Showing posts with label Divine Reason. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Divine Reason. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Prominent Evangelical Theologian Returns to Catholic Church

A recent Catholic News Service article, "Prominent Evangelical Theologian Returns to Catholic Church," is of great interest to me. According to the article, Francis J. Beckwith, one of the most prominent Evangelical scholars in America, has returned to his childhood roots and re-entered into full communion with the Roman Catholic Church. His switch, accompanied by the conversion of his wife, has involved his resignation as president of the Evangelical Theological Society. That resignation is documented in this post he made to Right Reason, the "weblog for conservative philosophers." That post also contains a wealth of comments from others about Mr. Beckwith's change of church affiliation, both pro and con.

I happen to be a Catholic who converted from Protestantism of the Episcopalian/High Anglican variety after spending my early years mostly unchurched. My lapsed parents' backgrounds were Southern Baptist on my mother's side and Methodist on my father's. When I finally felt called to worship God at about age 40, I found my way to an Episcopal congregation, thanks to the help of a friend. Later, another friend introduced me to Catholicism — or, re-introduced me, since I had learned much about the faith as a student at Georgetown in the '60's — at a time when I had become personally dissatisfied with Anglicanism. I underwent the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults and was confirmed as a Roman Catholic in 1995.

I now, to some inner surprise, find my religious journey has left me bewildered by some of the matters raised by Mr. Beckwith and others, in the wake of his conversion.


Mr. Beckwith writes in his blog post:
... I began reading the Early Church Fathers as well as some of the more sophisticated works on justification by Catholic authors. I became convinced that the Early Church is more Catholic than Protestant and that the Catholic view of justification, correctly understood, is biblically and historically defensible. Even though I also believe that the Reformed view is biblically and historically defensible, I think the Catholic view has more explanatory power to account for both all the biblical texts on justification as well as the church’s historical understanding of salvation prior to the Reformation all the way back to the ancient church of the first few centuries. Moreover, much of what I have taken for granted as a Protestant—e.g., the catholic creeds, the doctrines of the Trinity and the Incarnation, the Christian understanding of man, and the canon of Scripture—is the result of a Church that made judgments about these matters and on which non-Catholics, including Evangelicals, have declared and grounded their Christian orthodoxy in a world hostile to it. Given these considerations, I thought it wise for me to err on the side of the Church with historical and theological continuity with the first generations of Christians that followed Christ’s Apostles.

To be quite honest, I don't follow all of that. The prose is a bit turgid ... and the basic Protestant-Catholic controversy over justification — God's act of declaring or making a sinner righteous before God — is one I simply don't think deserves all the ink it has been given over the centuries since the Protestant Reformation.

Of course, I get why justification is crucial in Christianity. It's a no-brainer, the idea that God and sin can't share the same "space" in heaven, so the fact that each of us humans is a sinner, even post-Crucifixion, has to be offset or overcome somehow.

I also understand that Martin Luther believed in sola fide, justification by faith alone, when in 1517 he challenged (per Wikipedia) "the Roman Catholic practice of indulgences for penance, and for that reason it [sola fide] is called the material cause of the Protestant Reformation, while the doctrine of sola scriptura is considered the formal cause."

Sola scriptura as a Protestant doctrine basically holds that Sacred Scripture — the Holy Bible — does not need interpreting by church teaching that takes place in the context of Sacred Tradition.


Sacred Tradition is the continuing, post-biblical elaboration of Christian understanding and doctrine reflected in the dogma of the Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches — Christian churches that adhere to the apostolic succession (the unbroken line of bishops beginning with the original apostles). It is the apostolic succession which is said to justify those churches in so extending Christian dogma from time to time.

The Catholic Church, for example, treats as dogma the ideas of papal infallibility, the Immaculate Conception of Mary, the Mother of God — i.e., Christ — and Mary's bodily Assumption into heaven. Admittedly, that any of those three items ought to be taken as indisputable articles of faith is not obvious from reading the Bible alone. Without the elaboration of Christian understanding that is embodied in the Sacred Tradition, it would be hard to credit them.

