, the university enforced a rule against "public display of affection": no kissing or petting outdoors or in public view. The more general rule, at G'town and in society, was that sex is to be kept private. If it's sexual, hide it from public view.

The rule was coming apart at the seams even then. It had been doing so for decades, going back to the ending of the Victorian era of the final two-thirds of the nineteenth century. "Victorian morality can describe any set of values that espouse sexual restraint, low tolerance of crime and a strict social code of conduct," says Wikipedia. Strict restraints on sexual attitudes and behavior meant men and women wore clothes that covered all and that emphasized nothing that might arouse sexual feelings. Sex obviously happened, and a lot of it was downright illicit. There's no doubt about it. But it was done in private.

My generation was not the first to rebel, but in our own nineteen-sixties sexual revolution the gloves — and much else besides — came all the way off. Ample justification was given: that getting rid of repression and of hypocrisy would make society and its citizens all that much healthier.

Now we have a 20-year-old former child star looking to extend her something-very-like-a-career by a twerking display on TV. We have rampant sexual abuse in the U.S. military. "More than 70% of male Internet users from 18 to 34," according to Wikipedia, "visit a pornographic site in a typical month." Priestly child sexual abuse has racked the Catholic Church. Scandal after scandal has cut short a host of political careers and besmirched the memory of one of the most revered of college football coaches.

All because sex is, I believe, now more public than private. Not the act itself (at least for the most part) buts its hintings, simulacra, and accouterments.

You might think — and a lot of people actually do think — there's no reason why the loosening of nineteenth-century moral strictures that was supposed to make us saner would instead be making us sicker. You might think that between Queen Victoria's corsetings and Miley's MTV cavortings there ought to be a sweet spot which society can occupy, with only a few depraved outliers to either side of the sensible median strip.

It hasn't happened. The depraved outliers are everywhere. So I'd say we need to rein ourselves in. The only way to do that, I think, is to take sex back into the privacy of the boudoir an keep it under demure covers.

How might that happen? We need to start by shrinking the boundary of personal behavior that is considered appropriate. I have in mind, to begin with, a new reticence about stuff that really isn't all that naughty, in the grand scheme of things. For example: no posterior anatomy visible for guys with low-slung belt lines; no visible bra straps for gals. Start with tiny little things like those.

Start with making this taboo ...

... and this.

Whoa! I hear voices raised in protest already. These infractions are, to the extent they are sexual displays at all, very minor ones. They are matters of personal choice and free individual expression. Every generation since Victoria passed away in 1901 has shown more and more anatomy, more and more underwear, and where do you draw the line? Isn't this all just a Trojan horse for a thoroughgoing new Victorianism?

I hope not. But it isn't at all clear to me that there really exists a viable sweet spot between Victorian deprivation and no-holds-barred depravity — it has to be one that the bulk of us can hold to — unless it is also one that abhors (for example) hordes of us "sexting" up a storm or assiduously "tweeting our junk" at every conceivable opportunity. Such activities are not necessarily immoral but, as I hope we are learning, they straddle the increasingly invisible line between public and private. Which is why we all now know so well the name of former-Rep. Anthony Weiner.

So, no more "sexting." No more "tweeting our junk." No more peeking-out bra straps. No more visible vertical smiles. And no more of the many other "innocent" behaviors that put us on a slippery slope to less-minor infractions and then to much more that is far worse.

Notice that I am saying nothing about what can or ought to happen between consenting adults in their bedroom or boudoir. I make no claim to knowing what kinds of sex are quote-unquote bad, or, for that matter, good. All I am saying is give sexual privacy a fighting chance. Keep sex, its stand-ins, its simulacra, and its accouterments well out of public view, and we will see whether I am right and the abuses diminish.


Monday, August 13, 2012

Lessons from "The Sex Lady"

Deborah Roffman has been dubbed "The Sex Lady" for her strong advocacy for teaching kids about sex the right way. Here's an example:



Baltimore Sun columnist Susan Reimer, in "'The Sex Lady' offers lessons for parents" in today's edition, writes glowingly about Roffman and her new book. Roffman's book is titled Talk to Me First: Everything You Need to Know to Become Your Kids' "Go-To" Person about Sex. Reimer lauds Roffman for the way "she employs the fundamental elements of parenting — affirmation, information, clarity about values, limits and guidance — and applies them to a child's developing sexuality."

I don't claim to know much about teaching kids about sex. My reaction to Reimer's column is, however, one of great concern. Reimer writes that so much has changed in "the four decades Deborah Roffman has taught [children] about their bodies," and that:

... the only thing that hasn't changed is the discomfort of their parents when they try to talk about sex. Even the sex has changed, becoming casual and transactional, invasive and pervasive. Marketing and advertising have driven the mercury higher. Technology has put sex only a touch or a keystroke away. "The boundaries that used to separate children's lives from adults' lives have in many respects vanished," said Ms. Roffman ...

And, per Roffman:

"We spent the 20th century carving out the stages of child development, and marketers have managed to collapse them. Now 8-year-olds are just short 14-year-olds. And 14-year-olds are just short 20-year-olds."

I know this much: there was a time in human history when the line between childhood innocence and adult sexual maturity was a clear one. It was crossed at the appropriate age by virtue of initiation ceremonies that were once part and parcel of religions. For example, Jewish bar mitzvah ceremonies, as originally conceived, were when a young male of the species could finally say (in Hebrew) "Now I am a man" ... and mean it!

