Showing posts with label Existential Guilt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Existential Guilt. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 09, 2007

My Existential Guilt (Part Two)

In My Existential Guilt I talked about being dogged by a free-floating sense of guilt that bears only a loose relationship, if any, to my actual transgressions. Philosopher, author, and advocate of Unitarian Universalism James Park calls the phenomenon "existential guilt." His Existential Philosopher's Museum website has this page on existential guilt.

Park says:

... existential guilt will not stick to a definite violation of standards. It seems to float from one fault to another. When it does temporarily attach itself to one moral weakness, which we then correct, it takes wing and settles on another fault. Sometimes our existential guilt spreads itself over many 'sins'. ... Our existential guilt arises not from past events but from our core of being.


We tend to look to moral violations to explain our feelings of guilt, but that's a mistake. Why do we make it? "Perhaps we are reluctant to give up our moral interpretation of guilt because we lose control over the problem — and the solution."

Interestingly, during recent weeks and months as I have started to recognize how guilty and inauthentic I feel, I have also noticed how increasingly desperate I am to keep in control of everything that goes on within and around me. It's like my ever-present guilt is an acid I'm carrying around in a beaker, which is now full to the brim. I feel I have to use any method I can to keep from spilling it. So if I give my free-floating guilt a moral interpretation, then perhaps I can control it by amending my life or confessing my sins. But if moral transgressions are unrelated to the guilt — as they are with existential guilt — then I am left without recourse to one of my prime hoped-for stabilization methods.

Park:

When we treat our existential guilt as if it were conscience — by turning away from a troubling dimension of our lives — we discover that existential guilt follows us. Diversion brings no relief; it only spreads the problem. Because our existential guilt arises from within ourselves, we might attempt to escape by jumping out of our selves: We brick up the access to who we really are. We function automatically, hoping to 'quarantine' our disease. If our inner selves are consumed by guilt, we dare not dwell there. So we plunge into frantic and obsessive external activity.

I've done that from time to time. Recently, I've gone through a period of being obsessive about (I know this sounds really weird) my Apple TV. An Apple TV is a device that streams movies from iTunes to an HDTV. I bought one a couple of months ago and soon found myself getting sucked into mastering the technical details of (among other things) ripping DVDs and obtaining illicit movie content on the Internet in other ways.

And another of my obsessions is even weirder, since it is a sexual one: I get a voyeuristic charge out of the idea of women relieving themselves in public (or, for that matter, in private) and can spend days happily looking for pictures of them on the Internet — and there are many of these pictures — engaged in the act of "popping a squat" or sitting on a toilet. Park has a section on Sexology in which he promises to take up the topic of "Imprinted Sexual Fantasies." I'm looking forward to reading the book, when he gets it written, since I imagine that I somehow got imprinted with this particular sexual fantasy from an early age.

But for now my point is that my obsessive behavior in response to pervasive existential guilt can paradoxically involve morally dubious preoccupations: engaging in copyright violations, nurturing a secret (now, not-so-secret) interest in women's excretory functions, etc. It is if whatever guilt I am "supposed to feel" for transgressive behavior has been so drowned out by my free-floating existential guilt that I am now engaging in downright provocative behavior to try to revive the normal connection between behavior and guilt.

Meanwhile, I feel detached from my "true self," as if I were indeed "jumping out" of who I am by taking on the role of devil-may-care copyright violator, or secret pee voyeur, or, say, in another of the personas I have recently explored, the quintessential appreciator of life's ironies — even though the "real me" is inclined to take everything quite seriously. I find that I usually wear some kind of mask, even with my friends. The fires of my inner spontaneity are considerably damped.

Park:

As we become morally better — correcting one fault after another — we might have to invent ridiculous sins to explain our sense of guilt. Is this an attempt to transform existential guilt into moral conscience?


I think so. I'm clearly "inventing ridiculous sins" by acting them out. If I can do that, maybe my moral conscience will oust my existential guilt. Then I can deal with my pangs of moral conscience in the usual, approved ways.

Park:

Moral 'backsliding' might be caused by on/off guilt: As we climb the ladder of self-improvement, we should feel less guilty as we become better. But if we are really trying to overcome our existential guilt, becoming more perfect does not make us feel better. Thus, if we feel just as guilty near the top of the ladder, we give up — and slide all the way back to the bottom again.


That's definitely me!

Park, again:

Let a basketball represent our resilient personality-shell: The air inside is our pressurized existential guilt. The knocks and bumps of everyday life are the pangs of conscience. Little mistakes make us feel clumsy, inadequate, ashamed, inept. But usually we bounce back to shape quickly and easily.