When Mr. Beckwith writes in his blog piece:
There is a conversation in [the Evangelical Theological Society] that must take place, a conversation about the relationship between Evangelicalism and what is called the “Great Tradition,” a tradition from which all Christians can trace their spiritual and ecclesiastical paternity. It is a conversation that I welcome, and it is one in which I hope to be a participant ...

... the "Great Tradition" he refers to is that same "Sacred Tradition." I gather he feels, uncontroversially, that this tradition is rooted in the writings of the early Church Fathers. Those writings are to him a source of valid authority and purportedly show him that "the early church is more Catholic than Protestant and that the Catholic view of justification, correctly understood, is biblically and historically defensible."


Today, the Catholic News Service article says, the official Catholic view of justification, as expressed in a 1999 joint declaration with Lutherans, is this:
By grace alone, in faith in Christ's saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit, who renews our hearts while calling us to good works.

Such a formulation seems to contradict what I imagine to be an erroneous, if widespread, understanding of the Catholic position: that virtuous works can supposedly get us into heaven.

As Mr. Beckwith would have it (per the CNS article):
... "Protestants often misunderstand" what the [Catholic] church is trying to convey in its teachings on the need to be virtuous. "The Catholic Church frames the Christian life as one in which you must exercise virtue — not because virtue saves you, but because that's the way God's grace is manifested," he said.


"Grace" is theo-speak for the notion that what God does to save us is unearned and unmerited: done out of the goodness of his heart, as it were. When we receive the free gift of salvation based on faith, it is only natural that we should respond by feeling called to perform "good works." This is what the Catholic Church actually teaches.

According to the Wikipedia sola fide article:
Protestants have historically summarized their view with the formula: "Justification is by faith alone, but not by the faith that is alone [that is, not by a supposed faith that has no accompanying works]."

It accordingly seems to me that there isn't a dime's worth of difference here! Catholics and Protestants actually believe the same thing!


True, that doesn't defuse the issues surrounding the Protestant sola scriptura outlook, which boils down to the question of whether any Church, Catholic or otherwise, has teaching authority beyond what the Bible "says," all by itself. I freely admit that that sounds to me as if it is but a purely formal controversy — as long as what the Church teaches is in harmony with what sola scriptura advocates substantively hold, anyway.

Is there anything about crediting the Immaculate Conception or the Assumption that leaves any of us in a different place, in terms of how we lead a properly Christian life? If so, my Protestant friends, I'd like to know what it is.


Or, take the disagreement over the true nature of the bread and wine of Holy Communion. Whether, or how, Christ is "really" present "in" the Eucharistic elements seems to me less important than that they bring us all to share one table with the Lord. For us to fall out over the precise nature of the items on the menu has to be just plain wrong.

The fault, I recognize, is on both (or all) sides. For reasons I don't understand, we Catholics feel that anything short of the full traditional doctrine of transubstantiation — the bread and wine at the Mass are changed into Christ's body and blood: the Real Presence — puts us on the slippery slope to perdition. But the marks of receiving Holy Communion — in the Catechism of the Catholic Church they include "preserving, increasing, and renewing the life of grace received at Baptism"; "growth in Christian life"; "cleansing us from past sins and preserving us from future sins"; and "strengthening our charity" — would seem to me to be in effect, even if the communicant has no idea of the Real Presence. Ergo, if we fall out over a philosophical dispute concerning the "substance" of the Eucharist, what can be said about our Christian charity in the first place?


As I talked about in Reason and Love, the well-known Catholic writer George Weigel has it that "the reason of God, the Logos through whom all things were made, calls us beyond reason to love" (see this article by Mr. Weigel). That notion echoes what Pope Benedict XVI has been saying, as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger and as pope. Says Mr. Weigel:
[The "scandal" of the Cross] is not a scandal against reason; it is a scandal beyond reason. Creation, Joseph Ratzinger once wrote, displays the “exaggerated infinity of God’s love.”

I think the principle of "not against reason, but beyond reason" offers a way out of the disputes that formally divide Protestants and Catholics.