The treatment of young women was somewhat different, since the onset of menstruation is in itself a threshold. But the point is that there was a threshold, and religions enforced it.

Not today. Our religions seem to have yielded to the general culture and "dumbed down" the whole concept behind thresholds, confirmations, bar mitzvahs, and religious initiations in general. Or maybe it's that the secular culture has drowned out our religions' ancient messages.

So now we hear from Reimer that Hoffman:

... writes with candor about ... the 12-year-old who announces to her stunned father that she will be going to parties this school year and she will probably be performing oral sex when she gets there.

Say what? Seventh-grade girls going to parties and performing oral sex? When I was in seventh grade, at a class party in 1959, I kissed a girl (her name was Carol Scott) for the first time, and considered myself bold for having done so. My how times have changed ...

... for the worse.

I agree with Roffman in the video above that "abstinence only" sex education in schools is not the answer, and that an admirable goal is to bring up children to be able to think clearly about sex. The goal of "chastity," mentioned in passing by Roffman, is, I agree, not the same as the goal of "abstinence." As I define chastity, though, it is a matter of "just saying no" in specific situations because you have made a personal choice to do so. So I think I have to disagree with Roffman's words in the video, to the extent that she seems to believe "abstinence only" actually means "chastity" — which she thinks is an inappropriate goal.

I'd say there still needs to be a threshold of maturity on the early side of which "just say no" is a rule, not a choice. Our sex-drenched culture, as Reimer says, obliterates that threshold ... mainly, I'd say, because sex sells products (left).

So I think we need to make at least three changes in our culture. One, as Reimer and Roffman say, we need to teach our kids about sex the right way. Two, we need to give our pre-teen children back their childhood by insisting on the old-fashioned rules concerning bodies and sex. Three, we need to get our churches and religions back on the same page with us, and us with them, because without religion's underpinnings for sexuality's thresholds, there is no earthly reason why 8-year-olds should not consider themselves short 14-year-olds.



Saturday, June 09, 2007

Ruby Slippers

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
In "O for Order," as I continued my ongoing discussion of Pope Benedict XVI's book Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures, I postulated that our society's capacity for ethical awareness is gradually producing a new moral "order for free" in the wake of the demise of old-fashioned taboos.

Very recently there has been a decline in the number of abortions being performed, in the amount of drug abuse that occurs, and in the rate of teen pregnancy, I said. Given that the erstwhile strictures on society's moral behavior have loosened considerably over the last several decades, why?

I suggested the reason has to do with evolution. Not biological evolution per se, but the way in which various types of complex-adaptive, self-organizing systems evolve. Among these types of systems are species, ecosystems, cultures, technologies, economies, financial markets ... and, I would suggest, the ways in which societies come to grips with their moral, ethical understandings.

All such dynamical systems, argues biologist Stuart Kauffman in his book At Home in the Universe, have the capacity to evolve by virtue of hovering mathematically at or near the "edge of chaos" — a unique dynamical locale where both novelty and stability are to be expected. "Chaos" itself has the ability to produce novelty but not stability; the two distinct regimes of dynamical "order" yield stability but not novelty. Only the "edge of chaos" offers sanctuary to the processes of graceful change we call evolution.

Stuff happens ... and when it does, chaos often ensues. But complex-adaptive systems are self-righting, and as they make their way back out of the regime of chaotic instability to the vaunted domain that has been dubbed the edge of chaos, which is equally the edge of order, their ability to self-organize produces new order for free — "for free," because the new order is not imposed on the system by any force or contrivance that exists outside or above the system.


The new moral order that is evolving in our society is not, I would claim, a matter of necessarily seeking different moral ends, but rather of having different moral means.

Take abortion. Those who support a "woman's right to choose" nevertheless want abortion to become (albeit safe and legal) rare. Of late, abortion indeed seems to have grown (slightly) less frequent than it was just a few years ago, as it remains safe and legal. Why?

That trend is probably due to a confluence of causes, I would say:

  • Various new laws have chipped away at the ease with which women — for example, teens living with their parents — obtain abortions.
  • Sexual mores have shifted in favor of serial monogamy, albeit not full-fledged pre-marital chastity.
  • There are now "morning after" birth control pills.
  • Women can now take birth control pills that suppress their monthly periods, a desirable goal in itself from the point of view of many women. The pills also protect against pregnancy.
  • Advice columnists in newspapers now give hard-headed, practical advice about sexual relationships that no parish priest was ever equipped to give.
  • Schools teach condom use.
  • TV shows portray getting pregnant when you aren't in a stable relationship as not necessarily a wonderful thing to have happen.
  • Women are not as starry-eyed as they once were about "Mr. Right."
  • Religious and secular institutions with a pro-life agenda have learned how to pursue it more effectively.
  • And so on.
There are also countervailing tendencies, to be sure, such as boyfriends, parents, and job requirements that pressure women to terminate unwanted pregnancies. But now there is increasingly a reaction against such pressures on the part of not only pro-lifers but also feminists who resent all forms of coercion exacted upon women.

