Showing posts with label Our Changing Mores. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Our Changing Mores. Show all posts

Friday, August 30, 2013

"Twerk" on MTV, Miley Cyrus Did

In 2013, 'twerk' was added to the Oxford Dictionary Online. The dictionary said the word had been around for 20 years, but the evidence for it to be included in the dictionary had tipped the scale when U.S. pop star Miley Cyrus gave a controversial and headline-producing twerking dance at the MTV Video Music Awards on August 25, 2013.

— Wikipedia          

The verb "twerk," says the Oxford dictionary, means "dance to popular music in a sexually provocative manner involving thrusting hip movements and a low, squatting stance."

Much debate ensued after Miley Cyrus "twerked" onscreen at MTV. Was her performance appropriate, the multitudes asked, or not?

Miley Cyrus on MTV
More Miley

I say not. My thought is that it extended a long-term trend a bridge too far. When I was in college at Georgetown in the late 1960s, the university enforced a rule against "public display of affection": no kissing or petting outdoors or in public view. The more general rule, at G'town and in society, was that sex is to be kept private. If it's sexual, hide it from public view.

The rule was coming apart at the seams even then. It had been doing so for decades, going back to the ending of the Victorian era of the final two-thirds of the nineteenth century. "Victorian morality can describe any set of values that espouse sexual restraint, low tolerance of crime and a strict social code of conduct," says Wikipedia. Strict restraints on sexual attitudes and behavior meant men and women wore clothes that covered all and that emphasized nothing that might arouse sexual feelings. Sex obviously happened, and a lot of it was downright illicit. There's no doubt about it. But it was done in private.

My generation was not the first to rebel, but in our own nineteen-sixties sexual revolution the gloves — and much else besides — came all the way off. Ample justification was given: that getting rid of repression and of hypocrisy would make society and its citizens all that much healthier.

Now we have a 20-year-old former child star looking to extend her something-very-like-a-career by a twerking display on TV. We have rampant sexual abuse in the U.S. military. "More than 70% of male Internet users from 18 to 34," according to Wikipedia, "visit a pornographic site in a typical month." Priestly child sexual abuse has racked the Catholic Church. Scandal after scandal has cut short a host of political careers and besmirched the memory of one of the most revered of college football coaches.

All because sex is, I believe, now more public than private. Not the act itself (at least for the most part) buts its hintings, simulacra, and accouterments.

You might think — and a lot of people actually do think — there's no reason why the loosening of nineteenth-century moral strictures that was supposed to make us saner would instead be making us sicker. You might think that between Queen Victoria's corsetings and Miley's MTV cavortings there ought to be a sweet spot which society can occupy, with only a few depraved outliers to either side of the sensible median strip.

It hasn't happened. The depraved outliers are everywhere. So I'd say we need to rein ourselves in. The only way to do that, I think, is to take sex back into the privacy of the boudoir an keep it under demure covers.

How might that happen? We need to start by shrinking the boundary of personal behavior that is considered appropriate. I have in mind, to begin with, a new reticence about stuff that really isn't all that naughty, in the grand scheme of things. For example: no posterior anatomy visible for guys with low-slung belt lines; no visible bra straps for gals. Start with tiny little things like those.

Start with making this taboo ...

... and this.

Whoa! I hear voices raised in protest already. These infractions are, to the extent they are sexual displays at all, very minor ones. They are matters of personal choice and free individual expression. Every generation since Victoria passed away in 1901 has shown more and more anatomy, more and more underwear, and where do you draw the line? Isn't this all just a Trojan horse for a thoroughgoing new Victorianism?

I hope not. But it isn't at all clear to me that there really exists a viable sweet spot between Victorian deprivation and no-holds-barred depravity — it has to be one that the bulk of us can hold to — unless it is also one that abhors (for example) hordes of us "sexting" up a storm or assiduously "tweeting our junk" at every conceivable opportunity. Such activities are not necessarily immoral but, as I hope we are learning, they straddle the increasingly invisible line between public and private. Which is why we all now know so well the name of former-Rep. Anthony Weiner.

So, no more "sexting." No more "tweeting our junk." No more peeking-out bra straps. No more visible vertical smiles. And no more of the many other "innocent" behaviors that put us on a slippery slope to less-minor infractions and then to much more that is far worse.