Take, for example, Mr. Beckwith's saying in his blog post:
... I began reading the Early Church Fathers as well as some of the more sophisticated works on justification by Catholic authors. I became convinced that the Early Church is more Catholic than Protestant and that the Catholic view of justification, correctly understood, is biblically and historically defensible. Even though I also believe that the Reformed view is biblically and historically defensible, I think the Catholic view has more explanatory power ...

What jumps out at me here is that Mr. Beckwith thinks the Reformed (Protestant) view of justification is "biblically and historically defensible," and so is the Catholic view. They're both defensible to human reason. In other words, neither is "against reason."

Accordingly, I think it ought to be possible for us Catholics and our Protestant friends to learn to debate in amity which of our two distinctive views "has more explanatory power," or whatever ... but debate it only after we have broken bread together, as we share in the “exaggerated infinity of God’s love," a love that we all agree lies "beyond reason."

Friday, May 25, 2007

Brute Facts, Alchemy, and Belief in God

I have been spending a fair amount of time recently looking into philosophy, especially the philosophy of mind I discussed in Whither the "Magic" of Mind? and, before that, in a whole host of other posts. One of the phrases I find many of today's philosophers using with some frequency is "brute fact."

A brute fact, in the way in which I read the term, is one which cannot be further explained: it just is. In the Oxford Companion to Philosophy, the definition "a terminus of a series of explanations which is not itself further explicable" is given. A brute fact is accordingly one that, though it may help explain other facts, is not itself susceptible of its own explanation.

For example, some physicists refer to the strength of the gravitational force in our universe as a brute fact, a just-so story that cannot be derived from other physical facts or laws. Science amounts to a hunt for systematic ways to explain what goes on in the world, accounts that can be validated experimentally and empirically, so when a scientist says X is a brute fact, what is being implied is that the hunt ends there, with X.

On the other hand, many scientists hold out hope that there is a Theory of Everything — perhaps some version of superstring theory — from which the strength of the universe's gravitational force just "falls out," as other supposed brute facts (e.g., Planck's constant describing the size of quanta in quantum mechanics) also would do.

But then the Theory of Everything would itself become a brute fact, lacking more basic explanation. Implicit in explanation-seeking science is the contradictory notion that there is an end to explicability, and it lies within the radius of the physical, material world.


At the same time, there is a preference for having everything explained as elegantly as possible, which means by making as few explanatory assumptions as one can. If two facts can be derived from one law as opposed to two separate laws, prefer the one law. This is Occam's Razor at work: "All things being equal, the simplest solution tends to be the best one."

There may be a physical Theory of Everything which we will validate someday. It may account for a whole passel of cosmic constants — strength of gravity, Planck's constant, etc. — that (according to certain interpretations of the Anthropic Principle) make ours a universe "fine-tuned for life." Even so, wouldn't there be certain other brute facts it doesn't account for?

I'm thinking of the existence of consciousness, the moral order in the universe, and the sheer rational coherence of the cosmos.

That consciousness transcends the mere physical is a subject I took up at great length in Whither the "Magic" of Mind? and its predecessors. That the world has a set moral order was one of the topics of the item I posted immediately before this one, Ethos Optional?. I have taken up the subject of the rationality of the mind of God and of his created world in To Reason Is Divine and Free Will and Divine Coherence, among others. But I feel I have yet more to say about rationality here. The big question is, why should we not take the sheer rationality of the cosmos as a brute fact, and nothing more, rather than (as I myself take it) as a sign that there is a God?