All in all, the situation is evolving. As it does, abortion becomes rarer ... even though there are (a) fewer formal legal forces exerted upon women contemplating abortion, as there were before Roe v. Wade; (b) fewer informal taboos that remain in widespread effect against premarital sex, pregnancy outside marriage, or the illegitimacy of children.


What does any of this have to do with the pope's book? Well, the pope argues that the rise in the West, over the last several centuries, of the notion that we as individuals are, or ought to be, radically free to express ourselves as we see fit, without having to kowtow to external authorities or taboos, has put us in a self-contradictory situation. As more and more of us gain more and more "power to choose," in the guise of newly minted human "rights," those newfound "rights" endlessly trump other people's and institutions' existing rights — to the point, ultimately, of constricting freedom itself. Lost in the struggle, he believes, is our basic respect for the lives and dignity of other human persons.

I see his point, of course, since in the short term there is an apparent deficit of respect for life and dignity abroad in the land. But I would argue that in the long term, moral "order for free" will in fact emerge and rectify that situation. Indeed, it is already happening.

And so, an analogy. In The Wizard of Oz, Dorothy and her fellow travelers on the Yellow Brick Road to the Emerald City expect the great wizard who rules the Land of Oz mostly by the force of bluster and intimidation to grant whatever it is that would turn each one's individual world into a seeming paradise. Dorothy wants to go home to Kansas. The Scarecrow wants a brain. The Tin Man, a heart. The Cowardly Lion, courage.

As the story unfolds, it becomes quickly apparent that the Great Wizard of Oz is actually a humbug who lacks the power to grant anything. The wizard, I take it, is a stand-in for all external, top-down sources of authority: governments, churches, and those less-visible bastions of behavioral governance which sociologists catalog.

Accordingly, the wizard, who is actually a soft-hearted charlatan whose hot-air balloon descended quite by accident into Oz, confers empowering symbols of braininess, compassion, and courage on Dorothy's friends, and they each come to believe in the qualities they had all along.

As for Dorothy, after the wizard's plan to carry her back to Kansas in his resurrected balloon misfires, the Good Witch Glinda reveals that the ruby slippers Dorothy has inherited from the killed Wicked Witch of the East have the unsuspected ability to transport her home. I take "home" to represent (among other things) the graceful stability we associate with life on earth. The ruby slippers betoken (again, among other things) the power of living organisms — ruby is the color of blood — to, by virtue of their self-organized complexity, produce order for free from within themselves.


The Wizard of Oz
is a paean to self-determination in the absence of external coercion, hard (as with formal laws) or soft (as with informal taboos). It is a tribute to the ability of complex systems such as Dorothy represents to right themselves after a catastrophe such as the cyclone that blew Dorothy's house from Kansas to Oz. It is an affirmation that good things can "magically" happen even when everyday logic would suggest otherwise.

When Pope Benedict makes in his book what otherwise would seem to be a logically compelling case that our radical bias toward more and more individual liberty today violates life's sanctity and dignity, and ultimately undermines liberty itself, I think he reckons without the capacity of self-organizing systems to produce (moral) order for free, as they gracefully evolve. I think he overlooks, as Dorothy did, the power of our cultural ruby slippers to transport us out of moral chaos and back to paradise.

Wednesday, June 06, 2007

O for Order

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
In "M for Maturity" I continued my discussion of Pope Benedict XVI's Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures. The Holy Father's recent book (written while he was still Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger) makes a case for re-anchoring Western culture in two essentially Christian values: the inviolability of human life and the furtherance of human dignity.

Pope Benedict believes that those values were shunted aside in the wake of the 18th-century Age of Enlightenment in Europe, supplanted by a commitment to the idea of the radical self-determination of the individual man or woman, in the name of liberty. According to Benedict, placing unfettered self-expression at the absolute center of our moral order relativizes everything else, including life and dignity, to the detriment of all.

In "F for Freedom" I contrasted the idea of absolute freedom with the longstanding Catholic call to chastity — sexual chastity. I showed how the recent movie "V for Vendetta" seems to typify the stresses in our culture. It presents us with a stark choice between freedom and the traditional sexual morality the pope would urge upon us in the name of chastity. I tried to suggest that "V for Vendetta's" attitudes are so much in the ascendant in our society today that any call for re-Christianization that has a return to old-style chastity as its hidden agenda — as I believe the pope's message does — is doomed to fail.

In "C for Chastity" I extended such remarks to show that chastity, as recommended to us by the Church, is more than just a matter of sexuality. It is a refusal to allow ourselves to be controlled by our own "unbridled restlessness" in any venue of life. I asked, "Is there any way we can be good Christians without a return to chastity as the Church traditionally defines it?" I pointed out the difficulty of having us go back to acting chastely in concert as a society, being publicly and overtly chaste together, so as to avoid the pitfall of chastity itself becoming just another option on the list of choices for radical individual self-expression.

In "M for Maturity" I intimated that our society is presently coming out of a stage of cultural "adolescence" in which top-down controls on our individual moral behavior are being supplanted by bottom-up self-control. The culture is maturing. Abortions are down. Drug abuse is down. Teen pregnancy is down. Gradually, we are learning to control ourselves in the absence of top-down, external taboos.

Now, in this post, I would like to suggest that this maturation is an example of "order for free."