Sometimes, however, these wounds of conscience injure us deeply, pierce thru our tough external shell, releasing our existential guilt. We might experience a gush of guilt or a devastating explosion. The explanation: We have a reservoir of pent-up existential guilt, which is sometimes released by a puncture-wound of conscience. But the tack that punctured our shell did not cause our existential guilt.


I have cleverly learned to avoid the "gush of guilt or devastating explosion" by various psychological dodges, which unfortunately have had the side effect of quashing my joie de vivre. My spontaneous inner self is factored right out of the equation, while joie de vivre depends on expressing the spontaneous self, warts and all.

So, is there hope for me?

If [our guilt] management techniques prove inadequate, we might still yearn for complete release from our existential guilt. If the pressurized guilt inside our basketball can be removed — replaced by forgiveness, atonement, joy, peace, & fulfillment — the little punctures of life will no longer release a gush of guilt.

When we understand the nature of our existential guilt, we can open ourselves to Existential Freedom. Existential Freedom removes our existential guilt, even if normal mistakes continue. Under Existential Freedom we still have pangs of conscience when we "mess up", but we no longer experience overwhelming guilt 'for' trivial reasons.


Wow! Where do I sign up?

We might have to grope our way toward freedom from existential guilt. Perhaps only after some years of struggling with this deeper guilt will we be convinced that becoming better does not cure our guilt. Then we can abandon our moral striving, surrender completely, & open ourselves to Existential Freedom — which overcomes, removes, & abolishes our existential guilt.


OK, consider me in "grope mode." But it's hard to imagine abandoning my moral striving, even now that I've begun to recognize what I'm groping toward. And exactly how do I "open myself" to existential freedom? It sounds like one of those things where you have to stop doing something that seems as natural and habitual as breathing.

Toward the end of this web page, Park asks some significant questions, including:

Have you known moments of release from existential guilt?
If so, how did you open yourself to Existential Freedom?
... what keeps you caught in existential guilt?


My answers are:

  • Yes, I have known many moments of release. In my own lexicon, I call them moments of "lassitude," but that's wrong. Lassitude is a state of mental and physical exhaustion. Here, what's exhausted and wants to retreat into its hidey-hole is my existential guilt itself. In a sort of "moral exhaustion," it simply shuts up for a while, and I feel as if God's in his heaven again.
  • It just happened, and I don't know why.
  • I don't know why I can't find the "lassitude" when I want to but can't.


More later ...

Monday, October 08, 2007

My Existential Guilt

The Taoist insight that things in our world are not fundamentally "broken" and do not need to be "fixed" was the topic of The Categorical and the Ineffable and other preceding posts in my Does Nature Need Correcting? series. Having written that last post yesterday, I woke up this morning with the powerful sense that I am suffering from a bad case of excessive guilt.

I don't mean feelings of guilt about any particular sin or sins, though I am not without those too. I mean what I think of as "free-floating guilt," guilt that bears no particular relationship to anything I have done.

Googling that phrase, "free-floating guilt," led me to The Existential Philosopher's Museum on the website of James Park, who calls the phenomenon "existential guilt." Park is an existential philosopher and author who advocates Unitarian Universalism as a religious stance.

I'm about to start investigating Park's sprawling website, but I have to admit I'm not really crazy about delving into existentialism and enlarging on what little I know about Unitarian Universalism, both of which I think of as somehow "godless." Yet I'm intrigued by Park's "Five Differences between Moral Conscience and Existential Guilt" which appear in a table about two-thirds of the way down this page.


Park says that moral conscience is remorse for particular misdeeds and omissions, while existential guilt is characteristically free-floating and non-specific. Well, I do have some specific misdeeds and omissions that I feel (some degree of) remorse for, but mostly what I feel is free-floating and non-specific guilt. So, check.

Park says that pangs of moral conscience are caused by the discrepancy between our actual behavior and our standards. In that sense, they are rationally justified. Existential guilt is uncaused and not psychologically intelligible. Check.

Moral guilt is temporary and passes with time. Existential guilt is permanent and renewed at every moment. Check.

Pangs of conscience are temporary and pass with time, says Park. I'm still feeling guilt over minor misdeeds from decades ago — even though I've "confessed" them in the prescribed manner of my faith. When Park says existential guilt "flows thru-out our selves [and is] pervasive [and] possesses our entire being," I know whereof he speaks. So, again, check.

If we suffer the strictures of moral conscience, we can, Park says, "relieve the tension by changing our behavior or standards." But existential guilt cannot be overcome in this way: "psychological techniques are useless." Yup. Check, again. I've been trying to engineer my own "reduction of tension" ever since the late 1980s, at the time when my parents died and I in mid-adulthood "got religion." (It hasn't worked.)