Rebecca
Stott's
Ghostwalk
I am presently reading a fascinating novel, Ghostwalk by Rebecca Stott. It concerns a modern-day writer delving into the details of Isaac Newton's biography revolving around an interest in alchemy. Alchemy was at one time a pseudo-scientific inquiry into something supposedly hidden and esoteric in nature. Per Stott (pp. 65-66):
Alchemists, like our scientists today, were trying to uncover nature's secrets, her patterns and processes, trying to work our how the five elements — earth, fire, water, space, air — transmuted into and out of each other under various astrological conditions to make up all forms of matter. They believed that everything, even those things that seemed inert, was actually teeming with spirits and that therefore everything could be raised or provoked into fuller form. They believed that all matter was on the move, moving into and out of everything else, waxing into or waning away from fullness so that lead fell short of gold, just as mortal man fell short of immortality. Under a certain pattern of stars and through fire, any matter (like lead) or spirit (like the human soul) might be "healed" or "killed" or "perfected" or "transmuted" into a greater state. A blossoming would take place. It had a rare beauty, this secret hybrid art made up of magic, chemistry, philosophy, hermetic thought, sacred geometry, and cosmology, a beauty in that passion to make things bloom into a fuller being.

A world in which the "philosopher's stone" could turn base metals to gold and the "elixir of life" could make us immortal would be a decidedly less rational, less coherent one that we actually live in. You might be able to flip a copper penny up through the right sort of air and have it come down a gold doubloon, or a perfected formula for Gatorade might ward off death forever.


In Christian thought, historically, such a world simply does not exist ... but not because it is inconceivable that it might exist. Ours might indeed have been an alchemical universe. But it isn't.

If our rational world were suddenly to become a world of magic, instead of what it is, such an upheaval would generally be thought of, in the long history of the thinking of the church, as the devil's work — for, in our rational world, God limits magic to his own miracles. Stott, for her part, mentions as being among these "the wine into blood, the burning bush, Lazarus raised from the dead" (p. 66). One might also mention Christ's resurrection.

Accordingly, the rationality of the world — the fact that alchemy is not really in the cards for us — would seem to be more than a brute fact. It needs to be taken seriously. It needs explanation. When a scientist skirts this issue by making of the world's rationality a just-so story — "It just so happens that there is no magic in the order of things" — it smacks of a willful blindness to other conceivable orders and to the Creator-Sustainer who holds them at bay.

Suppose I am right, and the rational order of things stands next to the existence of human consciousness and the existence of a moral order in the universe as not brute facts but facts deserving of further explanation. Occam's Razor would seem to dictate that explaining them all with recourse to one single assumption — that there is a God — makes perfect sense.

Monday, May 21, 2007

Reason and Love

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
"Only that creative reason which has manifested itself as love in the crucified God can truly show us what life is," Pope Benedict XVI has written in Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures, a book I expect to read as soon as my public library can fetch it on inter-library loan. Meanwhile, I am engaging in a pursuit of the pope's thought as seen through the eyes of Catholic explicator George Weigel, one of whose recent columns, "To the rescue, again," is a big help.

The article is only indirectly about the Holy Father's ideas concerning rationality. It is, rather, a paean to the “exaggerated infinity of God’s love,” to borrow another of Benedict XVI's phrases.

As I have discussed in earlier installments in this "Divine Reason" series, Benedict XVI has proposed that the gaze of the Christian West needs to put reason back at the center of its visual field. But one is entitled to ask whether reason is the be-all and end-all of Christian values — and if not, what is?

Weigel's article makes clear that the
“exaggerated infinity of God’s love," as revealed in Christ via the Incarnation, the Crucifixion, and the Resurrection, is, if not the be-all, the end-all:
The reason of God, the Logos through whom all things were made, calls us beyond reason to love. Walking the Way of the Cross, Jesus reaches the end of the road of the world’s rationality — and becomes, thereby, a stumbling block and a folly. But a more ample “reason” is at work here: the logic of love, carried out to infinity. That is what bursts the bounds of the tomb on Easter morning. The tomb is empty. The world has been suffused with the power of divine love, which is the most living thing there is.

The
“scandal” of the Cross, as it is spoken of in the New Testament, is for Weigel "not a scandal against reason; it is a scandal beyond reason." I am glad he drew that distinction, for it is one which allows reason to remain firmly at the center of the Christian outlook, even as divine love wreathes it all about at the leading edge of an expansion toward infinity.