Stuart
Kauffman's
At Home in
the Universe
By "order for free" I mean roughly what biologist Stuart Kauffman meant by it in his book At Home in the Universe. The book is about evolution. Not just biological evolution, mind you — though that's a big part of it. There are also cultural, technological, and economic forms of evolution, says Kauffman, and they have a number of characteristics in common.

One of these characteristics is for some changes which emerge naturally in any sort of complex, dynamically self-altering system to be weeded out and others to prosper. Darwin called this process "natural selection."

But Kauffman proposes another common characteristic of such evolving systems: "self-organization." Self-organization is the tendency for complex dynamic systems to produce "order for free."

Kauffman shows how there may well be "laws of self-organization and complexity" by dint of which, in the realm of biological evolution, the living forms which selection chooses among are generated in the first place. These candidate forms of life which natural selection chooses from are examples of order for free.

These same proposed laws of self-organization and complexity, Kauffman, shows, might well govern evolutionary processes at all higher levels of biological organization: species, ecosystems, right up to what biologists call the "evolution of co-evolution" — the way in which species play off against one another as they evolve itself evolves. Self-organization could accordingly be appropriately called the "handmaiden" of natural selection.


Many different types of self-organizing systems seem to share yet another characteristic, that of gravitating to a conceptual — nay, mathematical — locale called the "edge of chaos." This, Kauffman shows, is a "place" where novelty can arise and not be immediately expunged, as it would be in the regime of true mathematical chaos.

On the other hand, there is also the mathematical regime that corresponds to static order ... or, actually, two orderly regimes. In one, nothing ever changes, period. In the second, there are sterile, cyclical changes, but never anything new under the sun.

The edge of chaos is where dynamic "order for free" arises. Systems whose constituent members are connected, but not too connected, produce both novelty and stability. There is a natural balance between bottom-up emergence and top-down control. In the latter, the system spontaneously develops what might be termed a form of self-control, and its activity accordingly tends to resist the destructive forces of the chaotic regime.

Should there be an external, exogenous disturbance to the system's ongoing activity, pushing the system over into the chaotic regime, the self-organizing system tends automatically to gravitate back out of chaos and regain its original poise at the edge of chaos. From there, it goes on producing new "order for free."


Life on earth seems to be such a self-organizing system, says Kauffman. So, too, are human culture, human technology, and human economic activity. My thought is that human moral consciousness is likewise capable of being self-organizing in such a way as to produce order for free.

If so, it evolves. And if it evolves, it organizes its history into eras. Just as the history of biological evolution has eras dominated by different kinds of fossils, the history of moral evolution has its own eras and extinctions.

For example, it can be profoundly hoped that we will soon arrive at an era in which war is a thing of the past.

Notice, as a likely example of the possible emergence of moral order for free, that war is largely absent today from the continent of Europe, whose soil was once so blood-soaked. Notice, also, that Europe is the very seat of the post-Enlightenment values which Pope Benedict tends to look so askance at in his book.

It isn't terribly clear how Europeans have managed to stop slaughtering one another. As recently as two years prior to my birth in 1947, the bloodshed of World War II came to an end. Since then there has been the overarching menace of the Cold War, then the wars and uprisings in the Balkans and parts of the former Soviet Union. But even with Cold War tensions no longer in play, most of Europe has remained peaceful. Who would have thought it, given the continent's bloody history?

Maybe it's a case of order for free ... moral order, since whether or not to wage war is at bottom a moral choice.


If order for free can replace bellicosity with peace, can it replace licentiousness with chastity? By "chastity" here I mean not a bunch of rules of behavior we find impressed upon us from the outside — from the top down, as it were — by the church and/or the secular culture, but a bottom-up orientation toward the avoidance of sexual (or any other kind of) excess.

If, as I say, abortions are down, drug abuse is down, teen pregnancy is down, and so on, are we on the verge of a new moral era? Is "order for free" at work in the way it is going to turn out to be oriented?

(To be continued in my next post ... )

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

M for Maturity

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
In my previous post, C for Chastity, I talked about the concept of chastity in relation to one of the themes of Pope Benedict XVI's recent book Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures: freedom. Specifically, the modern understanding of freedom as a matter of individual, radically unfettered self-expression seems to the pope incompatible with the traditional Christian view of the inviolability of human life and dignity, since the latter has always been vouchsafed by tenets of chastity.

Traditionally, chastity has meant primarily sexual chastity, though it extends into the realm of any sort of self-abnegating behavior that defeats what has been called our "unbridled restlessness." We have long been taught rules, most of them taboos, as guidelines to ensure chastity. But, more and more, the dictates of radical individual liberty have overthrown the taboos.

The pope would, I am sure, like us to start acting in concert and being publicly and overtly chaste together ... which would change the culture drastically.


But the culture has already changed drastically, in the opposite direction, during my lifetime of close to 60 years and counting.

After fulminating about lost chastity in the previous post, it dawned on me yesterday that we have turned a corner. Where there was once a system of external restraints in place to keep us on the straight and narrow — the Church was a big part of that system — there is now (and has been for a long time) an ongoing revolt against that. It has become the primary business of our culture today to throw over the old external restraints on how we are going to behave.

We're going through a cultural adolescence, in other words. Adolescence is the period of life when, as individuals, we break the shackles of parental control and learn to control ourselves. Like as not, we make mistakes, sometimes big ones. We do things we later regret. We tend to run wild.

But we come out the other side as adults who can take full charge of their own affairs, morally and practically.