Specifically, the sacrament of penance in the Catholic Church — known popularly as "going to confession" — doesn't serve to reduce my tension. I expect that may be because it is not expected to have any effect on existential guilt.


Park asks, "Have you ever been
a perfectionist, driven by a deep sense of guilt that does not go away no matter how good you become?" Yes, I've been there. "Do you sometimes feel more guilty than you ought to feel?" Definitely. "Does your sense of guilt keep coming back attached to new 'reasons'?" Yes ... that, and I seem to manage to recycle old reasons that one would think had lost their sting.

Why? Why do I have this weird, senseless guilt? Why does nothing I do (or eschew doing) relieve the tension? Park says:

Human beings have been feeling guilty since before the dawn of civilization. The decline of organized religion in the West has corresponded with less interest in guilt. But at least for some people, it is still relevant to look into the deeper dimensions of the experience of guilt.


OK, then maybe the hidden agenda of this whole In Search of Solidarity blog has been, for me, an attempt to change the terms of religion so I could have my cake and eat it too: be religious, but get rid of the guilt.

In other words, I'd like religion to become, not nonexistent as atheists would prefer, but much less in the guilt-provoking vein ... simply because I myself have a boatload of existential guilt weighing me down at all times and I don't need to take on any additional guilt from the teachings of my church.


In view of the above, I believe I have been putting myself in an ever-tighter moral straitjacket over the course of the past several years. It is as if I have been trying to "cure" my existential guilt by ratcheting up punctiliousness. In making this attempt, all I have succeeded in doing is getting less natural and spontaneous — becoming less "refreshing," to repeat a word one of my friends used of me several decades ago.

I am no longer refreshing, and I rarely feel refreshed.

In recent posts to this blog (the Confessions series) I have admitted to being a closet prig and prude, while confessing to feeling "inauthentic" about it all. Inauthenticity is one of the characteristics Park speaks of as the lot of the existentially guilt-ridden, as a quick scan of his site reveals.

In other recent posts in my Does Nature Need Correcting? series, I have sidled up to a Taoist perspective in which there is no ground whatsoever for guilt. Guilt has no part in a philosophical system in which the whole object is to cultivate spontaneity and naturalness ... as if the only thing we can do wrong is not be spontaneous and natural.

I think the hidden agenda of my Taoism interest is my (formerly unconscious, now conscious) hope to cure my existential guilt.


One of the upshots of discovering that I suffer from existential guilt is that it renders suspect everything I have ever said in this blog, as well as in my other blogs, about religion, morality, and related matters.

It is as if I have held myself out to be an insightful art critic and then discovered to my supreme embarrassment that I have been color blind all these years. Or a music critic who can't, and never could, hear musical overtones.

Without quite realizing it, I have been carrying around a massive load of existential guilt for a very long time now. Because it makes no sense on the face of it to even believe a person can have such free-floating, unmotivated guilt, I haven't been able to put a name to it. Lacking the ability to name it, I simply assumed it wasn't there.

But it was, and is. I has been a bit like a dark star around which a visible star revolves. The position in the sky of the visible star is apt to wobble, as its brightness waxes and wanes. Translate that analogy into the realm of religion and morality, and you can see that my supposedly rock-steady pronouncements need to be taken, now, with a whole shaker of salt.

For my hidden (from myself) agenda has always been to say and make myself believe things that can help me shoulder my heavy load of existential guilt. So when I have dissed "conservative" religious outlooks which, as their theological starting point, emphasize how sinful we are in God's eyes — Christian fundamentalists/evangelicals, mainline churches as the Lutherans, and also my own church mates the "conservative" Catholics — I obviously can't be trusted to be objective.

There may be a valid case to be made that theologies of sin and guilt are simply incorrect and un-biblical, such as the argument set forth recently in a book by Garry Wills (see What Paul Meant). But I am clearly not the best judge: I want Wills to be right so very badly, simply because it might help cure my existential guilt. Ergo, I can't be trusted to pass evenhanded judgment on Wills' ideas.

In fact, I now realize my capacity for making moral judgments is generally out of whack, for the exact same reason. I simply don't have the ability to make consistent moral choices. I find myself trying to exorcise the tiniest lingering blemishes in my own personal behavior while excusing in the behavior of other people what many Christians call grievous sin — as if waving off someone else's major transgressions will somehow lessen my own existential guilt.

So I'm all over the map on sin and Christian morality. I'm a closet prig and a prude, while at the same time I'm tolerant of gays' and lesbians' right to act naturally and spontaneously according to their inmost natures.

I'll continue to explore the ramifications of my existential guilt in future posts ...