I am put in mind of what can happen to certain garden plants that under adverse circumstances tend to die off at their centers, even as their outer parts flourish. This is not good, for without a healthy middle, a plant will soon die. The cure is often to feed the roots.

Pope Benedict is saying that we need to fertilize the roots of the "plant" of Christianity, whose soil is made of reason. This emphasis on reason is not an affront to Christian love. It is its
restoration and salvation.

Friday, May 18, 2007

The World According to Me

In the last week or so I have posted a handful of articles to this blog which together sketch out a bird's-eye view of what I'm going to call the World According to Me, or WAM.

• In I Am a Camera I said the human mind's consciousness feeds the immortal soul with the "qualia" of our subjective experiences, which the soul (acting as a metaphysical "camera") records and carries into the afterlife.

• In Free Will and Divine Coherence I said "coherence within the universe of reason" describes God's true inner nature, which is why we find ourselves living in a rational, comprehensible universe of God's own creation. Then, alluding to the Incompleteness Theorem of the Austrian mathematician Kurt Gödel, I went on to give reason to believe that we have free will in this rational, comprehensible world specifically because God had to choose between that option and having us be deterministic machines, mere robots with good skin.

Had we been deterministic robots, we would have either been somewhat less smart than we are, or else truly stupid. If the former, we would have lacked the ability to see the truth of (among other things) the "Gödelian sentence," the telltale proposition by means of which Kurt Gödel was able to distinguish between human intelligence and that of all producible formal systems of logic, as embodied by even the smartest machines.

If the latter, we would have had mental capabilities less than that of a simplistic formal system that can do no more than derive the basic laws of arithmetic.

Given that our Gödel-aware brains are not flummoxed by the "Gödelian sentence" G — "G [this proposition itself] is not provable within this formal system of logic" is a true statement, and we know it's true, yet the formal system itself is ineluctably blind to its truth — we had to be other than deterministic androids. Hence, we had to have free will!

• In To Reason Is Divine I said more about the idea that rational coherence constitutes God's inner nature, which is why "creative logos" characterizes God's activity in founding and sustaining our world, according to the Christian Bible. Pope Benedict XVI has made a point of emphasizing this aspect of Christian theology, as over against views which hold that God is so "other" than us that his will is not constrained by rationality, or anything else

Though the pope has implied that just such an anti-rational view of God's nature besets the religion of Islam, at least according some of its interpreters, he has also pointed out similar strains of anti-rationalism in Western Christian thought over the last few centuries. He believes we in the West need to get back to our patrimony of truth-seeking reason if our culture is to be able to "give an account of its political commitments and their moral foundations, to itself, or to those who would replace the free societies of the West with a very different pattern of human community, based on a very different idea of God — and, consequently, of the just society."

To which I can only add, "Hear, hear!"

• Finally, in Esse Est Percipi I championed a metaphysics, based in part on that of the early-18th-century philosopher and Church of Ireland bishop George Berkeley, which holds that "to exist is to be observed" — seen or perceived by an agent with a conscious mind.

I alluded to a real-world test that confirms a thought experiment dreamed up by quantum physicist John Archibald Wheeler: which of two equiprobable paths a photon follows to this planet from a galaxy millions of light years distant is not determined until we train our attention on one path or the other!

While it is not universally agreed that the photon's arrival has to be observed by a conscious agent, as opposed to merely recorded by a non-sentient mechanism, there are physicists who believe the former. If they are right — and I like to think they are — then observational consciousness somehow produces material actuality.

Hopping back to the thought of Berkeley, I then hypothesized that the material reality of the universe is sustained in its existence by God's observational consciousness.


God, soul, afterlife, free will — all are longstanding topics of theological and philosophical inquiry. So, too, are questions of human consciousness — what it is, how it arises — and of mind in general — is it real, is it distinct from the physical, material world? In WAM, the World According to Me:

  • God
  • the soul
  • the afterlife
  • human free will
  • human consciousness, and
  • the actuality of mind, as distinct from matter
are all real.