That's what's happening in our cultural adolescence. Every time some celebrity acts up or acts out in full public view, filling the tabloids with gossip fodder, the culture pricks up its ears in much the same way as teenagers do when a schoolmate gets caught by the principal breaking the rules. It's how we learn about actions and their consequences, and right and wrong, and justice.

Later, when we are no longer being told what to do and what not to do, we'll need to know those things.


We've been going through our cultural adolescence for some time now — at least since the advent of rock 'n' roll in the 1950s. In fact, it was while I was listening to rock by Paul McCartney on my iPod that it struck me that the complaints I have about how we behave today — crude, rude, and lewd, rather than chaste and demure — are mostly about the extreme, highly publicized excesses of behavior people are prone to these days. Most of us behave pretty well, most of the time. So why haven't we actually gone to hell in a handbasket, I asked myself.

Because, I answered, there is some sort of bottom-up morality forming. That is, once top-down, external strictures on personal behavior are effectively overthrown, people have been finding ways and means of keeping their tendencies toward behavioral excess at bay.

One of the ways we do this is by vicariously experiencing the excesses of others, whether real or fictional or musical. This is why so many rock and rap lyrics are raunchy. Why so many movies and TV shows are over-the-top. Why we have such a low, mean, tabloid-y culture. Why the news on TV emphasizes drive-by shootings and other sensationalist gore.

This is also why there are so many mistakes being made by us average people. I consider such things as abortion and drug dependency to be (whatever else they are) moral mistakes. Just as teens make mistakes en route to maturity, members of an adolescent culture do so as well.

But the culture is maturing. Abortions are down. Drug abuse is down. Teen pregnancy is down. Gradually, we are learning to control ourselves in the absence of top-down, external taboos.

(To be continued in "O for Order" ... )

Monday, June 04, 2007

C for Chastity

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
In my previous post, F for Freedom, I talked about one of the themes of Pope Benedict XVI's Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures: freedom. Specifically, is the modern understanding of freedom as a matter of individual, radically unfettered self-expression compatible with the traditional Christian view of the inviolability of human life and dignity?

That comes down to, I suggested, a question of chastity. Although the pope doesn't say so outright in his book, it's clear he feels our dignity is best served by self-imposed chastity and not by radically free self-expression.

Of course, the word "chastity" conjures up images of sexual self-restraint, primarily. In the Catholic lexicon — and I say this as a Catholic — chastity is actually more than that.

Fr. Ron
Rolheiser's
The Shattered
Lantern
"To be chaste means to experience things, all things, respectfully and to drink them in only when we are ready for them. ... Unbridled restlessness makes us unhealthily impatient for experience ... Greed and impatience push us toward irresponsible experience," writes Ronald Rolheiser, a Catholic priest, in The Shattered Lantern: Rediscovering a Felt Presence of God.

As I intimated in my prior post, when you combine the exigencies of "want to" and "now," you have a recipe for what Rolheiser calls "unbridled restlessness," the enemy of chastity. It doesn't really matter whether the urge for immediate gratification involves sex or not.

Still, self-indulgent sex is a biggie in our culture; we call it "hooking up." That's why it comes as no surprise that the Catholic Church opposes sex outside the confines of heterosexual marriage. It even opposes sex within marriage if one partner is using the other merely for personal gratification ... or even if both partners are treating each other as objects.


I ask myself all sorts of questions about the topic of sexual chastity as it is viewed within Christianity, and I find I can't answer a lot of them.

I don't really understand, for example, why homosexual relations are considered "objectively disordered" by the Church. Clearly, the pope's rhetoric in Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures and elsewhere, combined with other things I have heard and read, implies that homosexual behavior is wrong because it is unchaste, which means he thinks it the handmaid of gratification and not of love. But is that true, always and everywhere? Is homosexual sex necessarily any more unchaste than married, heterosexual sex?

Also, I don't really understand why the Church finds fault with "artificial" means of birth control. The so-called "rhythm method" is permitted as "natural," but condoms and pills are prohibited as "unnatural." With the former, sex has to be avoided on certain days of the month, which may, I suppose, strengthen a couple's ability to postpone gratification in the name of chastity. Is that the not-so-hidden agenda here?


I also ask myself a lot of hard-to-answer questions about chastity in general, in the context of our popular culture today. The culture is not known for promoting abnegation and self-mastery, to say the least.

It seems rather to push us right up to the edge of truly "bad" behavior. Occasionally, some of us go way beyond the edge. When that happens publicly to a star of Hollywood or sports or the mass media, we talk about it for months.

Then there's the fictional "bad" behavior we see all the time on TV or movie screens. It used to be only the villain of the piece who misbehaved. Now the hero can too.

In fact, the popular culture seems to have turned into a giant sociological laboratory in which we're continually asking ourselves, "How far can we go?"

My question is, "Is this so bad?"


Let me put that question another way: "Is there any way we can be good Christians without a return to chastity as the Church traditionally defines it?"

(I'll sidestep the question as it applies to Jews, Muslims, and members of other religions. I have a hard enough time dealing with it in the Christian context.)

One might think that the answer to the question in that form is simple: if an individual freely opts to be a practicing Christian and accordingly chaste, there is no conflict. But, clearly, the pope urges a culture that promotes chastity not individually but communally ... chastity being the antithesis to the mandate of radically free self-expression which he finds at the core of secular values today.