Notice that I am saying nothing about what can or ought to happen between consenting adults in their bedroom or boudoir. I make no claim to knowing what kinds of sex are quote-unquote bad, or, for that matter, good. All I am saying is give sexual privacy a fighting chance. Keep sex, its stand-ins, its simulacra, and its accouterments well out of public view, and we will see whether I am right and the abuses diminish.


Saturday, June 08, 2013

A New Awakening, Part 12

I have in this ongoing series been investigating the wisdom of myth as it informs what I call a potential "new awakening" of spirituality in our society. I take as one of my main reference points the book and PBS television series The Power of Myth, in which, during the mid-1980s, Bill Moyers interviewed at great length the scholar of comparative mythology Joseph Campbell.

In The Power of Myth, Joseph Campbell tells Bill Moyers that myth has four functions: the mystical, the cosmological, the sociological, and the pedagogical. The mystical function (a.k.a. the metaphysical function) is meant to lead us to awe before the mystery of creation, after which “the universe becomes, as it were, a holy picture.”

Carl Sagan, whose
Cosmos TV series
brought us a sense of awe
in the face of the discoveries

of modern science
The cosmological function of myth is to tell us “what the shape of the universe is, but showing it in such a way that the mystery again comes through.” At its best, Campbell says, our scientific awareness today is all about that.

The sociological function is for the purpose of “supporting and validating a certain social order,” Campbell says. “And here’s where the myths vary enormously from place to place. You can have a whole mythology for polygamy, a whole mythology for monogamy. Either one’s okay. It depends on where you are. It is this sociological function of myth that has taken over in our world — and it is out of date.”

Finally, the pedagogical function tells us “how to live a human lifetime under any circumstances. Myths,” according to Campbell, “can teach you that.”

Moses, who gave us the
Ten Commandments handed
down by God
Campbell makes clear throughout The Power of Myth that he strongly urges us to reclaim the fourth function of myth — and to an equally great extent, the first and second functions — and not so much the third. The validation of a particular social order boils down to, Campbell somewhat disparagingly says, “Ethical laws. The laws of life as it should be in the good society. All of Yahweh’s pages and pages and pages of what kind of clothes to wear, how to behave to each other, and so forth, in the first millennium B.C.” But those ancient laws are, he says, “out of date” today.

Many Catholics today would have a problem with that attitude. They would re-label the "ethical" the "moral" and instead insist on a "new evangelization" in behalf of the church as the teaching authority responsible for promulgating traditional moral rules that Campbell might call into question. (See this story in The Washington Post.) If polygamy is "okay," depending on "where you are" — on your social circumstances, that is — then such things as abortion on demand, gay marriage, birth control paid for by universal health coverage, and in vitro fertilization become moral questions whose answers are relative to time and place.

I personally find problematic any pooh-poohing of the sociological function of our religions and their underlying mythologies. My main reason is that we can't very well have a "new awakening" of spirituality based on the four functions of myth if one of the functions is effectively relegated to the trash heap.

Let me be as clear as I can about that touchy subject. I personally support such hot-button moral choices as abortion on demand, gay marriage, birth control paid for by universal health coverage, and in vitro fertilization. I think such moral questions are relative to time and place. But I recognize that such issues need to be resolved, over time, within a framework of sociological authority grounded ultimately in all four functions of myth. We can't completely peel off our ethical/moral debates from any "new awakening" of spirituality that might occur as we rediscover the "power of myth."

Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Are Men Failing?

New York Times columnist David Brooks's recent "Why Men Fail" merits attention. Mr. Brooks's column summarizes a recent book by Hanna Rosin, The End of Men: And the Rise of Women, to the effect that during the last 40 years, men in our culture have failed to demonstrate sufficient flexibility and have accordingly lost ground, while women have exhibited greater adaptablilty and, relatively speaking, have prospered.

Men's hyper-rigidity has doomed them to dropping out of the labor force in disturbing numbers, says Mr. Brooks, echoing Ms. Rosin. They more and more find themselves collecting disability compensation, and they are ceding the lead in jobs and, in some cases, even pay to women.

All because women are more adaptable.

Brooks contrasts Ms. Rosin's hypothesis with the older theory that men and boys have disadvantages that are at once cultural and genetic/neurological: so they fidget and daydream in school; they aren't "emotionally sensitive and aware of context" as adults; they can't "communicate smoothly" as employees.