The four posts just mentioned show how these questions interlock together, like the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle. I could also have introduced into the puzzle picture the question of Darwinian evolution, which I also believe in. In fact, I believe that particular puzzle piece latches directly to the piece concerning human free will. If our lives are not determined by an ineluctable destiny, then neither is the life of the world. Our planet is free to evolve as it will.

Another puzzle piece would seem to be that which represents the lawfulness of the universe — i.e., the pervasiveness and reliability of the laws of nature which science discovers. Without that lawfulness, graceful evolution would have been impossible. The laws of nature themselves are evidence of a Creator who is rational to his core.

Thus, the tenets of WAM, the World According to Me.


My purpose in going to such lengths to sum up WAM as it stands at present is partly to delve into the subject of personal bias.

I clearly have a bias in favor of the sort of worldview WAM represents. Perhaps my sort of worldview is best characterized by what it isn't. It isn't religious fundamentalism, and it isn't anti-religious atheism. I'm biased against both of those.

By religious fundamentalism I mean the sort of "conservative" religious outlook that upholds creationism or "intelligent design," the literal inerrancy of the Bible, and a radically personal or individual style of faith that de-emphasizes collective reason and ecclesiastical teaching authority. I'm afraid I have to be upfront about this: I think many "evangelical" Christians are simply wrong in some of their foundational beliefs.

Richard
Dawkins'
The God
Delusion
I am equally nonplussed by the foundational beliefs of outspoken atheists like the British biologist Richard Dawkins, whose latest book I expect to read soon: The God Delusion. Dawkins is presently one of the more eloquent spokespersons for a strictly materialistic worldview which allows for nothing either supernatural or metaphysical to exist.

Inflected into the realm of questions of consciousness and the separateness of mind and body, this materialist/physicalist worldview is argued for by Daniel Dennett, the noted philosopher of mind. In the area of more abstract philosophy, it is represented by the school of thought known as positivism.

I do not mean to imply that all these anti-religious thinkers and views are in total sync. There are positions which metaphysically assert that everything that exists has a physical property, for example, which others, such as that of philosopher A.J. Ayer, claim that metaphysics per se is bunk.

Still, all seem to have in common that there is, and can be, no God, no soul, no afterlife. If there is a mind apart from matter, it in some way arises out of matter. If consciousness is not an illusion, it is merely a side effect of the workings of our physical brains.


My WAM mindset asserts exactly the opposite on all these questions. That I am prone to such a worldview reflects, I am sure, the deep-seated biases of my particular style of temperament.

Oh, WAM is (I fully believe) an outlook that is eminently reasonable to support — now that I have managed to develop a rational way of accounting for and upholding its tenets. Not that my arguments to date are conclusive, or even complete. I imagine they establish at best a sort of sketchy, prima facie case for the World According to Me. Still, I humbly suggest that WAM — God, souls, consciousness, and all — is plausible because
  1. it explains the facts at hand
  2. it does so simply and elegantly
  3. it does so without disenfranchising vast areas of human experience
1. Among the "facts" which WAM "explains" is (in addition to the customary scientific explanations of the physical world) the presence of mind-slash-consciousness, which strictly materialist outlooks have to relegate to the unexplainable and/or call an illusion. According to WAM, God has (or is) a mind — a rational mind which is reflected in our own rational, conscious minds. Existence per se is conferred by the observational activity of such minds.

2. If true, that explanation is about as simple and elegant as any could be. There is a supernatural mind — God's — behind it all. God's conscious activity creates and sustains all material existence. The material world recapitulates the mind of God in the conscious minds of creatures who evolve in it freely, albeit according to the firm laws of nature, and who themselves have free will.

3. WAM accordingly carefully avoids disenfranchising empirical science, human reason, or longstanding religious beliefs. WAM is compatible with all three.


What WAM is not compatible with is, as I say, religious fundamentalism in it various guises and atheistic materialism in its various guises. Just as I am aware that WAM, despite the rational arguments I make for it, originates in the biases of my own particular style of temperament, I assume that the fundamentalists and the materialists have their own temperament styles whose biases lead their possessors toward worldviews that differ radically from each other, and from mine.