In other words, if self-expression is to be reined in, in the name of what will it be done? Life and dignity. How would it be done? Manifestly, by opting not to express our freedom in certain ways. But if that is not going to turn back into just another way of expressing our radical freedom of choice as individuals, we would have to act in concert and be publicly and overtly chaste together ... which would change the culture drastically.

(To be continued in "M for Maturity" ... )

Sunday, June 03, 2007

F for Freedom

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
One of the themes of Pope Benedict XVI's Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures is freedom. There are in Western culture today two competing notions of it. According to one notion of human liberty, each one of us ought to be free to express "who we are" in any way we see fit, as long as it does not trample on another individual's equal right to free self-expression.

That is not the pope's notion of freedom. His notion is that we are free only to the extent that exercising our freedoms does not take the life of, or violate the essential dignity of, a human person — including ourselves.

Most of the time, our untrammeled, individualistic self-expression is not circumscribed by the pope's twin criteria of the inviolability of life and the sanctity of personal dignity. But there are times when the two points of view diverge.

One of these times is when a woman considers having an abortion. If her "freedom to choose" gets exercised, her fetus's life gets snuffed out.

Other situations in which the pope would find a divergence are those involving questions of chastity. A woman considering an abortion has not necessarily been unchaste, since her gestating infant may well have been conceived within the confines of holy wedlock. But other hot-button issues surrounding church teaching today are often questions of chastity.

Sex without marriage. Sex between people of the same gender. Using contraceptive devices such as condoms and technologies such as birth control pills. These are three hotly debated topics that divide the pope's notion of freedom from the secular view that all of the above are fine as long as they are acts of individual self-expression that hurt no one. In the pope's view they are all offenses against life, dignity, and chastity.


I personally struggle with such questions myself. For instance, last night I squirmed as I watched the recent excellent movie "V for Vendetta."

Though it occurs in the year 2020, it's set in a 1984-like British dystopia in which an all-powerful High Chancellor and his minions have stripped the people of all real freedom in the name of "peace," "order," and, yes, "faith." One masked man, "V," strikes a blow for freedom by blowing up the courtrooms of the Old Bailey — now symbols of injustice — and pirating the television airwaves to broadcast a call-to-arms to the oppressed. In exactly one year, on the November 5th anniversary of Guy Fawkes Day, the people are asked by "V" to rise up and incinerate the Houses of Parliament, and thereby the dictatorship.

Great stuff ... except that the plot makes clear that the filmmakers' stance with regard to freedom is centered around what the pope would assail as offensive to life, dignity, and chastity.

One of the movie's more sympathetic characters, played by Stephen Fry, takes in the story's heroine, Natalie Portman, "V's" sometime henchwoman, when she is on the run from the police. He is actually her boss at the un-BBC of the day, and as much of a dissident as one can be under the circumstances of the oppression. As such, he has his secrets. One of them is that he reads the Koran for its beautiful poetry — the Koran having been banned by the government because it supposedly underwrote 9/11-type terrorism.

Another of his secrets is that the people he would like to love and be intimate with are not permitted to him — a veiled reference, one assumes, to his homosexuality.

Portman is eventually put in prison and finds, concealed in a rat's hole in her cell, the life story of another prisoner, written stealthily on toilet paper. This testament of her female predecessor tells of how she and her equally female lover had been sharing an idyllic life together for three sweet years when the government murdered her partner and incarcerated her. Their lesbian relationship was, it seems, impermissible under the law.

So we would seem to have, ostensibly, a stark choice between freedom, on the one hand, and what the pope would call the call to chastity. If we choose chastity — no sex outside heterosexual marriage, and so forth — we ipso facto lose all freedom.

Put another way, if we circumscribe sexual freedoms in any way, we are on a slippery slope to complete tyranny. That would seem to be the subtext of "V for Vendetta."


The question is, is it true?

It would arguably be true if, as the filmmakers (who also made the "Matrix" series) seem to feel, any restriction, self-imposed or otherwise, on our radical freedom of self-expression is tantamount to tyranny. Certainly the dictates of chastity qualify here, for chastity calls us to observe self-imposed limits on how we express "who we are."

That is, they do so under the assumption that we "are" whatever it is that we want to do, and have the power to do, now. If we want to "hook up" now, and if we have the power to keep from making babies when we do so, fine.

The pope would say that the exigencies of "want to" and "now" enslave us, expunge our true selves from our very own view. Our true selves are ordered to life, dignity, and chastity, not "want to" or "now." The true tyrant in all of this controversy over freedom is at work inside us, the pope would say. The true tyrant is the one who would conceal from us who we really "are."

(To be continued in "C for Chastity" ... )

Friday, June 01, 2007

Life's Inviolability at the Center of Morality

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
I have finished reading Pope Benedict XVI's recent book Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures. It's a small one, but a great one. To me, the axis around which the whole thought of the book pivots is that of the inviolability of human life.

It it thus a book which even nonbelievers can seek sustenance in.

In fact, the book is aimed more at atheists and agnostics than at believers. The Holy Father argues that atheism contains a fatal flaw: in opposing religious dogmatism, it is itself dogmatic. Agnosticism likewise stumbles over the impossibility of carrying out in practice its theory that one can and should sidestep the question of God's existence as undecidable. When push comes to shove — as it does at every instant of our waking life, the pope points out — we have to decide on moral commitments that, ultimately, find their roots only in God's self-revelation.