I don't really know whether Rosin's hyper-rigidity thesis explains why little boys get more D's and F's in school than little girls do. Perhaps the old theory and the new hypothesis are both telling us something we need to know.

But Brooks's column says something else that is of great interest to me:

Rosin also reports from college campuses where women are pioneering new social arrangements. The usual story is that men are exploiting the new campus hookup culture in order to get plenty of sex without romantic commitments. Rosin argues that, in fact, women support the hookup culture. It allows them to have sex and fun without any time-consuming distractions from their careers. Like new immigrants, women are desperate to rise, and they embrace social and sexual rules that give them the freedom to focus on their professional lives.

"Desperate to rise" seems a bit wide of the mark. Desperate? Yet I bet Brooks is right that the hookup culture in colleges is chosen by women as a surrogate to committed relationships that might truncate their professional aspirations.

* * * * *

What if as a woman professional — specifically, a university professor — you are breast-feeding a baby, and you need to teach a class at baby's feeding time?

Under normal circumstances, working mothers can cope by pumping their breasts and feeding baby on expelled milk while in public. But American University professor Adrienne Pine ran into a situation where her baby was sick one morning and she had no good child-care options, so she brought her infant along to a 75-minute class she was teaching. I'm guessing that pumping was for some reason not an option in this situation. Once in the classroom, the baby grew restless, and "Pine breast-fed her while continuing her lecture in front of 40 students." So says this article in The Washington Post.

That sparked a controversy. "Some students [who were interviewed] said breast-feeding doesn’t belong in the classroom."

This was a feminist anthropology class, and Pine has since written that "I fed my sick baby [in it] without disrupting the lecture so as to not have to cancel the first day of class. I doubt anyone saw my nipple, because I’m pretty good at covering it. But if they did, they now know that I too, a university professor, like them, have nipples."

A sign of the times, I think. Beyond that, I'm not sure how I feel about this.

* * * * *

Another Washington Post story points up that both women and men today are, uh, desperate to enhance those bodily features that distinguish them from the other sex. "NJ woman charged with fatal penis enlargement injection pleads not guilty to manslaughter" says a 23-year-old man died the day after Kasia Rivera, 35, injected silicon into his penis, supposedly to lengthen it.

Kasia Rivera, charged with
reckless manslaughter in
penis-enlargement botch
According to Dr. Daniel S. Elliott, an associate professor of urology at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn.:

Enhancement procedures performed by unlicensed practitioners or people with no medical training are more commonly seen among women ... Liquid silicone is sought on the black market by women seeking to enhance their figures, even though it is not approved for cosmetic injections. Besides liquid silicone, injections of substances including paraffin, petroleum jelly and hydrogel have been illegally used to enlarge women’s breasts, hips and buttocks.

Of course, silicone breast and buttock implants (not liquid silicone) are often used cosmetically by women today.

Many men resort to other techniques to enlarge their penis. As far as I know, none of them work.

But why? Why the need for a bigger sex organ (men), bigger boobs and booties (women), and buffer bodies (both sexes)?

Both sexes, I think, realize they have to attract and then hold onto mates not just once or maybe twice in a lifetime, but maybe once or twice in a college semester. There's a continual lottery going on, from both sexes' point of view. A survival-of-the-sexiest, if you will.

It's a reflection of how long it takes to get a first-class education these days, a factor that affects both sexes, but also of the gender-specific need of today's women to hold firmly onto men's interest while at the same time keeping them at arm's length as they go for that advanced degree.

Meanwhile — dare I say it? — men feel increasingly emasculated. A bigger male member seems entirely in order. It makes them (us) feel more of a man.

As a 65-year-old, unmarried Catholic man, I personally favor chastity and abstinence. But I think it's unrealistic to expect that of young women and men who must wait many long years for marriage and children, owing to how long they're in school.

That same situation as it affects women, primarily, seems to be driving all I reported above. Young women must be abstinent — fat chance, for most of them — or use contraception. If contraception fails, then abortion is in order. Those are two realities today that Catholic authorities resent and reject.

But they and many other Catholics likewise resent the hookup culture, not to mention the seemingly excessive emphasis women and men are putting on their physical attributes.

And professors breast-feeding in front of their students will seem, to most Catholics, an affront to common decency.

We Catholics really need to come to grips with how much society has changed! That much I'm sure of, and for that change in Catholic attitude, I earnestly pray ...