What I would like to be able to do — but see no way to accomplish at present — is to explain why those three basic styles of temperament exist and accordingly divide us as badly as they do.

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

To Reason Is Divine

As I hinted in The Pope of Reason and The Pope and Islam, I nurture a late-blooming respect for the now-leader of my church, Pope Benedict XVI. For tutelage in his thought, I've turned to the recent writings of Catholic ethicist/author George Weigel, many shorter ones of which may be found here. One of them, "Pope Benedict XVI: The Master-Teacher," does an excellent job of laying out the Holy Father's views on the future of Europe and the Judeo-Christian West vis-à-vis the present threats from Islamic fundamentalism.

Pope Benedict
XVI's
Christianity and
the Crisis
of Cultures
In this article originally written for The Catholic Herald in the U.K., Weigel emphasizes the book which the pope published in 2006 under his birth name, Joseph Ratzinger. In Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures, which I have yet to read, the then-cardinal (per Weigel) "distils a lifetime of reflection on the relationship between faith and reason, and on the cultural consequences of a collapse of both faith and reason, into a challenge of prime importance for the entire world — but especially for Europe, in its current crisis of civilisational morale."

This pope is making quite a few pointed assertions these days about rationality and reason being part and parcel of the Christian faith. I'm inquiring into his ideas in part because I'd like to know more about what he means by reason.


Along those lines, Weigel alludes to the lecture Benedict XVI made last year at Regensburg, Germany, in which
... the Pope warned his listeners that an unreasonable faith is a real and present danger to the world — a faith, for example, in which God can be imagined capable of commanding the irrational, like the murder of innocents. But so, the Pope argued ..., is a loss of faith in reason: that, too, is a real and present danger. If, for example, the West limits the concept of "reason" to a purely instrumental rationality, or, in a fit of post-modern self-indulgence, denies the human capacity to grasp the truth of anything with certainty, then the West will be unable to defend itself. Why? Because it will be unable to give an account of its political commitments and their moral foundations, to itself, or to those who would replace the free societies of the West with a very different pattern of human community, based on a very different idea of God — and, consequently, of the just society.

The Pope seems to feel that cutting our traditional anchor line to divine reason in the Christian West could sap our ability to stave off the forces of unreason in the Muslim East. Historical trends we moderns have inherited from the Age of Enlightenment in 18th-century Europe are sawing away at that line.

Stripped to its essentials, the story seems to be that denizens of the Christian West at one time believed implicitly in "the human capacity to grasp the truth ... with certainty." Over the last two or three centuries that confidence has eroded into an attitude of skepticism toward the knowability of truth in general and of moral truth in particular. The pope would like us at least to reclaim our patrimony of truth-seeking reason ... even those of us who do not believe in God.

Weigel says the Holy Father "lays down a challenge" to religious nonbelievers today:
"In the age of the Enlightenment, the attempt was made to understand and define the essential norms of morality by saying that they would be valid etsi Deus non daretur, even if God did not exist... [Today], we must... reverse the axiom of the Enlightenment and say: Even the one who does not succeed in finding the path to accepting the existence of God ought nevertheless to try to live and to direct his life veluti si Deus daretur, as if God did indeed exist. This is the advice Pascal gave to his non-believing friends, and it is the advice I should like to give to our friends today who do not believe. This does not impose limitations on anyone's freedom; it gives support to all our human affairs and supplies a criterion of which human life stands sorely in need."

I suspect the pope believes that living a moral life based on rational principles — living "as if God did indeed exist" — might bring even agnostics under God's spell, since (as I indicated in The Pope of Reason) he feels that reason or logos lies at the very core of God's nature. "Only that creative reason which has manifested itself as love in the crucified God can truly show us what life is," Benedict has written in his book. Logos, the Greek word for creative reason, was the one selected by the evangelist for the prologue to his Gospel of John.

In future posts in this, my "Divine Reason" series, I intend to explore Pope Benedict XVI's ideas about the place of reason in Christian faith and Western thought more thoroughly.