Take the notion of the inviolability of human life. Under most circumstances, it sounds good to even the most confirmed non-believer ears, the assertion that no human life ought to be taken by human hands. But without God in the philosophical picture, the principle slips through our fingers like a soap bubble, squirting out in the general direction of a supposed "right" of individuals to free self-expression and personal autonomy. This is the basic "right" which we enshrine today in our secular, post-Enlightenment Western culture.

Thus, when the "right to life" of a human fetus impacts upon the "right to privacy" of a pregnant woman contemplating abortion, the latter wins.


The secular governmental program of "rights" protection quickly becomes much like spin-balancing a tire. In spin-balancing a wheel with a tire on it, the wheel is mounted on a machine that rotates it at high speed. If it wobbles, the machine is stopped and a weight is hammered into the rim. Spun again, the wheel may still wobble ... calling for another weight to be hammered in. Eventually, after enough weights, maybe no more wobble.

Unless, that is, the wheel was originally mounted off center on the machine. Then there's no amount of weight whose judicious application can de-wobble it.

In human culture, when the once-axial idea of an inviolable life given by God to each person, no matter how puny and weak, squirts over into the secular domain, we find ourselves placing individual autonomy rights in the middle of our moral order ... not guarantees of life's sanctity and inviolability.

The wheel of the culture — and the hub of its guiding moral philosophy — is accordingly mounted off center. The neverending secular program of adding weight after weight to society's moral hub to try to get the cultural rim in proper balance becomes a lost cause.


Building our moral house on the foundation of radically free individual self-expression is building it on quicksand. The chimera of "I'm OK, You're OK!" all too quickly turns into "I'm suing you and, what's more, I'm going to slime your name all over the Internet, you self-serving snake!"

You can't balance out self-serving with more self-serving. An ethos of serving others is the only way to spin-balance society. But service to others can only be grounded in seeing their lives as being as sacrosanct as our own ... seeing other persons through the eyes of God, as it were. Ignoring God's affirming gaze, said in scripture to be cast upon us all without exception, gives us no reliable basis for squelching self-serving attitudes and taking the wobble out of our secular culture.


This is why the pope invites nonbelievers to opt to live their life as if God exists. For them to make God a postulate of their moral lives — not necessarily a provable fact, simply a starting point for moral discourse and action — would help get our culture back on center.

I invite all nonbelievers to think deeply about this.

Thursday, May 31, 2007

The Crisis in Our Culture

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
Pope Benedict XVI's recent book Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures is one that should not be missed. As I said in my previous post, it is a radical riposte to post-Enlightenment thinking which, for the foundational Christian insistence on the personal dignity of man, made in God's image, substitutes the absolute liberty of the individual to express himself freely ... as long as doing so mortally offends no other individual or group.

Unfortunately, that Enlightenment postulate contains its own internal contradiction. There is ultimately no way in which such radical freedom of our individual, personal self-expression doesn't run aground on the angry sensibilities of others who despise what we say. We in modern society, accordingly, devise laws to protect us vessels of radical freedom from each other's "hateful" expression. Laws then unavoidably proliferate to enshrine offended citizens' claimed needs for further protection, and state powers grow at the expense of liberty! Thus, the contradiction.

The Christian postulate, that human dignity itself lies at the root of all morality and justice, is grounded in the belief that God made everything, including man, upon which event he beheld his creation, finding "it was very good" (Genesis 1:31, quoted on p. 71). The key word is "behold": God sees us, includes us in his gaze, however small and weak we may be. Therein lies our unimpeachable claim to personal dignity.

And therein lies the personal moral responsibility we each have to use our own eyes in a way that validates the like claim to dignity of every other human person ... rather that to close our eyes to him or her and to treat that other human person as an object to be utilized and/or disposed of at our pleasure.


Secularists who prefer the Enlightenment credo to the Judeo-Christian one are not ogres who are snarlingly, universally blind to others' dignities. Unless and until, that is, the fact that they have put the individual freedom mandate they inherit from the Enlightenment at the center of their value system — in place of the erstwhile religious mandate to publicly circumscribe our own freedoms in deference the claims others make on us — forces them to choose the former credo over the latter, if only not to make liars of themselves.

This, the pope observes, is what happens when abortion rights are said to be within the province of a woman's private discretion, as a radically free individual. When a "privacy" justification for abortion rights is asserted in today's society, it necessarily forces all of us to avert our eyes from the unseen fetus, hidden away in a womb. And we are only too willing to look away, for when we decline to envision that the fetus has a face and eyes of its own, we avoid the cognitive dissonance that would otherwise spring from our instinctive readiness to accord a being with human face and human eyes some sort of claim to inviolability, if we but look upon that face and into those eyes.

The pope thinks our culture is in crisis because we accept abortion-on-demand's legality in the name of radical individual liberty. I find, somewhat to my own surprise, that I agree with him.


Throughout my life, including the last twenty years of it, during which I have called myself a Christian, I have nurtured a strong bias toward accepting unquestioningly the Enlightenment prescription of radical individual liberty. It is this very prescription which the pope says is a distortion of the Christian ethos that gave birth to it.

I have no intention here of giving a full account of the history of my libertarian assumptions, but my attitude in the 1960s toward the War in Vietnam gives you its essential flavor. If I am going to be completely honest with myself, I have to admit that perhaps the major reason I opposed that war as a late-teen and then a twenty-something had to do with the indignation I felt at the thought of being drafted and forced to fight in it.

The question, for me, was more than one of whether the war was right or wrong. It was a question of, "How dare they not ask me whether I think it's a right and just war, before they draft me?"

In other words, my assumption that my own liberty trumped any and all claims that my society made upon me — my assumption that I had no civic responsibility to serve — was something that I never called into question. And to avoid calling it into question, my psychological strategy was to call the war immoral on its very face.

Now, that particular war may indeed have been immoral and unjust ... but so too, I now see, was my assumption that the dictates of radical individaul liberty mandated my right to opt out, at my own personal discretion, from fighting in it.


For me to follow the pope and honor what he says in Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures, I'll have to scrap that attitude. It's admittedly tricky to do, for there are indeed Christian justifications for pacifism and nonviolence, ones the pope would respect. And there are indeed Christian criteria for a war's being just, according to which the Vietnam conflict may not have passed muster.

Yet, the pope seems to suggest, when one argues against a war from Enlightenment-enshrined considerations of personal liberty alone, one is building one's house on moral quicksand. Hmmm ... tricky, indeed, to see that the moral conclusion may be the same — this war is a bad war, for example — but the justifications for that conclusion are nevertheless flawed and need to be jettisoned.

Yet this is what the pope is telling secularists. No matter how much religion and secularism (he calls the latter "laicism") may agree on a great many grand moral pronouncements, ultimately what matters is how you get to those pronouncements. Just as the end never justifies the means, the conclusion never justifies the arguments. If a system of argumentation — a philosophy — is flawed and contains an internal inconsistency, at some point morality itself becomes mutilated.

Wednesday, May 30, 2007

The Self-Contradictions of Liberty

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
Today I finally got hold of a copy of Pope Benedict XVI's Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures, a book I originally mentioned in Reason and Love. Written just before its author, Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, was elected pope, it argues that Europe and the West are experiencing a cultural crisis for a very deep-seated reason: we Westerners have bought into a crippled, incompletely rational philosophy that has an internal contradiction at its core.

At the root of the philosophy that grew out of the 18th-century Age of Enlightenment in Europe, a stance that continues to dominate our Western culture today, is the value we call liberty. Personal liberty as a value and a right was originally derived from the Christian idea of the intrinsic dignity of the human person created in God's image. But the scientific version of rationalism which flourished in the wake of the Enlightenment cut the umbilical cord between such values and an erstwhile belief in God. Liberty became its own supreme good.

The pope shows how that seemingly progressive idea has carried the seed of its own self-cannibalization. Protecting the right of man to liberty inevitably leads to the prohibition of discrimination — see pp. 34-35 — which equally inevitably leads to a reverse discrimination wherein we lose, say, the liberty loudly to proclaim ideas resented by legally protected groups.

There are many manifestations of this that can be listed, among them:

  • Women, as possessors of abortion rights, are protected from hearing the speech of anti-abortion protesters on the way into an abortion clinic, by keeping the protesters at a certain distance away from the woman's path.
  • Meanwhile, as the pope himself mentions (p. 35), the rights to life and liberty of the human fetus about to be aborted get lost in the shuffle.
  • A church that calls homosexuality "objectively disordered" and claims that it, as a church obedient to divine revelation, "does not have the right to confer priestly ordination on women" is, according to the pope's book, relegated to the status of an institution whose tenets are deemed entirely private matters of merely subjective belief — which, I think the pope would agree, is equivalent to designating them "not even wrong" at the level of our publicly shared culture.
  • On many progressive college campuses, "politically incorrect" speech is simply not tolerated, and can be grounds for dismissal.
  • We in the U.S. now feel we need special laws against "hate crimes" in which, for example, assaults aggravated by hateful, discriminatory motivations on the part of the perpetrator draw longer jail sentences. How does a jury know the perp's inner motivations? Well, if the perp has spoken out against homosexuality and slugs a gay guy in a bar fight, presumably it was a hate crime. The onus is on the assailant to show that it wasn't.

I'm not trying to say that hate is OK, or that laws should change, or that controversial positions taken by the Catholic Church are unassailable. The overarching point that the pope is making, and that I agree with, is that liberty, unmoored from the Christian religious values which engendered it, ties itself in knots. It then needs ever more knots in order to balance out the first knots. The compensating knots need to be tied — by an increasingly powerful state! — at the cost, ultimately, of handcuffing liberty itself.

This is the logical flaw in the hard diamond of Enlightenment thought, to the extent that its science-only version of rationality disenfranchises the Christian religion and associated moral understandings which originally gave rise to secularism's most cherished values.


To the Enlightenment axiom that personal liberty can serve as the indisputable source of all else we need to believe in, morally and ethically, the pope juxtaposes Christianity's foundational assumption: human life itself is sacred; it belongs to God. Liberty, though itself a worthy value, derives from the dignity of the human person who is made in God's image, and whose life comes as a gift from God.

That idea is the only true basis for morality, for justice, for a rationality that is not crippled and incomplete ... and, yes, for liberty.